Tucked away on North Kings Highway in Myrtle Beach, AJ’s Pizza is the kind of place locals whisper about and visitors stumble upon by happy accident. With a 4.7-star rating from nearly 1,700 reviews, this small carryout and delivery shop has earned a massive reputation for serving some of the most crave-worthy pizza in all of South Carolina.
From scratch-made dough to loaded specialty pies, AJ’s proves that great pizza doesn’t need a fancy dining room to win hearts. If you’re planning a trip to Myrtle Beach, this hidden gem absolutely belongs at the top of your must-eat list.
From-Scratch Dough That Changes Everything
Some pizzas are good. AJ’s pizza is the kind you think about on the drive home.
The secret starts before any toppings are added — it’s all in the dough. Made completely from scratch, AJ’s crust has earned its own fan club among customers who grew up in pizza-obsessed cities like Chicago and New York.
Reviewers consistently describe it as light, airy, and perfectly chewy — not too hard, not too soft. One transplant from Illinois said it was possibly the best pizza she had ever eaten, and she had been searching for over a decade.
That kind of dough takes real skill and dedication. AJ’s doesn’t cut corners, and you can taste the difference in every single bite.
Fresh ingredients, real technique, and passion for the craft make this crust the foundation of something truly special.
Specialty Pizzas Worth Every Penny
Forget boring pepperoni-only menus. AJ’s Pizza brings creativity to every pie, offering specialty options that keep customers coming back just to try something new.
From the Carolina Coast to the Surf N Turf, each specialty pizza feels like a carefully thought-out recipe rather than a random topping combo.
One reviewer raved about the taco pizza on their very first night in Myrtle Beach, calling it tasty and delicious. Another couldn’t stop talking about the pickle pizza paired with ranch dressing — a combo that sounds unusual but apparently works beautifully.
Families ordering for multiple people have found that every specialty pizza they tried was a hit. Interestingly, the plain cheese pizza was the one left with the most slices.
That says a lot about how exciting and flavorful the specialty options really are at this standout local shop.
The Carolina Coast Pizza Experience
Named after the very shoreline that brings millions of visitors to Myrtle Beach each year, the Carolina Coast pizza is one of AJ’s most talked-about menu items. One reviewer arrived just as it came out of the oven and described the experience as perfectly timed and absolutely satisfying.
There’s something poetic about eating a pizza named after the coast while you’re actually visiting the coast. It feels like the full Myrtle Beach experience wrapped up in one delicious meal.
The toppings are generous, the sauce is rich, and the crust delivers that signature AJ’s chew that regulars adore.
Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a returning vacationer, ordering the Carolina Coast feels like the right move. It’s the kind of pizza that captures the spirit of the place — laid-back, bold, and genuinely satisfying from the very first slice.
Breadsticks That Deserve Their Own Spotlight
At just $4.99 for six breadsticks, AJ’s side offering punches way above its price tag. These aren’t the thin, forgettable sticks you get tossed in a bag at chain restaurants.
Customers describe them as soft, garlicky, and absolutely delicious — a worthy companion to any pizza order.
What really gets people talking is the dipping sauce portion. Unlike many places that hand you a tiny cup of marinara, AJ’s gives you a genuinely decent-sized serving.
That detail might seem small, but it shows the kind of thoughtfulness that runs through everything they do.
One loyal customer said breadsticks are now a permanent part of every order, no exceptions. Once you try them warm out of the kitchen, you’ll completely understand why.
They’re the kind of side dish that makes you rethink everything you thought you knew about breadsticks at a pizza shop.
Wings That Go Way Beyond Average
Pizza might be the headliner at AJ’s, but the wings have their own devoted following. Customers have raved about flavors like garlic parmesan, teriyaki, mild, and lemon pepper — and not a single one has come away disappointed.
These aren’t just wings thrown in a fryer; they’re seasoned with care and cooked to order.
One family ordered three different wing flavors alongside two large pizzas and declared every single item awesome. That’s the kind of consistency that builds real loyalty.
Another reviewer specifically called out the wings as delicious and said they were excited to keep trying new things on the menu.
For groups visiting Myrtle Beach, wings and pizza from AJ’s make for an easy, crowd-pleasing meal. Whether you’re feeding picky kids or adventurous adults, the wing selection gives everyone something to get genuinely excited about at the dinner table.
Carryout and Delivery Done Right
AJ’s Pizza is strictly carryout and delivery — no sit-down dining — but that setup hasn’t stopped it from becoming one of the most beloved pizza spots in Myrtle Beach. The ordering process is smooth, the staff is responsive, and the food consistently arrives in great condition.
One reviewer even noted that deliveries always show up exactly when promised, year after year.
For vacationers staying at nearby hotels and beach resorts, the delivery option is a total game-changer. Several customers mentioned that hotel staff pointed them directly to AJ’s when asked for a good local pizza recommendation.
That kind of word-of-mouth trust is earned, not bought.
Calling ahead to place your order is recommended, especially on busy Friday and Saturday nights. But even if you walk in and wait, most customers say the pizza is so worth it that the extra few minutes barely register.
Friendly Staff That Makes You Feel Welcome
Walk into AJ’s and you’re greeted like a regular, even if it’s your very first visit. Multiple reviewers have highlighted the staff as one of the biggest reasons they keep coming back.
From holding the door open to offering to carry orders out to the car, the team at AJ’s goes noticeably beyond what’s expected.
One heartwarming story came from a reviewer who was eating in her car with her son when a delivery driver noticed and brought out napkins without being asked. That kind of genuine, unprompted kindness is rare anywhere — let alone at a busy pizza shop on a Friday night.
The staff has also been praised for being patient while helping customers choose toppings, for staying friendly during peak rush hours, and for treating every customer like their business truly matters. Good food is great, but great people make it unforgettable.
Rich, Thick Sauce That Sets the Standard
Ask any serious pizza lover what separates a good pie from a great one, and the sauce almost always comes up. At AJ’s, the tomato sauce is made with the same from-scratch commitment as the dough.
Reviewers describe it as rich, thick, and deeply flavorful — not watery, not bland, not straight from a can.
One customer who drove 15 minutes from their resort specifically mentioned that the sauce was so rich and satisfying it made the entire trip worthwhile. Another lifelong pizza fan from western New York — a region famous for its pizza culture — called AJ’s the best she had ever eaten, and gave the sauce serious credit for that ranking.
When sauce, dough, and toppings all come together at this level, the result isn’t just pizza. It’s the kind of meal that rewires your expectations and makes every other slice feel a little less exciting by comparison.
Taco Pizza — A Must-Try Twist on a Classic
Not every pizza shop is brave enough to put taco-inspired toppings on a pizza crust — but AJ’s pulls it off brilliantly. The taco pizza has become one of the most frequently mentioned menu items in customer reviews, drawing in curious first-timers and converting them into instant regulars.
One reviewer tried it on their very first night in Myrtle Beach and came away totally impressed. Another customer who visited multiple times across several years always made sure to order it as part of their AJ’s experience.
That kind of repeat enthusiasm is a strong signal that this isn’t just a novelty item — it’s genuinely delicious.
If you’re the type of person who likes bold flavor combinations and isn’t afraid to try something outside the usual pizza box, the taco pizza at AJ’s is practically calling your name. Order it once and you’ll understand the obsession completely.
A Location That’s Easy to Reach from the Beach
Sitting at 5917 N Kings Hwy, AJ’s Pizza is just minutes away from many of the most popular beachfront hotels and condos along North Myrtle Beach. You don’t need to go far or fight heavy tourist traffic to get your hands on some of the best pizza in South Carolina.
Several reviewers mentioned that the drive from their resort took only about 10 to 15 minutes, and every single one said it was absolutely worth it. The location also makes AJ’s an easy delivery destination for guests staying nearby, with drivers that know the area well and arrive on schedule.
Being close to the beach doesn’t mean being overpriced or overhyped. AJ’s keeps its focus on quality and service no matter how packed the tourist season gets.
That reliability, combined with a super convenient location, makes it a go-to spot throughout the entire Myrtle Beach vacation season.
Cheesy Cheese Pizza for the True Cheese Obsessed
Sometimes you don’t need a dozen toppings — you just need cheese. A whole lot of cheese.
AJ’s Cheesy Cheese pizza was made for exactly that kind of craving, and it delivers in the most satisfying way possible. Customers who ordered it described it as loaded, gooey, and completely over-the-top in the best sense.
One reviewer who ordered multiple specialty pizzas for a group of families said the plain cheese pizza was ironically the only one with slices left over — because everyone was too busy demolishing the specialty pies. That’s a fun way of saying the specialty pizzas are incredible, but also that the Cheesy Cheese holds its own.
For kids, picky eaters, or anyone who simply believes that more cheese is always the right answer, this pizza is a reliable, crowd-pleasing choice. Add a side of those famous breadsticks and you’ve got a meal worth remembering.
Margherita Pizza Done With Local Pride
Classic doesn’t have to mean boring, and AJ’s Margherita pizza is proof of that. Made with quality ingredients and that signature from-scratch foundation, this simple pie shines because every element is handled with real care.
No shortcuts, no cheap cheese, no thin-on-flavor sauce — just a clean, honest pizza done right.
A reviewer who ordered the Margherita alongside several other pies said every single one was worth the price. For a pizza that relies so heavily on the quality of its base ingredients, that kind of praise is particularly meaningful.
It shows that AJ’s commitment to freshness runs through every item on the menu, not just the flashier specialty options.
If you grew up loving Margherita pizza or just appreciate a well-executed classic, AJ’s version will remind you why this style became iconic in the first place. Sometimes simplicity, done with pride, is the most impressive thing on the menu.
A Hidden Gem Worthy of Every Five-Star Review
With a 4.7-star rating built from nearly 1,700 reviews, AJ’s Pizza has quietly become one of the most celebrated food spots in all of Myrtle Beach. It doesn’t have a flashy sign or a big dining room.
There’s no chain backing it up or a corporate marketing budget making noise. Just a small shop, an honest menu, and food that genuinely earns its reputation.
Visitors from Pennsylvania, Illinois, New York, and beyond have all walked away saying the same thing — they’ll be back next time they’re in Myrtle Beach. That cross-country loyalty speaks volumes about what AJ’s has built over the years.
Hidden gems like this are exactly what make traveling worthwhile. When a hotel employee, a front desk clerk, or a total stranger points you toward AJ’s Pizza, take their advice without hesitation.
You won’t leave disappointed, and you’ll probably start planning your next visit before you even finish the last slice.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.