Step into Capt Tony’s Saloon and you step straight into the unruly soul of Key West. This landmark bar feels like a living scrapbook, where smoky air, raucous music, and wild stories cling to every wall.
You will spot dangling bras, scrawled dollar bills, and a tree with a ghostly past, all while a singer belts classics a few feet away. If you crave a bar with grit, history, and irresistible weirdness, this place has your name on a stool.
TrendingNow
The Original Sloppy Joe’s Legacy
Locals will tell you the legend proudly: this is the original Sloppy Joe’s building, long before the neon glow two doors down. You feel it in the floorboards and the creak of the barstools, like echoes of bootsteps from another era.
Order a cold beer and let the bartender spin the tale while music rolls.
Every corner hints at Hemingway, rum-soaked nights, and friendships forged over salty laughter. You can almost picture the cigar smoke, the hustlers, and Key West’s scrappy resilience.
It is not a museum, though. It is a working saloon where history and happy hour share the same bar rail.
The Hanging Tree And The Haunted Past
Right inside, a massive tree punches through the roof, roots in legend and branches in lore. Stories whisper about lynchings and restless spirits, the kind that make your neck prickle when the room hushes.
You will hear about bottles once filled with holy water tucked into walls, a talisman against whatever lingers.
Step closer, read the plaques, and feel the bar grow quiet around that trunk. Whether you believe or not, the mood changes, like the air cools a notch.
Order a Pirate Punch, lean in, and let the bartender share the eerie parts. It is Key West’s darkness, poured neat.
Dollar Bills And Bra-Covered Ceiling
Look up and the ceiling tells you everything: thousands of signed dollar bills, bras, patches, and travel scars from decades of wanderers. You add your own crumpled bill and suddenly feel inducted into a rowdy, international club.
It is messy, charming, and totally Capt Tony’s.
There is no curated perfection here, just real memories stapled to wood. You will spot names, wedding dates, even inside jokes that survived hangovers.
Snap a photo, then tuck your marker away. The ritual is part donation, part declaration that you were here, you drank, you laughed, and the saloon swallowed your story whole.
Flip The Quarter Into The Fish’s Mouth
Outside, a grouper sign waits with a dare: flip a quarter backward over your shoulder into the fish’s mouth. Easy, right?
Try it with a crowd watching and a tropical breeze nudging your aim astray. You will laugh, miss, try again, and suddenly feel like part of the sidewalk show.
When someone sinks it, the cheer snaps down Greene Street. It is small-town carnival magic mixed with island mischief.
Bring a handful of coins and a good attitude. Even if you miss, you win the memory, and that might be the best souvenir you will take home from Key West.
Live Music Every Day And Night
The stage is small but the sound fills the room, guitars cutting through conversation and ice clinks. You will hear classic rock, island covers, and the kind of sing-alongs that pull strangers shoulder to shoulder.
Bands rotate, but the vibe stays consistent: lively, unpretentious, and a little rough around the edges.
Grab a stool near the front for a breeze of AC and a front-row view. Musicians here are storytellers, slipping jokes between verses and reading the room like mind readers.
Tip them, raise your plastic cup, and shout the chorus you half remember. The saloon thrives on shared songs and hoarse voices.
The Drinks: Pirate Punch To Ice-Cold Beer
At Capt Tony’s, the menu keeps it simple and fun. Pirate Punch is the island sweetheart, bright and refreshing without tipping into syrupy sweet.
You will see locals with bottles of beer sweating in the heat, and nobody is ordering fancy martinis here.
Prices are fair for the neighborhood, especially with the history tax baked into the walls. Order fast, pay cash or card, and tip well when the band is cooking.
Plastic cups rule the room so you can dance and roam. It fits the dive-bar ethos perfectly: practical, unfussy, and totally about your good time.
Hemingway, Buffett, And Celebrity Stools
Look closely at the barstools and plaques and you will spot familiar names. Regulars get immortalized, and legends like Hemingway and Jimmy Buffett float through the stories like friendly ghosts.
It is not about velvet ropes, though. It is about earning your seat the old fashioned way, visit after visit.
Ask a bartender about the stools and you will get an education on Keys lore. Maybe you will even sit where a songwriter once sketched a lyric on a napkin.
Snap a photo and sip slow. In here, famous and anonymous blur together under the same low lights.
Graves In The Floor And Stories In The Walls
Few bars can say there are headstones underfoot, yet Capt Tony’s wears that macabre detail like a badge. You will notice a marker near the pool room and feel an odd pause mid-laugh.
It is strange, respectful, and undeniably part of the saloon’s mystique.
Ask kindly and staff will point out the details without turning it into a circus. The building has lived many lives, and some of those lives left names behind.
Take a moment, then toast the ones who came before. This is Key West, after all, where history and happy chaos share the same floorboards.
How To Visit: Hours, Crowd, And Comfort
Doors swing open by late morning and the party lingers past midnight almost every day. Daytime brings photo hunters and history buffs, while nights pack in music lovers and bar-crawl crews.
If you like room to breathe, slide in early. For a loud, sweaty sing-along, come after dark.
Expect smoke in the air sometimes, AC pockets up front, and bathrooms that match dive-bar expectations. Bring cash for tips and quarters for the fish.
Dress light, smile often, and set your bar for friendliness rather than polish. You will leave grinning either way.
Why It Remains Key West’s Weirdest Stop
Weird here is a compliment, a cocktail of haunted roots, dive-bar grit, and joyful noise. You will walk in for the legend and stay because the place refuses to be anything but itself.
No slick gimmicks, no sterile makeover, just stubborn character.
By the time you scrawl your name on a dollar and lose a quarter to the grouper, you are converted. The music will chase you onto Greene Street and into the night.
And tomorrow, you will tell someone else to go. That is how a landmark stays alive: story by story, song by song, round by round.
Discussion about this post