Tucked along Main Street in Plymouth, Connecticut, Clevelands’ Country Store is the kind of place that makes you slow down and stay a while. With a 4.7-star rating and a loyal crowd of regulars, this charming little shop has earned its reputation as a true hidden gem.
From homemade ice cream and old-fashioned candy to freshly made deli sandwiches and catered events, there is something here for everyone. Whether you are passing through or making a special trip, this country store delivers big on flavor, nostalgia, and heart.
Handcrafted Ice Cream With Wildly Creative Flavors
One scoop of the “Sandbox” flavor — a dreamy blend of vanilla, caramel swirl, and Butterfingers — is enough to make you a lifelong fan of Clevelands’ Country Store. The ice cream here is locally made, and the flavor combinations go way beyond your standard chocolate and vanilla lineup.
Customers rave about the creative offerings that you simply cannot find at a chain shop. Each scoop feels like a little adventure, crafted with care and plenty of personality.
The ice cream counter is one of the first things you notice when you walk through the door, and for good reason. Whether you prefer something classic or something totally unexpected, the staff is always happy to help you find your new favorite.
Come hungry and leave with a smile on your face.
Old-Fashioned Candy That Brings Back Memories
Remember candy you thought had disappeared forever? Clevelands’ Country Store keeps the classics alive, stocking nostalgic treats like Mary Janes that many shoppers have not spotted in years.
Walking through the candy section feels like flipping through a scrapbook of childhood snack memories.
The selection goes beyond just the old standbys. Freeze-dried candy, novelty sweets, and unique finds line the shelves, giving both kids and adults plenty of reasons to linger.
It is the kind of candy aisle that sparks genuine excitement.
Reviewers consistently call out the candy section as one of the store’s most charming features. Whether you are picking up a treat for yourself or hunting down something your grandparent used to love, this is the spot.
Just be sure to check those expiration dates and ask staff if you have any questions about freshness.
Homemade Fudge Worth Every Single Bite
Fudge lovers, take note. Clevelands’ Country Store offers homemade fudge that customers describe as rich, satisfying, and made with real ingredients you can actually taste.
There is nothing mass-produced about it, and that difference shows up in every single bite.
The texture is smooth and dense without being overly sweet, striking that perfect balance that keeps people coming back for more. Grab a slice to enjoy in the store or pick up a larger piece to bring home and share — though sharing might prove to be harder than expected.
Fudge has been a staple of country stores for generations, and Clevelands honors that tradition beautifully. Pair it with a scoop of their creative ice cream for a dessert combination that is hard to top.
It is a small indulgence that makes any visit to Plymouth feel like a special occasion.
Freshly Baked Goods Straight From The Kitchen
One bite of the homemade blueberry loaf and you will understand why reviewers cannot stop talking about it. Baked fresh in-house, the baked goods at Clevelands’ Country Store carry that warm, comforting quality that store-bought items simply cannot replicate.
It tastes like something your favorite aunt would pull out of the oven on a Sunday morning.
Beyond the blueberry loaf, the store rotates in other freshly prepared items depending on the season and what the kitchen team is inspired to make. That spontaneity is part of the charm.
You never quite know what delicious surprise might be waiting for you.
Stopping in for baked goods pairs perfectly with a cup of coffee to start your morning right. The store opens at 8 AM on weekdays, making it a genuinely appealing breakfast destination for locals and travelers passing through the Plymouth area.
Gourmet Sandwiches And Grinders Stacked High
Forget fast food — the grinders at Clevelands’ Country Store are in a completely different league. Packed high with Boar’s Head meats and made fresh to order, these sandwiches have earned serious loyalty from regulars who drive out of their way just to grab one for lunch.
The Thanksgiving sandwich is a fan favorite, loaded with warm sliced turkey breast, fluffy stuffing, and tart cranberry sauce on perfectly grilled bread. The meatball sandwich, made with homemade meatballs, is another standout that customers call the best they have ever had at the store.
The deli area sits just up a few steps from the main floor, and watching your sandwich come together is half the fun. Staff members are friendly and willing to customize orders.
If you have a wild idea for a combination, do not be shy — they are usually game to try it.
Beer-Battered Fried Chicken That Steals The Show
Juicy, crispy, and made fresh right in the store — the beer-battered chicken at Clevelands’ Country Store is the kind of dish that stops people mid-sentence. One reviewer described it as “SO juicy and flavorful,” and that enthusiasm is echoed across dozens of visits from happy customers.
Chris, one of the owner’s sons, has become something of a legend in the kitchen for his ability to pull off dishes like this with real skill and care. The fried chicken cutlets were even requested as the star of a catered first birthday party, where guests kept asking where the food came from.
Ordering something hot and freshly made at a country store feels like a rare treat, and Clevelands delivers on that promise consistently. Pair the chicken with one of their specialty sides for a lunch that far exceeds any expectations you might walk in with.
Maple Bacon Turkey Wrap That Regulars Swear By
Some menu items develop a cult following, and the maple bacon turkey wrap at Clevelands’ Country Store is absolutely one of them. Regulars describe it as “stuffed to the max” and insist that no other spot makes wraps quite like this one.
The combination of smoky bacon, savory turkey, and sweet maple is genuinely inspired.
What sets it apart is not just the ingredients but the generous portions and the care that goes into every single wrap. Nothing feels skimpy or rushed.
You get the sense that the people making your food actually want you to leave satisfied.
First-timers often order it on a recommendation and then immediately start planning their next visit. It is that kind of menu item — the one that turns a casual stop into a regular habit.
If you only try one wrap in Plymouth, make it this one without hesitation.
In-House Roasted Meats Made From Scratch
There is something deeply satisfying about roast beef that has been slow-cooked in-house rather than shipped in pre-sliced from a factory. Clevelands’ Country Store takes that extra step, and customers who have been lucky enough to try the in-house roast beef say it is some of the best they have had in years.
Chris has also been known to slow-cook pork shoulder right in the store and offer tastings to curious customers. That kind of generous, hands-on hospitality is rare and makes the whole experience feel personal rather than transactional.
The quality of the meat speaks for itself, but it is the intention behind it that really resonates. Every cut is prepared with the goal of delivering something memorable.
Whether it ends up in a sandwich, a wrap, or on a catering platter, the in-house roasted meats at Clevelands set a high bar.
Unique Jarred Goods And Specialty Pantry Items
The shelves at Clevelands’ Country Store are lined with jars and bottles that make browsing feel like a treasure hunt. Apple salsa, smoked bacon jam, flavored syrups, and creative mixes are just a few of the pantry gems waiting to be discovered.
These are the kinds of items you cannot find at a regular grocery store.
Many of the products come from local businesses, giving shoppers a chance to support the broader Connecticut food community with every purchase. Picking up a jar of something unexpected makes for a great gift or a fun addition to your own kitchen experiments.
Reviewers often mention leaving with armfuls of jarred goods after stopping in for something else entirely. The store has a real gift for stocking items that feel both useful and exciting.
Once you spot the smoked bacon jam, putting it back on the shelf becomes nearly impossible.
Candied Bugs And Novelty Snacks For The Adventurous
Not every sweet treat at Clevelands’ Country Store is for the faint of heart. For the boldly curious, the store carries candied bugs — yes, actual bugs — alongside other novelty snacks that make this place feel like part candy shop, part adventure zone.
Kids absolutely love daring each other to try them.
This playful side of the store adds a layer of fun that you would not expect from a small-town Connecticut shop. It turns a simple candy run into a story worth telling at the dinner table.
Even if you skip the bugs, the novelty selection around them is worth browsing.
Clevelands leans into the idea that shopping should be entertaining, not just functional. The mix of old-fashioned classics and wild modern novelties creates a candy section with genuine range and personality.
Bring the kids, bring your adventurous friends, and prepare to be surprised by what you find.
Catering Services That Consistently Wow A Crowd
Planning an event in Connecticut? Clevelands’ Country Store has quietly built a reputation as one of the most reliable and delicious catering options in the area.
From bridal showers to birthday parties to corporate gatherings, they have handled it all with professionalism and serious culinary skill.
Menus have included chicken piccata, eggplant parmesan, penne alla vodka, BBQ spreads, 6-foot subs, and fresh salads. Guests at these events consistently ask where the food came from, which is the highest compliment any caterer can receive.
Chris makes the planning process easy and genuinely enjoyable.
The pricing is described by multiple customers as very reasonable, especially given the quality and portion sizes involved. Delivery is available, which removes a huge logistical headache from event planning.
If you have an upcoming occasion and want food people will actually remember, Clevelands’ catering is a genuinely smart call.
Locally Sourced Products Supporting Connecticut Makers
Shopping local has never tasted this good. Clevelands’ Country Store goes out of its way to stock products from nearby Connecticut makers, giving customers a genuine connection to the regional food scene.
Every purchase of a locally sourced item supports a small producer working hard in the same community.
From artisan jams to specialty sauces and regional snacks, the selection reflects a real commitment to quality over convenience. You will also spot Moxie — the classic New England soda — sitting proudly on the shelves, a detail that loyal fans of the regional drink always appreciate finding.
This focus on local goods gives the store a character and authenticity that bigger retailers simply cannot manufacture. Browsing the shelves at Clevelands feels like getting a taste of Connecticut itself.
Whether you are a local or a visitor, picking up something made nearby is a meaningful and delicious way to shop.
A Warm, Welcoming Atmosphere That Feels Like Home
Walk into Clevelands’ Country Store and something immediately shifts. The rustic wooden shelves, the smell of fresh food, and the sound of friendly conversation create an atmosphere that feels less like a retail stop and more like visiting a place that genuinely cares about the people who come through the door.
Staff members like Brayden, Bailey, Jessica, and Bryan are called out by name in reviews for making customers feel like regulars from the very first visit. That personal touch is increasingly rare and makes every trip feel worthwhile beyond just the food.
Open seven days a week until 9 PM, the store fits easily into any schedule. Whether you pop in for a quick ice cream after dinner or spend an hour browsing the shelves and chatting with the staff, Clevelands offers something that no algorithm can replicate — genuine human warmth wrapped in a country store package.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.