Tucked along Ohio Route 557 in Millersburg, Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery is the kind of place that makes you want to slow down and stay a while. Run by Amish folk with a deep pride in their craft, this charming spot offers everything from fresh-baked pies and handmade goods to a lively petting zoo filled with animals of all shapes and sizes.
Families, couples, and curious travelers keep coming back year after year, and it’s easy to see why. Whether you’re grabbing a warm cinnamon roll or hand-feeding a baby goat, every moment here feels like a small, happy memory in the making.
The Amish Bakery Counter and Its Irresistible Treats
Walking up to the bakery counter at Hershberger’s feels like stepping into your grandmother’s kitchen on the best possible day. The smell alone is enough to stop you in your tracks.
Cinnamon rolls, peanut butter donuts, and golden hand pies line the display in a way that makes choosing just one feel almost impossible.
Reviewers rave about the strawberry-rhubarb hand pie, calling it so good they could have eaten two. Most bakery treats are priced around just one dollar, making it easy to grab a little of everything without breaking the bank.
The Amish bakers here put real care into every item they produce, and that dedication shows in every bite. Whether you’re a pie person or a donut devotee, the bakery counter is absolutely the first stop you should make when you arrive at the farm.
Petting Zoo Packed with Personality
Few things in life match the pure joy of a baby goat trotting straight toward you looking for a snack. At Hershberger’s petting zoo, that moment happens all day long.
The animals here are healthy, well cared for, and clearly used to friendly visitors of all ages.
Families with young kids especially love this area. You can pet bunnies, feed goats, hold ducks, and wander through a space that is surprisingly clean and well organized for a working farm setting.
Multiple reviewers specifically called out how orderly and safe the whole experience felt.
The petting zoo has expanded over the years and has become one of the biggest reasons people make the trip out to Holmes County. Even visitors without little ones find themselves lingering longer than expected, charmed by the animals and the relaxed, unhurried atmosphere of the place.
Big Ben the Giant Horse – A True Showstopper
There are farm animals, and then there is Big Ben. This enormous horse has become something of a legend at Hershberger’s, and reviewers make a point of mentioning him by name.
Standing well over the average horse height, Big Ben commands attention the moment you lay eyes on him.
One visitor described him as a 3,000-plus-pound wonder and said simply, “You must go.” That kind of enthusiasm says it all. Kids and adults alike stand at the fence wide-eyed, trying to wrap their heads around just how large this animal actually is.
Big Ben is a perfect example of what makes Hershberger’s more than just a farm market. There are genuine moments of wonder tucked into every corner of this property.
Seeing a horse that size up close is the kind of experience that sticks with you long after you’ve driven home.
Horse and Buggy Rides Through Amish Country
Climbing into a horse-drawn buggy and rolling through the rolling hills of Holmes County is one of those experiences that feels completely removed from everyday life in the best possible way. At Hershberger’s, buggy rides are a beloved highlight that visitors return for time and time again.
The drivers, like the well-loved Abe, are known for being warm, informative, and genuinely fun to ride along with. One reviewer described the driver as amazing and said the whole experience added something special to their visit.
Jasper the horse has also earned fans of his own among returning guests.
If you have never taken a buggy ride through Amish country, this is the perfect place to try it. The pace is slow, the scenery is gorgeous, and the conversation is easy.
It is the kind of simple pleasure that reminds you why slowing down is always a good idea.
Fresh Produce That Practically Glows
One reviewer put it perfectly when they said the produce smelled amazing before they even walked through the door. That is the kind of freshness you can expect at Hershberger’s.
The Amish approach to growing and selling food is meticulous, and it shows in every bin and basket on display.
Seasonal offerings rotate throughout the year, so each visit brings something new to discover. In the fall, the farm is especially stunning with pumpkins and mums arranged in eye-catching displays that practically beg to be photographed.
Summer brings fresh peaches, berries, and more.
Prices here are fair and the quality is hard to beat anywhere in the region. Whether you are stocking up for the week or just grabbing a few things to enjoy on the drive home, the produce section at Hershberger’s delivers the kind of quality that grocery stores rarely match.
Kettle Popcorn Made Over an Open Fire
Somewhere between the bakery and the animal barn, the smell of kettle popcorn made over an open fire will stop you mid-step. It is one of those small sensory details that makes a visit to Hershberger’s feel like something out of a storybook.
Old-fashioned methods, real ingredients, and a whole lot of charm.
The popcorn is made right on site the traditional way, and watching the process is almost as fun as eating the final product. It makes for a perfect snack to munch on while wandering through the market or exploring the petting zoo with the kids.
Visitors consistently mention the popcorn as one of those unexpected delights that surprised them. Sometimes the simplest things end up being the most memorable part of a trip.
A bag of freshly made kettle corn at Hershberger’s is proof that old-school cooking methods never really go out of style.
The Farm Market Loaded with Bulk Goods and Pantry Staples
Beyond the bakery and the fresh produce, Hershberger’s main market is a treasure trove of pantry staples that home cooks absolutely love. Bulk spices, handmade noodles, soup starters, and a wide variety of jams and jellies fill the shelves in a way that makes you want to restock your entire kitchen.
The selection of preserves, sauces, and specialty grocery items draws serious attention from food lovers who make the trip specifically to load up on things they cannot find at regular grocery stores. Fresh meats, local honey, and specialty candies round out the offerings nicely.
One reviewer laughed that the food market was so good they could gain weight just by walking through it. That is high praise and completely understandable.
Shopping here feels intentional and enjoyable, not rushed. Every product on the shelf reflects the same care and craftsmanship that defines everything else at Hershberger’s Farm.
Handmade Leather Goods and Wooden Toys
Tucked into a separate building on the property, the leather and woodworking shop at Hershberger’s is the kind of place where you go in for one thing and leave with three. Handcrafted leather belts, purses, and accessories sit alongside beautifully made wooden toys and home goods, all produced with impressive skill.
One reviewer went in specifically for a leather belt and walked out also carrying a purse, laughing that she had no regrets. That is pretty much the experience everyone has.
The craftsmanship is genuine and the prices reflect real value for handmade goods.
Wooden toys here make wonderful gifts, especially for kids who deserve something built to last longer than a plastic toy from a big-box store. The Amish tradition of making things by hand with quality materials comes through clearly in every item on display.
Shopping here feels like supporting something worth supporting.
The On-Site Food Truck with Locally Sourced Burgers
Not everyone arrives at Hershberger’s with a full stomach, and the on-site food truck makes sure nobody leaves hungry either. Serving up burgers made from locally sourced beef alongside breakfast options and other hot meals, this little trailer punches well above its weight in terms of flavor.
Reviewers have called the burgers awesome and noted that the food smelled incredible even when they were not planning to eat. Fresh ingredients and a relaxed outdoor setting make grabbing a meal here a genuinely enjoyable experience rather than just a quick convenience stop.
Prices are comparable to other casual food spots, but the quality feels a step above average thanks to the farm-fresh sourcing. Whether you need a full lunch or just something to tide you over between bakery samples and animal feedings, the food truck is a solid and satisfying option worth checking out during your visit.
Pumpkin Patch Rides in the Fall Season
October at Hershberger’s is something special. The trees turn brilliant shades of red and gold, the air smells like fallen leaves and fresh pie, and the pumpkin patch ride becomes one of the most popular activities on the entire property.
Families pile onto wagons and head out to pick their own pumpkins straight from the field.
Kids absolutely love the hands-on nature of it. Choosing your own pumpkin from a real patch feels entirely different from grabbing one off a grocery store shelf.
Parents love the memories it creates, and grandparents love watching the little ones scramble through the rows hunting for the perfect one.
The fall decor throughout the farm is also worth mentioning. Pumpkins are arranged in creative, beautiful displays that make the whole property feel festive and warm.
If you can only visit Hershberger’s once a year, early October might just be the absolute best time to do it.
Peach Cider Slushy and Seasonal Drinks
Nobody expects a farm market slushy to become a highlight of their day, but here we are. The peach cider slushy at Hershberger’s has earned genuine fan status among visitors who stumbled upon it by chance and ended up raving about it in their reviews.
One customer called it surprisingly good, which feels like a delightful understatement.
Seasonal drinks like this one reflect the farm’s commitment to using real, fresh ingredients in everything they offer. When the peaches are in season and the cider is cold, this drink hits differently than anything you would find at a convenience store along the highway.
Sipping a peach cider slushy while wandering through the farm on a warm afternoon is one of those simple pleasures that makes the whole trip feel worthwhile. Keep an eye out for what seasonal drinks are available during your visit because they tend to change and each one is worth trying.
Exotic Animals That Go Beyond the Usual Barn Crew
Goats on a barn roof. That is not a sentence you read every day, but at Hershberger’s it is completely normal.
The petting zoo here goes well beyond the typical chicken-and-sheep setup, featuring a rotating mix of animals that includes some genuinely surprising exotic species that catch visitors off guard in the best way.
The expanded animal area has grown significantly over the years and continues to be the feature that draws the most enthusiastic reactions from guests. Seeing unexpected animals alongside the familiar barnyard crew gives the whole experience an adventurous quality that kids find especially thrilling.
Parents appreciate that the whole area is clean, monitored, and set up thoughtfully so even very young children can participate safely. The staff keeps a close eye on things without making the environment feel overly controlled.
It strikes a balance that is genuinely hard to achieve and makes Hershberger’s petting zoo stand out from anything else in the region.
A Family-Friendly Atmosphere That Welcomes Everyone
Some places are great for kids. Some are better suited for adults.
Hershberger’s is one of those rare spots that genuinely works for everyone at the same time. Grandparents browse the market while parents chase toddlers through the petting zoo and teenagers sneak back to the bakery counter for another fry pie.
The atmosphere here is unhurried and welcoming in a way that feels organic rather than manufactured. Employees are consistently described as kind, helpful, and genuinely happy to be there.
That warmth sets a tone that carries through the entire visit from the first parking lot step to the last loaded-up grocery bag.
With a large parking lot, accessible layout, and something interesting around every corner, Hershberger’s has quietly become one of the most beloved family destinations in all of Holmes County. People with family memberships visit multiple times a year, and first-timers almost always leave already planning their return trip.