Tucked along South Avenue in Boardman, Ohio, The Amish Market is the kind of place that stops you in your tracks the moment you walk through the door. The smell alone — fresh-baked pretzels, warm donuts, and homemade bread — is enough to make anyone forget they had a plan.
With a 4.7-star rating from over 2,500 reviews, this market has earned serious bragging rights in the Mahoning Valley. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular, there’s always something new to discover here.
The Legendary Soft Pretzels
One bite is all it takes. Visitors who try the soft pretzels at The Amish Market in Boardman consistently say they’ve never tasted anything quite like them — and that’s not an exaggeration.
One reviewer noted that their spouse, who doesn’t even like pretzels, regretted not ordering a second one before leaving.
These pretzels come out hot from the oven, with a perfectly chewy inside and a golden, slightly crispy outside. At under $5 for a pretzel and a Birch Beer, it’s honestly one of the best deals around.
The pretzel station draws a crowd for good reason.
If you’re visiting for the first time, make the pretzel your very first stop. Don’t wait until you’re full from everything else — trust the crowd and grab one while it’s still warm from the oven.
Pretzel Wraps That Hit Different
Forget everything you thought you knew about stuffed bread snacks. The pretzel wraps at The Amish Market are in a completely different league.
One loyal customer put it perfectly: “Hot pockets can’t hold a candle to these things.”
Loaded with pepperoni and melted cheese inside a soft, hand-crafted pretzel shell, these wraps are hearty enough to count as a full meal. They’re made fresh, not frozen, and you can taste the difference immediately.
Customers have even been spotted requesting custom orders at the counter.
The pretzel wrap booth draws repeat visitors who plan their entire Thursday, Friday, or Saturday around getting one. Once you’ve had a fresh, warm pretzel wrap from this market, the convenience store version will never satisfy you again.
Come hungry and maybe order two — you won’t regret it.
Aunt Martha’s Donut Shop
There’s a reason there’s almost always a line at Aunt Martha’s Donut Shop inside the market — these donuts are worth every second of the wait. Multiple reviewers call them some of the best donuts they’ve ever had, and one customer admitted a dozen “accidentally” followed them home.
These aren’t your average grocery store donuts. They’re described as unique, huge, and made with the kind of care that mass-produced versions simply can’t replicate.
One reviewer confessed that donuts don’t normally tempt them — but these ones are impossible to resist.
Plan to grab at least a half-dozen, because sharing them at the office the next day is basically a community service. They also freeze surprisingly well, so stocking up is a completely reasonable life choice.
Show up early on Saturdays, as the most popular varieties tend to sell out fast.
Cora’s Cookies and the Famous Pecan Roll
Cora’s Cookies & Such is the kind of bakery booth that ruins you for every other baked good you’ll eat afterward. The pecan roll, in particular, has achieved near-legendary status among regular visitors.
One customer called it the best pecan roll they’ve ever had — full stop, no qualifiers.
What makes it so special? It’s the combination of buttery, caramel-soaked layers and perfectly toasted pecans that come together in every single bite.
The texture is rich without being heavy, and the sweetness is balanced just right. The good news is they freeze well, so buying two is not just acceptable — it’s encouraged.
Whether you’re picking up a treat for yourself or bringing something home for the family, Cora’s is a non-negotiable stop on your market tour. Don’t walk past it thinking you’ll circle back — grab one immediately.
The On-Site Restaurant With Home-Cooked Comfort Food
Some people come to The Amish Market just to shop. Others come specifically for the restaurant — and once you’ve eaten there, you’ll completely understand why.
The menu leans heavily into home-cooked comfort food, the kind that reminds you of Sunday dinners at grandma’s house.
Reviewers rave about the biscuits and gravy, calling it the best they’ve had in years. The stuffed French toast has its own dedicated fan base.
BBQ ribs are described as fall-off-the-bone tender, and the mac and cheese earns enthusiastic praise from just about everyone who orders it.
Portions are generous, prices are fair, and the service is consistently warm and friendly. Families visiting during the holidays have made it an annual tradition to stop in for breakfast.
One thing to note: eat at the restaurant first, before snacking your way through the market, or you’ll run out of room.
The Meat Market With Eight Kinds of Bacon
Eight different types of bacon. Let that sink in for a moment.
The meat market inside The Amish Market is not playing around when it comes to selection, quality, or freshness. It’s the kind of counter that makes you rethink every grocery store trip you’ve ever taken.
Beyond the bacon — though, really, eight kinds of bacon deserves its own conversation — the market carries fresh steaks, smoked meats, deli cuts, and specialty items that are hard to find anywhere else. One reviewer picked up smoked bacon and used it to make what they called the best grilled cheese sandwiches of their life.
The staff at the meat counter are knowledgeable and happy to make recommendations. Dogs reportedly love the bones from the counter, too, making this a win for the whole family.
If you’re a meat lover, budget extra time here — there’s a lot to explore.
The Bulk Food Shop
Walking through the bulk food shop at The Amish Market feels like discovering a pantry you didn’t know you needed. Floor-to-ceiling bins and jars are filled with staples that are genuinely hard to find at regular grocery stores — specialty grains, dried fruits, unique spices, and so much more.
For home cooks and health-conscious shoppers, this section is a goldmine. You can buy exactly as much or as little as you need, which cuts down on waste and saves money in the long run.
One reviewer specifically mentioned how much they appreciate being able to stock up on quality bulk items all in one place.
The variety here goes well beyond the basics. From baking ingredients to hard-to-find snack items, the bulk shop adds a whole layer of discovery to the market experience.
Bring a list, but also leave room for surprises — you will find things here you didn’t know you were looking for.
Fresh Produce and Seasonal Goods
Fresh, vibrant, and honestly priced — the produce section at The Amish Market is a welcome reminder of what fruits and vegetables are supposed to look and taste like. Shoppers regularly pick up fresh veggies alongside their baked goods and deli items, turning a market trip into a full grocery run.
Seasonal offerings rotate throughout the year, which gives regular visitors something new to look forward to every visit. The quality is noticeably higher than what you’d typically find at a big-box store, and the prices are competitive enough that you don’t feel like you’re paying a premium for it.
One reviewer summed it up simply: everything here is delicious, and prices are not any worse than a regular grocery store. Pair a bag of fresh produce with a loaf of homemade bread from the bakery, and you’re set for the week.
It’s simple, wholesome shopping done right.
Handmade Amish Furniture Store
One reviewer said it best: this furniture isn’t built to last ten years — it’s built to be passed down to your children. The Amish furniture shop inside the market carries pieces that are entirely hand-crafted, and the quality is immediately obvious the moment you lay eyes on them.
From solid wood dining tables to bedroom sets and unique accent pieces, the selection is both impressive and genuinely beautiful. These aren’t mass-produced items with a rustic label slapped on them — every joint, surface, and finish reflects real craftsmanship that takes time and skill.
Yes, the prices reflect that quality. But when you’re buying furniture that will outlast trends, decades, and possibly even you, the investment starts to make a lot of sense.
More than one visitor has joked about needing a bigger car just to take something home. The furniture section alone is worth the trip to Boardman.
Jams, Candy, and Specialty Pantry Items
Somewhere between the bakery and the bulk food shop, you’ll stumble across a stretch of booths that feels like a treasure hunt. Jams in every flavor imaginable, handmade candies, specialty sauces, and pantry items that make genuinely thoughtful gifts — or just excellent additions to your own kitchen shelves.
The homemade jams are a particular highlight. Spread on a slice of fresh Amish bread, they’re the kind of simple combination that reminds you food doesn’t need to be complicated to be extraordinary.
Many of the specialty items here are made using traditional recipes you simply won’t find on supermarket shelves.
Shoppers who love to cook or bake will find plenty of inspiration in this section. Stock up on a few jars to take home and share — they make great gifts that feel personal without requiring much effort.
Just be prepared to explain why you didn’t bring more when people inevitably ask for another jar.
The BBQ Booth in the Back
Hidden toward the back of the market, the BBQ booth is the kind of find that makes you feel like you’ve discovered a secret. Reviewers who’ve eaten there describe ribs that fall clean off the bone and chicken tenders that are genuinely moist and tender — not the dry, rubbery kind you dread at other spots.
The mac and cheese gets its own fan mail in the reviews. Rich, creamy, and made with real care, it’s the kind of side dish that could easily become the main event.
The portions are generous enough that most people leave completely satisfied — sometimes too full to try anything else from the market.
If you’re planning to eat a full meal at the market, the BBQ booth is a strong contender for your lunch stop. Arrive with an appetite, order more than you think you need, and settle in at one of the market’s seating areas to enjoy it properly.
Deli Counter With Lunch Meats and Cheese
Regular visitors to The Amish Market will tell you the deli counter is one of the most underrated stops in the entire building. One reviewer called it flat-out the best place to get lunch meats — and with the quality on display, it’s easy to see why that reputation has stuck.
The selection covers everything from classic sandwich meats to specialty sliced cheeses that you’d struggle to find at a typical grocery store. Everything is cut fresh to order, which makes a noticeable difference in both flavor and texture compared to pre-packaged deli options.
Whether you’re building a charcuterie board for a weekend gathering or just stocking up for the week’s lunches, the deli counter delivers. Pair your selections with a fresh loaf from the bakery and one of the homemade jams from the specialty booth, and you’ve got a meal that feels far fancier than the effort involved.
Market Hours, Location, and What to Know Before You Go
Planning your visit to The Amish Market takes a little preparation, because this place keeps a schedule that’s different from your typical grocery store. The market is open Thursday and Friday from 9 AM to 6 PM, and Saturday from 8 AM to 4 PM.
It’s closed Sunday through Wednesday, so mark your calendar accordingly.
Located at 6121 South Avenue in Boardman, Ohio, the market has plenty of parking and is accessible for shoppers who have trouble walking long distances — there are plenty of spots to rest throughout the building. Shopping carts are available, which is genuinely helpful once you start loading up on everything you didn’t plan to buy.
Each vendor inside operates as its own separate booth, so you’ll check out at each one individually. Bring cash just in case, and give yourself at least two to three hours to do the market justice.
You can reach them at 330-248-9933 or visit theamishmarket.net before heading out.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.