Tucked away at 105-29 Metropolitan Ave in Flushing, NY, Eddie’s Sweet Shop is one of those rare places that makes you feel like you’ve stepped back in time the moment you walk through the door. First opening its doors in 1925, this beloved neighborhood gem has been serving up homemade ice cream, massive sundaes, and classic soda fountain treats for nearly a century.
With a 4.4-star rating from over 1,700 happy customers, it’s clear that Eddie’s has earned its spot as one of New York’s most cherished sweet shops. Whether you’re a lifelong local or a first-time visitor, here’s everything that makes Eddie’s Sweet Shop so wonderfully special.
A Century of Sweet History
Some places are just buildings, but Eddie’s Sweet Shop is a living piece of New York history. Originally opened in 1925, this Forest Hills-area gem has been scooping homemade ice cream for nearly 100 years, making it one of the oldest ice cream parlors in all of New York City.
It’s been operating under the name Eddie’s Sweet Shop since the 1960s, and somehow, it still manages to feel exactly the way it did back then. The marble counter, the wooden booths, and the clinking sundae glasses haven’t changed much at all.
Walking through the door feels less like visiting a shop and more like flipping through an old family photo album. Generations of Queens families have made memories here, and that deep-rooted community love is something no chain ice cream brand could ever replicate.
History has never tasted so good.
Homemade Ice Cream Made the Right Way
The moment you take your first bite at Eddie’s, you’ll notice something is different. The ice cream here is made in-house, and that homemade quality shows in every single scoop.
It’s rich, creamy, and packed with real flavor in a way that store-bought pints simply can’t compete with.
Popular flavors like coffee, coffee chip, maple walnut, and cherry vanilla keep regulars coming back again and again. Even something as simple as a scoop of vanilla feels elevated because the care and craftsmanship behind it are so obvious.
One longtime customer put it perfectly: “No place compares.” That kind of loyalty doesn’t happen by accident. It’s built over decades of consistently delivering ice cream that tastes the way it’s supposed to taste.
If you’ve ever wondered what ice cream was like before everything became overly processed, Eddie’s is your delicious answer.
Massive Sundaes That Are Almost Too Good to Finish
Ask anyone who’s been to Eddie’s, and they’ll probably mention the sundaes first. These aren’t your average two-scoop-with-a-drizzle deals.
Eddie’s sundaes are legendary for their sheer size and over-the-top deliciousness, piled high with homemade ice cream, toppings, and that famous fresh whipped cream.
One customer came in for a banana split and described it as “HUGE and hard to finish” — but managed to clean the bowl anyway, because how could you not? The hot fudge sundae, in particular, gets rave reviews from first-timers and regulars alike.
Each sundae is made with genuine care and attention, never rushed. The staff takes their time to build every order correctly, which means you might wait a few minutes longer than at a fast-food chain — but the result is absolutely worth every second.
Great things, after all, should never be hurried.
Fresh Whipped Cream That Changes Everything
There’s whipped cream from a can, and then there’s Eddie’s whipped cream. Made fresh in-house, this topping alone is enough to convince skeptics that homemade really does make all the difference.
Even customers who claim they don’t normally like whipped cream find themselves completely won over at Eddie’s.
It’s light, fluffy, and just sweet enough without being overwhelming. When it lands on top of a hot fudge sundae or a banana split, it creates a contrast of temperatures and textures that’s genuinely hard to describe without sounding dramatic about dessert.
Multiple reviews specifically call out the whipped cream as a highlight, which says a lot when the ice cream itself is already this good. It’s one of those small details that shows how much pride Eddie’s takes in doing things right.
Fresh, real, and made with care — that’s the Eddie’s way.
The Old-School Soda Fountain Atmosphere
Before Instagram-worthy dessert bars and neon-lit soft-serve shops became trendy, there was Eddie’s. The interior of this sweet shop looks almost exactly the way it did when it first opened, complete with a marble counter, old-fashioned stools, wooden booths, and the satisfying clink of glass sundae dishes.
Customers consistently describe the experience as “stepping back in time,” and that’s no exaggeration. The vintage charm isn’t manufactured or staged for photos — it’s simply what Eddie’s has always looked like, and that authenticity is magnetic.
One reviewer who held their engagement photo shoot here said the shop’s backdrop was “nothing short of magical.” Whether you’re there for dessert or just soaking in the atmosphere, the space itself feels like a warm hug from a different era. In a city that’s constantly tearing things down and rebuilding, Eddie’s stands beautifully, stubbornly unchanged.
Banana Splits Worth Every Single Calorie
If you only order one thing at Eddie’s, plenty of regulars would tell you to make it the banana split. This classic dessert is served in the most generous, old-fashioned way possible — a full banana, multiple scoops of homemade ice cream, your choice of sauces, fresh whipped cream, and a cherry perched right on top.
One customer who visited on a Saturday night described their banana split as “HUGE and hard to finish” before immediately adding they’ll definitely be back and bringing their son next time. That’s the kind of review that says more than any five-star rating could.
Banana splits feel like they were invented for a place exactly like Eddie’s. There’s something wonderfully theatrical about the whole production — the long dish, the layered toppings, the dramatic size.
It’s a dessert that demands your full attention, and at Eddie’s, it fully deserves it.
Milkshakes and Floats That Hit the Spot
Eddie’s isn’t just about sundaes — the milkshakes and floats here have their own devoted fan base. The strawberry ice cream shake and the chocolate-coffee combo have both earned glowing praise from visitors who describe the flavors as “absolutely divine” and the textures as perfectly creamy.
The orange freeze is another crowd favorite, offering a refreshing, fruity twist that works especially well on a warm New York afternoon. And if you’re a classic soda float person, Eddie’s does those right too, though a recent review did note some inconsistency in preparation on a repeat visit.
What makes these drinks stand out is the same thing that makes everything at Eddie’s special: they start with homemade ice cream. When your base ingredient is this good, everything built around it naturally tastes better.
Order one, sit at the counter, and enjoy the experience slowly. You’ve earned it.
Warm, Welcoming Staff Who Make You Feel at Home
Great ice cream is one thing, but the people who serve it make all the difference. At Eddie’s, the staff are consistently praised for being friendly, attentive, and genuinely kind — the kind of team that makes you feel like a regular even on your very first visit.
One customer joked with their waitress that the food was horrible and they’d never return, and the easy-going banter that followed just added to the charm. Another visitor noted that when they held their son’s first birthday party at Eddie’s, the staff went “above and beyond” to make everything easy and stress-free.
Even a Girl Scout troop that showed up was welcomed with full enthusiasm and great service. That level of warmth isn’t something you can train into people overnight — it comes from a team that genuinely loves what they do and where they work.
Eddie’s staff are simply the real deal.
A Perfect Spot for Birthday Parties and Special Events
Not every birthday party needs a bouncy castle or a rented venue. Sometimes, the most memorable celebrations happen over a table full of towering sundaes at a 100-year-old ice cream parlor.
Eddie’s Sweet Shop has become a go-to spot for families looking for a unique and genuinely fun party experience.
One parent described hosting their son’s first birthday here as “exceptional,” adding that the shop went above and beyond to make the day easy, stress-free, and full of fun. The old-world charm of the space gives any celebration an instant personality that modern party venues just can’t fake.
From birthday milestones to casual get-togethers, the intimate, warmly lit booths and attentive staff create the kind of environment where real memories get made. If you’re planning something special in the Queens area, Eddie’s deserves a serious spot on your shortlist.
Call ahead at +1 718-520-8514 to make arrangements.
Hot Chocolate and Other Sweet Treats Beyond Ice Cream
Eddie’s Sweet Shop is ice cream royalty, but the menu doesn’t stop there. Hot chocolate, candy, and other sweet treats round out the offerings, making this a destination for anyone with a serious sweet tooth regardless of the season or their mood that day.
One enthusiastic customer summed it up beautifully: “There is literally nothing that you can order that isn’t magnificent.” That kind of blanket confidence in a menu is rare, but at Eddie’s, it feels completely earned. The hot chocolate, in particular, gets mentions alongside the ice cream as a must-try.
Keep in mind that Eddie’s is a dessert-only spot — there’s no savory food on the menu. But when everything sweet they serve is made with this level of care and quality, who needs anything else?
Come hungry for sugar, sit back, and let Eddie’s take care of the rest. You will not be disappointed.
Opening Hours and What to Know Before You Visit
Planning a trip to Eddie’s requires a little bit of advance thought, because this shop keeps its own schedule. Eddie’s is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, and opens at 3 PM Wednesday through Sunday.
On Fridays and Saturdays, it stays open until 11 PM, while the rest of the week wraps up at 10 PM.
That afternoon opening time makes Eddie’s a natural after-school or post-dinner destination, especially on weekends when the shop buzzes with energy. Expect it to get busy, particularly on Saturday nights when the banana splits and sundaes are flying out of the kitchen.
One important tip from seasoned visitors: bring cash. Eddie’s is a no-frills classic, and cash is preferred.
Also, don’t rush. The staff takes pride in making each order correctly, so settle in, enjoy the atmosphere, and treat the visit like the experience it truly is.
Find them at 105-29 Metropolitan Ave, Flushing, NY 11375.
A Nostalgic Gem That Belongs on Every Queens Bucket List
Some places are popular because they’re trendy. Eddie’s Sweet Shop is popular because it’s genuinely, timelessly great.
With over 1,772 Google reviews and a 4.4-star rating, this little parlor on Metropolitan Ave has built a reputation that speaks for itself across generations of Queens residents and visitors alike.
Reviewers call it a “timeless gem,” a “neighborhood staple,” and even a place that “should be a historical landmark.” One customer who has been visiting since age five described it simply as a place where “no place compares” — and they’ve had a century of ice cream to compare it against.
Whether you’re a lifelong New Yorker or just passing through Queens for the day, Eddie’s belongs on your list. It’s not just about the ice cream — it’s about connecting with a piece of the city’s soul.
Some traditions are worth protecting, and Eddie’s is absolutely one of them.
Engagement Photos, Date Nights, and Unforgettable Moments
Eddie’s Sweet Shop has a way of turning ordinary visits into something genuinely memorable. The vintage decor, the cozy booths, and the warm atmosphere create a backdrop that feels almost cinematic — which is exactly why one couple chose Eddie’s as the setting for their engagement photo shoot.
The owner and staff welcomed them with open arms, going out of their way to make the experience comfortable and special. The resulting photos, set against marble counters and old-fashioned wooden booths, looked like something out of a mid-century love story.
But you don’t need a camera crew to feel the magic here. A first date over shared sundaes, a family outing with grandparents and grandkids, or even a solo visit after a long week — Eddie’s has a way of making every occasion feel just a little more meaningful.
That’s the quiet power of a place that truly cares about its guests.