Tucked away at 1306 McGavock Pike in Nashville, Tennessee, Mitchell Delicatessen has quietly built a reputation as one of the city’s most beloved sandwich spots. With a 4.7-star rating from nearly 1,800 reviews, this bright and welcoming deli draws loyal locals and curious visitors alike.
The star of the menu? A Reuben sandwich so packed with flavor that people keep coming back just to taste it again.
Whether you’re a Nashville native or just passing through, Mitchell Deli is absolutely worth the drive.
The Legendary Reuben Sandwich
Some sandwiches are just food. The Reuben at Mitchell Delicatessen is an experience.
Stacked with savory pastrami, tangy sauerkraut, creamy dressing, and melted cheese, every bite hits a different note.
Reviewers have called it delicious, and it’s easy to see why. The balance of flavors is spot-on, with the richness of the meat perfectly cut by the sharpness of the sauerkraut.
One customer mentioned their husband ordered it for an anniversary lunch and couldn’t stop raving.
Mitchell Deli also offers a pastrami upgrade for the Reuben, making it even heartier. The bread, when fresh, ties everything together beautifully.
It’s the kind of sandwich that makes you close your eyes after the first bite and just appreciate the moment. If you only try one thing here, make it this classic.
Mitchell Deli’s Famous House-Made Bacon
Forget everything you thought you knew about bacon. At Mitchell Delicatessen, the bacon is so good that one reviewer boldly declared it worth five stars all on its own.
That’s a big statement, and somehow the deli lives up to it.
Smoked to perfection and added to sandwiches like the turkey avocado, this bacon brings a deep, rich flavor that elevates whatever it touches. The smokiness is noticeable but not overwhelming, which is the sign of truly well-made bacon.
One guest even suggested that no matter what you order at Mitchell Deli, you should just add bacon to it. That’s the kind of advice that’s hard to argue with.
Whether it’s layered into a club sandwich or tucked beside turkey and avocado, this bacon is a supporting character that constantly steals the show.
The Turkey Avocado Sandwich
Ask regulars at Mitchell Delicatessen what to order, and the Turkey Avocado comes up again and again. It’s become something of an unofficial mascot for the menu, praised by everyone from first-timers to longtime fans.
Fresh turkey, ripe avocado, smoked bacon, and a satisfying sauce come together on bread that actually complements the fillings rather than competing with them. One reviewer called it a home run, while another ranked it as their second-favorite sandwich in all of Nashville.
What makes it stand out is how light yet satisfying it feels. You won’t leave stuffed and sluggish, but you’ll feel completely content.
The sprouts tucked inside add a surprising crunch that works surprisingly well. It’s a sandwich that feels both wholesome and indulgent at the same time, which is a rare and wonderful combination worth ordering every single visit.
The Club Sandwich Done Right
Club sandwiches can be hit or miss at most places, but Mitchell Delicatessen takes the classic to a whole new level. Reviewers have called it the best club sandwich they have ever had, and that kind of praise doesn’t come easily.
The secret seems to be in the ratios. The meats, bread, and toppings are layered with care so that no single ingredient overwhelms the others.
Multiple types of ham work together in harmony, and the sourdough bread brings just the right chew and flavor to hold it all together.
One guest admitted they couldn’t stop eating even though the portion was generous. That’s the mark of a truly great sandwich — it makes you forget you’re full.
Whether you’re a club sandwich loyalist or someone trying it for the first time, Mitchell Deli’s version will reset your expectations entirely.
The Grilled Veggie Sandwich
Who says you need meat to have the best sandwich in Nashville? One devoted Mitchell Delicatessen fan declared the Grilled Veggie Sandwich their all-time favorite menu item — and they’re not even vegetarian.
That says everything.
Packed with roasted vegetables and grilled portobello mushrooms on freshly baked bread, this sandwich is filling without being heavy. The flavors are bold and earthy, and the texture contrast between the soft veggies and the crusty bread is genuinely satisfying.
Even guests who came in expecting to order something meaty have found themselves drawn back to this vegetarian option. Mitchell Deli proves that a great sandwich doesn’t need to be defined by its protein.
The Grilled Veggie is the kind of dish that changes minds and starts cravings. One bite in, and you’ll understand exactly why it tops so many favorites lists.
Artisan Bread Baked Fresh Daily
Great sandwiches start with great bread, and Mitchell Delicatessen takes that seriously. The bread here is baked fresh, and you can sometimes smell it the moment you walk in.
That kind of detail makes a difference you can taste.
Customers have specifically praised the sourdough for its perfect texture and flavor. One reviewer got a little envious watching someone else’s sandwich arrive on sourdough while they had wheat — and even then, they admitted their wheat bread was still really good.
That’s a testament to how much care goes into every loaf.
Fresh bread changes the entire sandwich experience. When the crust has the right amount of chew and the inside is soft and flavorful, it becomes more than just a vehicle for the fillings.
At Mitchell Deli, the bread is a full participant in every sandwich, and that commitment to quality shows in every single bite.
The Pastrami Sandwich Experience
Pastrami lovers in Nashville have found their spot. Mitchell Delicatessen serves up pastrami sandwiches that have earned genuine fans who return specifically for this menu item.
The meat is flavorful, well-seasoned, and generously portioned.
Multiple reviewers have praised the pastrami here, with one calling it a highlight of their entire visit. The deli keeps things classic, letting the quality of the meat speak for itself without overcomplicating the build.
For many guests, it’s the sandwich that made them fall in love with the restaurant.
It’s worth noting that standards vary — some guests with very specific deli expectations from other cities have mixed opinions. But for the majority of diners, the pastrami at Mitchell Deli hits the mark.
If you’re a fan of this classic deli staple, it’s absolutely worth ordering on your next visit to see where it lands for you.
The French Dip Sandwich
Warm, savory, and deeply satisfying — the French Dip at Mitchell Delicatessen is the kind of comfort food that makes you slow down and enjoy the moment. Reviewers have described it simply as awesome, which is often the most honest review you can get.
Tender sliced beef on a soft roll, paired with a rich dipping broth, creates a combination that feels both classic and special. It’s not a flashy sandwich, but it doesn’t need to be.
The French Dip earns its place on the menu through pure, uncomplicated deliciousness.
For anyone who wants something warm and hearty rather than cold-cut style, this is the pick. It’s the kind of sandwich that works equally well on a cold winter afternoon or a breezy Nashville spring day.
Mitchell Deli’s French Dip is proof that the classics never go out of style when they’re made with care.
House-Made Soups That Steal the Show
Sandwiches get most of the spotlight at Mitchell Delicatessen, but the soups deserve their own standing ovation. Guests who pair their sandwich with a bowl of soup consistently walk away impressed by how good the house-made options are.
One reviewer specifically called out the vegetable soup as excellent, and others have noted that the soups feel genuinely homemade — not like something poured from a can. There’s a warmth and depth to the broth that you can only get when someone actually cooks with care and good ingredients.
Pairing a bowl of soup with your sandwich turns lunch into a full, satisfying meal without breaking the bank. Mitchell Deli keeps the menu prices reasonable, making the soup-and-sandwich combo one of the best deals in East Nashville.
On a cooler day especially, that bowl of soup hits exactly the way comfort food is supposed to.
The Welcoming Atmosphere and Seating
Walking into Mitchell Delicatessen feels like stepping into a neighborhood spot that genuinely wants you to stay awhile. The interior is bright and comfortable, with more seating than most first-time visitors expect.
There’s a relaxed, unhurried energy that makes it easy to linger over your lunch.
Outside, a canopied patio offers a lovely option for dining al fresco. Guests have mentioned loving the outdoor seating, especially on pleasant Nashville days when the weather cooperates.
It adds a casual, almost European cafe vibe to the experience.
The space manages to feel both lively and laid-back at the same time. Yes, it gets busy — especially around lunchtime — but the energy is warm rather than chaotic.
For a quick solo lunch, a casual date, or a relaxed meal with friends, the atmosphere at Mitchell Deli sets just the right tone from the moment you walk through the door.
Friendly Staff and Fast Service
Even on the busiest lunch rushes, the team at Mitchell Delicatessen keeps things moving with a smile. Guest after guest has mentioned how nice and welcoming the staff are, which is the kind of detail that turns a good meal into a great memory.
Service is generally quick, though the deli gets genuinely busy during peak hours. A short wait is occasionally part of the deal, but reviewers consistently agree that the wait is worth it.
One guest noted that the deli was constantly busy and clearly a hot spot — yet still managed to deliver excellent service throughout.
There’s something refreshing about a place where the staff actually seems happy to be there. It creates a ripple effect that makes the whole experience feel warmer.
At Mitchell Deli, the people behind the counter are just as much a part of what makes it special as the food itself.
A Menu Built for Every Kind of Eater
Not everyone eats the same way, and Mitchell Delicatessen seems to know that. The menu covers a wide range of tastes and dietary preferences, from hearty meat-loaded sandwiches to satisfying vegetarian options that hold their own against anything else on the board.
The Asian Tofu sandwich surprised one reviewer so much they described the tofu as tasting like meat, with a Korean-inspired flavor combination they couldn’t get enough of. The salad bar adds another layer of flexibility for lighter appetites.
There’s even a hot breakfast bar for early birds who show up when doors open at 8 AM.
Whether you’re a dedicated carnivore, a vegetarian, or somewhere in between, there’s something here that will click for you. That kind of inclusive menu is rare in a deli setting, and it’s one of the reasons Mitchell Delicatessen keeps drawing such a loyal and diverse crowd of regulars.
Why Mitchell Delicatessen Is Worth the Drive
Some restaurants are convenient. Mitchell Delicatessen is worth going out of your way for.
Sitting at 1306 McGavock Pike in the East Nashville neighborhood, it’s earned a 4.7-star rating from nearly 1,800 reviewers — a number that tells a story all on its own.
The combination of freshly baked bread, generous portions, creative sandwich builds, and genuinely warm service creates an experience that sticks with you long after the last bite. People who visit once tend to become regulars.
People who move away still talk about it.
Open Tuesday through Monday from 8 AM to 4 PM (closed Fridays), Mitchell Deli fits into a morning, brunch, or lunch outing without any trouble. Parking can be tight, but there’s an overflow lot nearby.
Call ahead at 615-262-9862 or check out mitchelldeli.com to plan your visit. Trust the reviews — this one truly delivers.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.