Ohio takes its pie seriously, and some of the best slices in the state are hiding at small shops far from the highway exits. From Amish country diners to family bakeshops that only open a few days a week, these are the places pie fans happily drive an hour or more to reach.
Whether you crave fruit pies packed with filling, silky cream flavors, or a whole cream pie for the price of a fast-food combo, this list has a stop for you. Grab your keys and a few empty pie boxes, because these seven Ohio shops are ready to load you up.
1. Mama Jo Homestyle Pies, Amherst, OH
Third-generation bakeries with this kind of following are rare, and this Amherst shop has been baking scratch-made pies daily since 1993.
The menu runs deep, with more than 35 flavors on a typical day covering fruit pies, cream pies, strudels, cookies, cakes, and seasonal specials. French silk, bumbleberry, and rhubarb are among the standouts, all made with real ingredients and no preservatives.
People have been known to carry these pies clear across state lines, which tells you something about the staying power of the flavors. The pies are not the cheapest around, but the top-shelf ingredients show up in every bite.
Plan for a quick visit, since this is a pickup and takeout operation with no dine-in seating. You can order online for fast in-store pickup or simply stop in and grab what looks good while it lasts.
Hours run Monday through Saturday from 9 AM to 6 PM and Sunday from 10 AM to 4 PM, with free parking in the lot. You will find it at 1969 Cooper Foster Park Rd.
2. Schmucker’s Restaurant, Toledo, OH
Yellow brick walls and a front-row seat to the grill set the tone at this longtime Toledo diner, where more than 20 kinds of pie share the spotlight with classic comfort food.
Breakfast and lunch are the main events, with plates like the Wimpy Burger Platter and the Meatloaf Sandwich anchoring the savory side. Save room, because the pie case is the real draw here.
Flavors range from chocolate peanut butter and vanilla peanut butter to strawberry rhubarb, Dutch apple, and a blueberry crumb with a thin crust and generous crumble. Almost every table seems to end the meal with a slice.
The vibe is casual, cozy, and family-friendly, with counter service, table service, high chairs, and a kids’ menu. Reservations are not accepted, so expect busier stretches on Thursday through Saturday mornings.
Doors open Monday through Saturday from 6 AM to 4 PM, and the restaurant is closed Sundays. Parking is easy, with a free lot, free street spots, and a paid lot nearby at 2103 N Reynolds Rd.
3. Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant, Berlin, OH
Deep in Holmes County, this circa-1940s spot has been serving homestyle Amish cooking to Berlin visitors for decades, and its house-baked pies are the reason many make the drive.
The lineup covers everything from cherry and fresh peach to black raspberry and peanut butter, with slices selling briskly throughout the day. A well-loved local trick is asking your server to stick a fork in your favorite so it does not sell out before you finish your meal.
Beyond the sweets, the kitchen turns out country fried steak, biscuits and gravy, taco salad, and hearty breakfasts. It is a full-service diner with a cozy, historic feel and room for groups.
Expect a wait during busy times, especially Saturday mornings, since reservations are not accepted. Hours run Monday through Thursday from 5:30 AM to 3:30 PM and Friday and Saturday until 7 PM, closed Sundays.
Free parking, street parking, and a paid lot are all available at 4819 E Main St, right in the heart of Amish country.
4. Partial To Pie Bakery, Dayton, OH
Locally sourced fruit is a point of pride at this Dayton bakery, where apples come from area orchards and land in pies with a buttery, flavorful crust worth every crumb.
The selection covers both sweet and savory, including apple, cherry, chocolate, coconut cream, and peanut butter pies alongside quiche, baklava, and mini hand pies. Gluten-free options are part of the mix too.
Prices lean affordable, and the crust here often converts people who normally leave it on the plate. Even the cherry pie gets attention for its light, flaky top and well-balanced filling.
The space is welcoming and LGBTQ+ friendly, with dine-in seating, coffee, free wi-fi, and a quick-visit pace. It is a small operation, so timing matters.
Hours are limited to Tuesday through Thursday from 7 AM to 3 PM, with the shop closed the rest of the week. There is free parking on site at 200 Shroyer Rd, so plan your midweek trip accordingly.
5. Just Pies Inc, Westerville, OH
Pi Day lines out the door say a lot about a bakeshop, and this family-owned Westerville spot draws a steady crowd of pie fans year-round.
The crust gets top billing here, thick and flaky and loaded with fruit filling. Cherry, apple, and peach are consistent favorites, with the peach pie earning must-try status among regulars.
Seasonal and creative flavors round out the case, from strawberry-rhubarb and boston cream to tripleberry and pecan chocolate chip cookie. Cookies are part of the haul too.
One handy feature is size flexibility, with small, medium, and large pies available so you can buy exactly what your table or gathering needs. This is a takeout and curbside pickup shop, so there is no dine-in seating.
Hours run Tuesday through Saturday from 9 AM to 5 PM, closed Sunday and Monday, with Saturday mornings the busiest. Free parking is available at 736 Northfield Rd, Suite 1.
6. Gardner Pie Co, Akron, OH
Some folks happily drive an hour and a half just to load up here, and the pies in Akron more than justify the mileage.
The focus is straightforward: fresh ingredients, perfect flavor, and just the right amount of sweetness in every pie. Honey crisp apple and blueberry are the kind of flavors that get finished off in a single sitting.
Prices land on the friendly side, which is part of why this becomes a go-to stop for people who buy a couple of pies at a time on repeat visits. The staff have a reputation for being helpful and easy to deal with.
This is a no-frills, pickup-focused shop with a free parking lot and no restroom, so keep the visit quick. Delivery is not offered.
Hours run Monday through Friday from 8 AM to 4 PM and Saturday from 8 AM to noon, closed Sundays. You will find it at 191 Logan Pkwy, with midweek afternoons among the busier windows.
7. Country Crust Bakery, Bainbridge, OH
A whole cream pie for around seven dollars is the kind of deal that stops road-trippers in their tracks, and this Amish-run bakery in Bainbridge delivers exactly that.
The shop specializes in pretzels and donuts but stretches well beyond, offering sandwiches, cinnamon bread, fried pies, turnovers, cookies, cakes, and giant soft pretzels. Apple fritters and pretzel bun sandwiches are among the highlights.
On the pie side, blueberry and blackberry earn loyal fans, and the lemon meringue is often called one of the most balanced slices around. No-bake cookies are a popular add-on.
There are picnic tables under shade trees outside, making it an easy place to enjoy your goodies before hitting the road again. It is a takeout-focused stop with coffee and a quick-visit pace.
Hours run Monday through Friday from 9 AM to 5 PM and Saturday from 8 AM to 4 PM, closed Sundays. Free parking and street parking are available at 4918 State Rte 41 S.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.