If you crave a burger where the edges crackle like a potato chip, you are in the right place. Feltner Brothers in Fayetteville takes smashburgers to the brink, pressing patties so thin the lacey crust becomes pure flavor.
The counter-serve vibe keeps things fast and friendly while the menu leans into nostalgic comfort with modern twists. Come hungry, leave convinced you found your new go-to in NWA.
TrendingNow
The Classic Smash Experience
Walk up to the counter and you can hear the sizzle before you even order. Feltner Brothers smashes quarter-pound patties until the edges frill into a salty, crunchy halo that you can taste in every bite.
That thin crust locks in beefy juices, so the center stays tender while the outer ring crackles.
Add American cheese, crisp lettuce, pickles, and a swipe of house sauce, and you have a burger that feels both familiar and surprisingly bold. It is messy in the best way, with flavor that lingers.
Pair it with fries, grab a booth under the playful decor, and watch orders fly by fast.
Hometown Burger With Pimento Cheese
This local favorite leans Southern with a generous scoop of pimento cheese melting into the crispy-edged patty. The spread pools into every crevice, giving each bite a tangy, peppery richness that plays perfectly with the crunch.
Add a fried green tomato for extra snap and a wink of acidity.
You will want napkins, because the pimento softens and mingles with the juices in glorious fashion. It is indulgent yet balanced, especially when the bun is toasted just right.
If you are curious about Fayetteville flavor, start here. You might never order another topping again once that warm, cheesy bite hits.
Mushroom Swiss Done Right
When the craving hits for umami, this is the move. The mushrooms arrive sautéed and deeply browned, bringing a woodsy savor that complements the thin, crunchy-edged patty.
Swiss cheese drapes over everything, melting into the nooks so each bite delivers earthy, buttery comfort.
It is a particular kind of cozy that still keeps its edge, thanks to that smash crust and toasty bun. A little mayo or house sauce adds sheen without overpowering the mushrooms.
Grab fries on the side if you want to keep it classic, or go wilder with chili cheese. Either way, this is a dependable favorite that feels like a hug.
Chili Burger Glory
There is a reason chili keeps popping up in local praise. Feltner Brothers ladles it hot over a crispy-edged patty, letting the beefy sauce seep into cheese and bun.
It is saucy and satisfying, the kind of burger that requires a sturdy grip and zero apologies.
The chili is savory with a gentle kick, not so spicy that it steals the show. It lets the smashed patty’s crust sing through the richness.
Add onions if you want extra bite, or go all-in with chili fries alongside. When you are craving serious comfort, this chili burger hits like a cozy weekend afternoon.
Chicago Dog At The Burger Counter
Yes, you come here for burgers, but the Chicago dog earns a spot in your order. It is bright, snappy, and loaded with the poppy seed bun, neon relish, sport peppers, tomato, onion, pickle spear, and celery salt.
The flavors slice through richness and reset your palate.
Grab this when you want variety without leaving the Feltner groove. The counter-serve speed means it lands fast, fresh, and photo-ready.
Take a bite between burger halves and you will appreciate how the acidity and crunch wake up your tastebuds. It is a road-trip classic served Arkansas-style with local warmth.
Onion Rings And The Perfect Crunch
When reviews keep mentioning onion rings, pay attention. These arrive golden and shattering, with sweet onion inside and a batter that stays crisp to the last ring.
Dip them in ranch or the house sauce, then chase with a sip of soda or a shake.
They are a perfect textural foil to the lacy burger edges, doubling down on crunch without feeling heavy. Order a basket for the table and they will disappear fast.
If you want a little heat, add pepper flakes or ask for a spicy dip. You will wonder why more places cannot keep them this snappy.
Fried Green Tomatoes, Side Or Topping
Fried green tomatoes show up as a side and a brilliant burger add-on. They bring a tart pop and sturdy crunch that holds under sauce and heat.
When paired with pimento cheese on a smash patty, they become a Southern power combo you will crave again.
On their own, they are light enough to snack without feeling weighed down. Squeeze a little lemon or dab some house sauce for contrast.
They also travel well for curbside pickup, keeping their crisp better than most sides. If you want to taste Fayetteville through one bite, this is the crispy, tangy way in.
Fries, Sweet Potato Fries, And Chili Cheese
Regular fries come hot, salted just right, and perfect for scooping runaway burger bits. Sweet potato fries add a caramelized edge and pair beautifully with ranch or cinnamon sugar.
When chili cheese enters the chat, you get a hearty pile that eats like a meal.
Do not overthink the order. Grab the combo, then add chili cheese for sharing.
The portions are generous without drifting into overkill, which is ideal alongside a crispy-edged patty. If you are taking it to go, ask for vents on the box so the fries keep their snap.
You will appreciate the attention to detail.
Shakes, Floats, And Old-School Vibes
Cap things off with a shake that tastes like a soda fountain memory. Vanilla, chocolate, maybe a seasonal twist, all blended thick enough to challenge the straw.
Floats fizz with creamy sweetness, washing down the savory rush from those crispy burger edges.
The music, the counter service, the steady hum of locals and students, it all adds to the charm. Prices sit comfortably in the $$ zone, so dessert never feels like a splurge.
Take it to the patio when the weather is kind. You will find yourself nodding along to the vibe while plotting your next visit.
Fast, Friendly, Consistent Service
Even when the parking lot is packed, orders come out quickly and with a smile. The team keeps lines moving, checks on tables, and handles curbside pickup smoothly.
Online ordering is painless, and the food stays hot and intact when you roll up.
Hours are steady from 11 AM to 9 PM daily, so lunch and dinner are covered. It is the kind of consistency that builds trust and turns first-timers into regulars.
When you want a sure thing in Fayetteville, Feltner Brothers delivers. Call ahead at +1 479-935-4545 or hit the website if you prefer to plan it out.
Discussion about this post