Tucked away on Main Street in Plymouth, Connecticut, Clevelands’ Country Store is the kind of place that makes you want to slow down and stay a while. From homemade fudge and nostalgic candy to gourmet ice cream and freshly baked treats, this charming little shop is a sweet lover’s dream.
With a 4.7-star rating and hundreds of glowing reviews, it has become a beloved local treasure that keeps visitors coming back again and again.
Old-Fashioned Candy That Takes You Back in Time
Remember the candy your grandparents used to love? Clevelands’ Country Store keeps that sweet nostalgia alive with a jaw-dropping selection of old-fashioned candy that most modern shops stopped carrying years ago.
Shoppers have spotted classics like Mary Janes and Mounds bars lining the shelves, bringing back memories with every wrapper. One happy customer described it as “a blast from the past” — and that pretty much sums it up perfectly.
Whether you grew up with these treats or you’re discovering them for the first time, the candy section at Clevelands’ feels like stepping into a time machine. It’s the kind of place where you’ll want to grab a little bag and fill it up with everything in sight.
Kids and adults alike leave with big smiles and pockets full of sugary goodness.
Gourmet Ice Cream With Wildly Creative Flavors
Walk through the front door of Clevelands’ Country Store and the first thing that catches your eye is the ice cream counter — and trust us, it does not disappoint. The flavors here are anything but ordinary, with locally made scoops that push the limits of what ice cream can be.
One customer raved about a flavor called “sandbox,” a dreamy combo of vanilla, caramel swirl, and Butterfingers that sounds almost too good to be true. Another fan couldn’t stop talking about the Cookie Monster ice cream that made their visit unforgettable.
Serving sizes are generous and fairly priced, making it easy to try something new without any guilt. If you’re the kind of person who loves a little adventure in your dessert bowl, this is your spot.
Clevelands’ ice cream is worth the drive from just about anywhere in Connecticut.
Homemade Blueberry Loaf That Steals the Show
Some things in life are just better homemade — and Clevelands’ blueberry loaf is living proof. Reviewers have specifically called it out by name, which says a lot when you consider how many amazing things this store has to offer.
One visitor said the blueberry loaf was their absolute favorite part of the visit, even above the grinders and the ice cream. That is high praise coming from someone who clearly had a lot of delicious options to choose from.
The loaf is moist, packed with blueberries, and has that warm, home-baked quality you just can’t fake.
Picking up a loaf to bring home makes for a perfect gift or a personal treat to enjoy with your morning coffee. It is the kind of baked good that reminds you why homemade will always beat store-bought.
Do not leave without grabbing one.
Freeze-Dried Candy for the Adventurous Sweet Tooth
Freeze-dried candy has taken the snack world by storm, and Clevelands’ Country Store is right on trend with its own selection of these crunchy, intensely flavored treats. If you have never tried freeze-dried candy before, prepare to have your mind blown.
The texture is light and airy, almost like a candy cloud, but the flavor is concentrated and bold. Classics like Skittles and gummy bears transform into something totally different through the freeze-drying process — it is genuinely surprising how good they taste.
Customers have noted the freeze-dried candy section at Clevelands’ as one of the more fun and unexpected finds in the store. It makes a great conversation-starter snack to bring to parties or share with friends who have never tried it.
Whether you are a candy connoisseur or just curious, this is one section of the store worth exploring with an open mind and an empty stomach.
Nostalgic Fudge Made to Melt Your Heart
Few sweets carry the same warm, comforting feeling as a thick slab of homemade fudge. At Clevelands’ Country Store, fudge is not just a treat — it is a full-on experience that regulars look forward to every single visit.
Rich, creamy, and made with care, the fudge at Clevelands’ hits that perfect balance between sweet and satisfying. Multiple reviewers have mentioned the fudge as part of what makes this store feel so special and different from your average convenience shop or chain store.
Fudge also happens to make one of the best gifts you can bring someone, especially when it is clearly homemade and packed with love. Wrap a few pieces up for a friend or keep the whole block for yourself — no judgment here.
Either way, one bite of Clevelands’ fudge and you will completely understand why people make special trips just for this alone.
Novelty Candy Finds You Won’t See Anywhere Else
Clevelands’ Country Store is not shy about stocking the weird, the wacky, and the wonderfully unexpected. Among the most talked-about items are candied bugs — yes, actual edible insects coated in sugar — and a rotating selection of novelty candy that keeps curious shoppers guessing.
For kids especially, this section of the store is pure magic. It sparks that same excitement as finding something totally surprising at a fair or carnival.
Parents have noted how their children light up when they spot the unusual offerings tucked between more familiar treats.
Even if eating a candied cricket is a bridge too far for you, just browsing the novelty candy section is entertaining enough on its own. Clevelands’ clearly takes pride in curating a selection that goes beyond the basics.
It is that extra layer of fun and personality that makes this store feel genuinely one-of-a-kind in the Connecticut area.
Handmade Maple Syrup Straight From the Source
There is something deeply satisfying about maple syrup that actually tastes like it came from a real tree — not a factory. Clevelands’ Country Store carries handmade maple syrup that has earned its own fan club among regular shoppers and first-time visitors alike.
One reviewer was so excited about the maple syrup that they mentioned buying some and looking forward to trying it at home. That kind of enthusiasm says everything about the quality.
Locally sourced and crafted with attention to detail, this syrup is the real deal in every sense of the phrase.
Beyond pancakes and waffles, good maple syrup can elevate everything from roasted vegetables to salad dressings to cocktails. Picking up a bottle from Clevelands’ is a practical souvenir that you will actually use and enjoy long after your visit.
It is the kind of product that makes you rethink everything you thought you knew about syrup.
Smoked Bacon Jam That Belongs on Everything
If you have never spread bacon jam on a piece of toast, a burger, or a cracker, your life is about to change for the better. Clevelands’ Country Store stocks smoked bacon jam that has developed a loyal following among customers who cannot get enough of its rich, savory-sweet flavor.
Reviewers have specifically highlighted the bacon jam as one of the best shelf items the store carries, and it is easy to see why. The combination of smoky bacon and sweet caramelized notes creates a condiment that is nearly impossible to stop eating once you start.
It pairs beautifully with cheese boards, sandwiches, or even scrambled eggs.
Jars of this stuff make incredible gifts for the foodie in your life — or for yourself, honestly. Clevelands’ has a real talent for sourcing and creating products that feel special without being pretentious.
The bacon jam is proof that sometimes the most unexpected things end up becoming your new pantry staple.
Apple Salsa That Surprises Every Single Time
Apple salsa might sound like an unusual combination, but one taste and you will wonder why you have not been eating it your whole life. Clevelands’ Country Store carries this standout condiment, and it has already won over plenty of skeptical first-timers who walked in expecting something ordinary.
One reviewer specifically mentioned buying apple salsa and being so impressed that they planned to return. That reaction is pretty common at Clevelands’ — people come in for one thing and leave with a whole basket of discoveries they never expected to find.
The sweet and tangy flavor of apple salsa works brilliantly with chips, grilled chicken, pork, or even spooned over cream cheese as a quick appetizer. It is the kind of product that shows real creativity and a willingness to think outside the jar.
Clevelands’ shelves are full of hidden gems like this, and the apple salsa is one of the best.
Creative Jams and Specialty Spreads Galore
Clevelands’ Country Store takes its jam game seriously. The shelves are lined with creative, flavorful spreads that go way beyond basic strawberry or grape.
From unexpected fruit combinations to locally inspired flavors, there is always something new to discover on each visit.
Customers have described the jam selection as one of the highlights of the store’s shelf offerings, often picking up multiple jars at a time to stock their pantries. The quality is noticeably high — you can taste the difference between these small-batch jams and the mass-produced versions sitting in a grocery store aisle.
Pairing a jar of specialty jam with some local honey or a block of cheese makes for a fantastic homemade gift basket. Whether you are shopping for yourself or someone special, the jam section at Clevelands’ delivers that feel-good satisfaction of buying something truly crafted with care.
These are the kinds of finds that make country store shopping so rewarding.
Locally Sourced Honey Worth Every Drop
Raw, local honey is one of those products that once you try it, you can never go back to the generic stuff. Clevelands’ Country Store carries handmade honey that has earned enthusiastic praise from customers who appreciate quality ingredients and local craftsmanship.
One reviewer mentioned being genuinely excited to try the honey after spotting it on the shelves — and that kind of anticipation is a good sign. Local honey also comes with the added bonus of potentially helping with seasonal allergies, since it contains pollen from nearby plants and flowers.
Beyond the health angle, the flavor of locally sourced honey is simply richer and more complex than what you find in most supermarkets. Drizzle it over yogurt, stir it into tea, or eat it straight off the spoon — all valid choices.
Grabbing a jar from Clevelands’ is one of those small purchases that ends up making a surprisingly big difference in your everyday cooking.
Gourmet Jerky in Every Flavor You Can Imagine
Jerky lovers, this one is for you. Clevelands’ Country Store stocks an impressive range of gourmet jerky that goes far beyond the basic teriyaki or peppered varieties you see at gas stations.
The selection here is the kind that makes you want to grab one of each flavor just to compare.
Multiple reviewers have called out the jerky as one of the standout finds at Clevelands’, often mentioning it alongside the candy and ice cream as a must-try. Whether you prefer beef, turkey, or something more adventurous, there is a solid chance you will find your new favorite right here on these shelves.
Jerky also happens to be a perfect road trip snack or hiking companion, and Plymouth’s location makes Clevelands’ a great pit stop for anyone passing through the area. High-protein, flavorful, and genuinely satisfying — the jerky at this store is anything but an afterthought.
Unique Mixes and Pantry Finds That Inspire Home Cooks
Beyond the sweets and snacks, Clevelands’ Country Store is a goldmine for home cooks who love discovering new ingredients and creative pantry additions. The shelves are stocked with a rotating selection of specialty mixes, sauces, and seasonings that you simply would not find at a regular grocery store.
Customers have described the overall shelf selection as one of the best parts of visiting, often spending more time browsing than they originally planned. There is a real sense of curation here — every product feels like it was chosen with purpose rather than just thrown on a shelf to fill space.
Picking up a few unique mixes is a great way to try something new in your own kitchen without a lot of risk or expense. Clevelands’ makes it easy to bring a little bit of that country store magic home with you.
It is the kind of shopping experience that turns a quick stop into a cherished routine.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.