Some restaurants earn a following one plate at a time, and then there are the rare few that folks will cross an entire state to reach. In a quiet Southern Illinois town, one barbecue spot has built a reputation so strong that road trips get planned around a single meal there.
The brisket alone has become the stuff of legend, drawing curious first-timers and loyal regulars back year after year. There is award-winning history here, a famous seasoning people carry home in their luggage, and a warmth that turns strangers into repeat guests.
Keep reading to learn where this place sits, how it earned its national fame, what keeps the parking lot full, and the practical details you need before you go. The story behind the smoke is every bit as good as the food.
The Town That Put Southern Illinois On The Barbecue Map
Tucked along the main east-west road through Murphysboro, Illinois, sits a barbecue spot that locals treat like a landmark. 17th Street Barbecue makes its home at 32 N 17th St, Murphysboro, IL 62966, just off the road that carries traffic through town.
The building itself sets the tone before the food ever arrives. Wooden panels line the walls, covered with barbecue-themed photos and a pig theme that regulars find charming and well done.
What makes this address special is not flash or size. It is the fact that a small-town joint managed to grab national attention and hold onto it for decades.
Murphysboro proudly wears the nickname the Barbecue Capital of Illinois, and this restaurant is a big reason why. Folks passing through Southern Illinois often make it a deliberate detour rather than a happy accident.
The place looks clean and well cared for, with the kind of setting that feels lived-in rather than staged. Newcomers and longtime fans alike find their way here for the same reason: a plate worth the drive.
The Godfather Of A Barbecue Movement
Behind the smoke and the crowds is a founder whose name carries real weight in barbecue circles. Mike Mills, a Hall of Famer, started this restaurant and helped push Southern Illinois onto the national stage.
His track record is not the ordinary kind. This team became the first from north of the Mason-Dixon line to win the Memphis in May competition, and they did it three separate times.
That accomplishment shifted how people thought about who could make championship barbecue. Winning contests that had long belonged to southern teams turned heads across the entire country.
Many consider Mills one of the founding figures of the modern barbecue movement in the United States. Serious enthusiasts talk about this place the way music fans talk about a legendary recording studio.
The awards are not hidden away, either. Staff take pride in sharing the history, the trophies, and the story of how a small-town operation earned so much recognition.
That heritage is something you can feel throughout the restaurant, woven into the walls and the conversations. It gives every plate a sense of occasion.
Brisket Worth Crossing State Lines For
Ask around about what to order, and one answer rises above the rest. The brisket here has become the single dish that inspires long drives and repeat pilgrimages.
Tender, flavorful, and carefully prepared, it earns praise from people who have eaten barbecue all over. Some describe their chopped brisket sandwich as outstanding, unable to find a single fault with it.
Part of the appeal is how clean the meat comes out. Regulars point out that the brisket is not fatty, which counts as a genuine treat for anyone who has been burned by greasy versions elsewhere.
Brisket is by far the most talked-about item on the menu, mentioned again and again by folks recounting their visits. It shares the spotlight with the ribs, but it holds its own as a headliner.
Whether ordered as a sandwich or as a plate with sides, it consistently lands as a highlight. The kitchen treats it with the patience that low-and-slow cooking demands.
For a town that already claims the barbecue crown, the brisket is the jewel in that title.
Championship Ribs With Real Pit Smoke
Right alongside the brisket, the ribs carry their own devoted following. They are, after all, the dish tied to those famous competition wins from 1990, 1992, and 1994.
The bark comes loaded with flavor from the house rub, while the meat around each bone shows a light pink hue. That color is the telltale sign of many hours spent under real smoke.
People who have been coming for decades often order nothing else, and they see no reason to change. When something reaches this level, experimenting can feel unnecessary.
The ribs pair beautifully with the restaurant’s red sauce, a combination that regulars recommend without hesitation. Smoke runs all the way through the meat, not just across the surface.
Ribs earn more mentions than almost any other item, a testament to their staying power. They are the dish that built the reputation before the trophies ever arrived.
Tender and generously portioned, they explain why this place drew crowds long before barbecue became a nationwide obsession.
Magic Dust And The Sauce Lineup
Few house creations travel as far as the seasoning here. Magic Dust has become so beloved that guests buy bottles to take home, some carrying it as far as Australia.
The rub is the backbone of the flavor, dusted over ribs and brisket to build that signature bark. Once people taste it on their food, many decide they need a bottle for their own kitchen.
Sauce lovers have options, too. Four varieties are available, including the Little Kick, the Original, the Apple City Red, and the Hog Warsh.
Servers often walk guests through the differences so they can match the right sauce to the right dish. That kind of guidance makes ordering feel like part of the experience rather than a guessing game.
The Apple City Red pairs especially well with the ribs, while the Little Kick adds a welcome touch of heat. Both the sauces and the seasoning are available online for anyone who cannot make the trip often.
Plenty of guests end up spending as much on take-home rubs, sauces, and merchandise as they do on the meal itself.
Sides And Sweets That Steal The Show
Great barbecue can carry a meal, but the supporting cast here refuses to be forgotten. The potato salad has stunned more than a few guests, with some calling it the best they have ever had.
Coleslaw earns steady praise, and the mac and cheese shows up often in the conversation. Fried pickles served with a special sauce have become a genuine fan favorite worth ordering on their own.
Then there is dessert, which nobody should skip. The bread pudding is described as incredible and worth saving room for, a fitting finish to a big plate.
Fans of fruit-forward endings can reach for the strawberry shortcake, which some prefer over the banana pudding. Speaking of which, that banana pudding arrives served in a mason jar and earns top marks.
Pimento cheese and sausage round out the lineup for those wanting to explore beyond the headliners. A sampler platter lets first-timers try several things in one sitting.
Between the sides and the sweets, the meal keeps giving right up to the last bite.
A Welcome As Warm As The Smoker
Food gets people in the door, but the hospitality is what keeps the stories going. Staff here have a reputation for being welcoming, quick with a friendly conversation, and proud of what they serve.
The owner is known to stop by tables when in the building, chatting with guests about the area and the restaurant’s history. Those small moments turn an ordinary dinner into something memorable.
Servers frequently go the extra mile, explaining the sauces and offering honest recommendations when a guest feels torn. Confidence in a suggestion, rather than a simple point at the menu, means something to diners.
Care extends to dietary needs, too. A gluten-friendly menu is available, and staff take food allergies seriously, which longtime guests genuinely appreciate.
Management pays attention to feedback as well, responding thoughtfully and inviting guests to reach out directly when something falls short. That willingness to improve reflects a team that cares about its reputation.
The result is a place where people feel looked after, even on the busiest holiday afternoons.
Who Fits Right In At The Table
A wide mix of people find their way to these tables, and most leave feeling like they belong. College crowds have a long history here, with SIU students filling booths for 40 years and counting.
Alumni who ate here as students often return every few years, treating a visit as a required stop. Many are delighted to find the place unchanged, holding onto the same quality that shaped their memories.
Road-trippers passing through Southern Illinois make deliberate detours, and travelers from as far as Australia have added it to their itineraries. Barbecue devotees on a mission to hit legendary spots put it high on the list.
Families, groups, and solo diners all fit comfortably in the casual setting. Large parties are common, and the kitchen manages sizable groups without losing its footing.
Birthdays, graduations, and holiday weekends bring extra crowds through the doors. The atmosphere leans relaxed and unpretentious, welcoming both newcomers and folks on their tenth visit.
Anyone who values genuine barbecue and a friendly room will feel right at home.
Hours, Prices, And Getting There
Planning a trip takes a little timing, since the doors are not open every day. The restaurant is closed Tuesday and Wednesday, so route your drive around those closures.
Hours run 11 AM to 8 PM on Thursday and Monday, 11 AM to 9 PM on Friday and Saturday, and 11 AM to 7 PM on Sunday. Opening at 11 AM makes an early lunch a smart way to beat the crowds.
Prices land in the 20 to 30 dollar range, reasonable for barbecue with this kind of pedigree. The restaurant holds a strong 4.5-star mark across more than 1,500 posted opinions.
You will find it at 32 N 17th St in Murphysboro, just off the main east-west road through town. Take-out and a drive-thru are available for those who prefer to eat on the go.
For anything specific, the website at 17bbq.com and the phone line at 618-684-3722 can help. Sauces, seasonings, rubs, and merchandise are also sold on site and online.
Weekends and event days draw lines, so a little patience pays off.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.