Picture a mountain of crab legs, a basket of golden hush puppies, and a plate of fried oysters stacked higher than your appetite can handle. That is the scene most evenings at Captain George’s Seafood Restaurant in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina.
With more than 16,000 Google reviews and a 4.4-star rating, it is one of the most talked-about buffets in town. Here is what to expect before you grab a plate and start piling it high.
A Seafood Buffet Parked on 29th Avenue North
Ask around Myrtle Beach for a spot to eat crab legs until you can barely move, and one name keeps coming up. Captain George’s Seafood Restaurant sits at 1401 29th Ave N, and it has built a reputation as a go-to seafood buffet for vacationers and locals alike.
At its heart, the restaurant is a nautical-themed buffet. Its official description calls it a relaxed, seafaring-themed joint offering an extensive seafood spread, plus classic sides and steaks.
So while the crab gets top billing, nobody who skips shellfish goes hungry.
The numbers tell part of the story. With a 4.4-star rating across more than 16,700 Google reviews, it ranks among the most discussed restaurants in the area.
Crab legs alone come up in over a thousand of those reviews, which says a lot about why people line up.
Guests can also order from an à la carte menu if a full buffet feels like too much. One visitor who went that route praised the she crab soup and a rice pilaf bowl.
Still, most tables head straight for the buffet, and that is where the real action happens.
Under-the-Sea Decor on a Grand Scale
First impressions start before you even find a seat. Guests often mention how big the place is, with one reviewer saying the sheer size of the dining room was the first thing that caught their eye.
There are tons of tables, so the restaurant can handle huge crowds at once.
Inside, the theme leans fully into life at sea. Visitors describe a warm, welcoming space decorated with an under-the-sea look, and several say the decor feels surprisingly high end for a buffet.
One diner noted that the atmosphere was beautiful from the outside all the way indoors.
Music plays throughout the evening, and one guest appreciated the wide variety of songs that kept the mood lively. Others describe the dining area as upscale yet relaxed.
That balance lets families in beach clothes feel just as comfortable as couples out for an anniversary.
Cleanliness comes up again and again in reviews. Words like spotless and exceptionally clean appear often, which matters when crowds pass through each night.
For a first-timer, walking in can feel a bit like stepping aboard a very large, very hungry ship.
Buffet Stations Built Like Sailing Ships
Here’s a detail kids tend to remember long after the trip ends. The buffet lines at Captain George’s are not plain steam tables.
Instead, the stations are designed to look like ships, complete with massive sails rising above the food.
One reviewer called the setup a fun, themed touch that sets the place apart. Another said the big ship stations were especially fun for children, who get to feel like they are raiding a pirate galley while filling their plates.
Adults seem to enjoy it too, judging by how often the ships show up in reviews.
Beyond the novelty, the stations are kept in sharp shape. Guests describe attendants constantly checking the ships, wiping up drips the moment they appear and refilling trays so everything stays full and fresh.
A visitor who admitted worrying about germs at buffets said the staffing put those fears to rest.
The menu on these ships also shifts depending on the day. A Monday visit might look a little different from a Saturday one, giving return guests something new to try.
Wandering from ship to ship to see what’s out is half the fun.
Crab Legs, the Undisputed Headliner
Over 1,100 mentions. That’s how often crab legs come up in reviews of Captain George’s, and nearly 300 more talk specifically about all you can eat crab legs.
If one dish defines this restaurant, it’s the crab.
Fans rave about them. Visitors describe the crab as fresh, flavorful and well seasoned, with one calling it easily the highlight of the meal.
A first-timer who had heard about the place for years said the crab legs lived up to the hype, adding that fresh trays kept coming out so there was never a long wait.
Servers help keep the mess under control too. Tables get scrap buckets for shells, and one guest noted their server emptied them in a timely way.
That small touch matters when a group is cracking through pile after pile.
Not every review is glowing, though. One diner who compared it to a nearby competitor found the crab very wet when broken open and a bit rubbery.
Another said most legs were good but some looked brown rather than bright red.
Even so, the crowds keep coming back for more. Most people seem to leave happy, full and a little sticky.
Oysters, Fried and Rockefeller Style
Oyster lovers, listen up, because the details matter here. Captain George’s serves oysters, but mostly cooked ones, and fried oysters earn more than 40 mentions in reviews.
One guest described them as perfectly fried, a golden treat that pairs well with everything else on the plate.
Oysters Rockefeller also make an appearance. A family reunion guest listed Rockefeller oysters among the dishes they tried alongside shrimp and crab legs.
For people who like their shellfish baked with a rich topping, that’s a welcome option.
What you won’t find, according to reviewers, is a raw bar. One guest wished the buffet had fresh oysters, saying it would have taken the meal to the next level.
Another, comparing the restaurant to a rival spot, pointed out that George’s had no raw bar at all.
So plan around that. If slurping oysters on the half shell is your top priority, this may not scratch that itch.
If you’re happy with crispy fried ones and a few baked beauties, you’ll find plenty to enjoy, along with juicy shrimp and tender scallops that one reviewer singled out for praise.
Hush Puppies and the Fried Side of the Menu
No Southern seafood spread feels complete without hush puppies, and Captain George’s keeps them on hand. Opinions on them vary.
One reviewer called the hush puppies very flavorful but also quite dry, and said a competitor’s version went down easier.
Fried food in general plays a starring role here. A visitor who gave the restaurant four stars said the selection is wide but leans heavily toward fried items.
For fans of crunchy shrimp, golden oysters and all the classic fixings, that’s great news.
Healthier eaters may need a plan. The same reviewer noted that grilled, steamed or broiled choices are limited, and that doing only the salad bar is possible but not quite enough to feel worthwhile.
A few lighter options do exist on the à la carte menu.
Even the fried spread gets mixed marks. One guest who compared it to another buffet thought George’s fried seafood selection fell short.
Others clearly loved it, praising the variety and pointing out that nothing tasted fishy.
A simple strategy works well. Grab a few hush puppies for the Southern experience, but save space for the crab.
Prime Rib, Brisket and Plenty for Landlubbers
Not everyone in the family wants seafood, and that’s fine here. Along with the ocean fare, the buffet carries classic sides and steaks, and reviewers mention a long list of land-based choices.
One birthday guest rattled off seafood, prime rib, chicken, ribs and more, saying the options just go on and on.
Prime rib earns over 50 mentions in reviews, while brisket shows up in nearly 40. One diner thought the brisket was cut a bit thick but still tasty.
Another visitor said even non-seafood lovers will find plenty of delicious options.
Side dishes hold their own. A family reunion guest called the mac and cheese top tier, and others praised the salads.
With the menu shifting depending on the day, the exact lineup can change from visit to visit.
Special diets get attention too. During a Thanksgiving buffet, one server personally walked a guest with celiac disease around the stations to point out gluten-free foods, even for dessert.
He later brought steak straight to her table, and stories like that suggest careful eaters can still build a full, worry-free plate.
A Dessert Bar Worth Saving Room For
Leave room. That advice appears in review after review, and the dessert bar, with about 70 mentions, explains why.
Guests describe a sweet spread that competes with the crab for attention.
Baklava stands out as a surprise favorite, earning around 30 mentions. Other treats guests name include creamy cheesecake, chocolate mousse, apple cobbler and ice cream.
One visitor noticed the strawberry shortcake tray getting emptied twice during their meal, which is about as strong a review as a dessert can get.
Even a reviewer who preferred a competing buffet overall admitted that George’s desserts were better, apart from the rival’s chocolate fountain. That’s quite a compliment from a tough critic.
Tastes vary, of course. One unhappy diner complained that the chocolate pudding missed the mark and felt the food overall wasn’t worth the price.
For most visitors, though, the dessert bar is a happy ending to a big meal.
Here’s a pro move: take a small plate first and sample a bite of several things. With this many choices, you’ll want to taste widely before committing to seconds.
Service That Keeps the Tables Moving
Behind every heaping plate is a crew working hard to keep up. Many reviewers single out servers by name and describe them as friendly, attentive and quick to clear plates and refill drinks.
A family reunion of more than 50 people praised three staff members for keeping everyone well cared for.
Larger groups get extra help. One party of 15 had three servers during a holiday meal and said food was maintained and swapped quickly.
A guest who chatted with the chef afterward came away feeling the crew was devoted and proud of their work.
Service isn’t flawless every night, though. One guest felt customer service was a bit subpar, while noting that a self-serve buffet naturally involves less hands-on attention.
Another got only one glass of water all evening despite asking for a refill, and a late-arriving group said they were never offered a drink menu or à la carte menu.
Friendliness extends beyond the dining room. One family mentioned the souvenir desk, where a staff member helped them pick out long-sleeve shirts during a cold snap.
Overall, the service picture is largely positive, with occasional slips on busy nights.
Beating the Crowds at Opening Time
Lines form fast at Captain George’s, and regulars have learned to plan around them. One reviewer arrived early on a Sunday and was among the first guests waiting for the doors to open, warning that people show up in droves.
Another put it simply: get there early, because the line builds quickly after the 3:30 PM opening.
Luckily, the operation runs efficiently. Quick seating comes up in reviews, and a group in town for a spring volleyball tournament said they were seated fast despite heavy crowds.
Food is continuously refilled, so even at peak hours the trays stay stocked.
Early arrivals may also benefit from an early bird special, which pops up in over 30 reviews. Current details aren’t spelled out, so calling ahead to ask what’s offered makes sense.
Arriving late has trade-offs. One group that came on the later side was still welcomed and told refilling was ongoing, but they weren’t sure every station was fully stocked.
Another guest who went on a slower night found it pleasantly uncrowded.
For the freshest trays and shortest wait, showing up near opening seems to be the smart play.
Birthdays, Reunions and Big Family Tables
Some restaurants are built for quiet dinners for two. Captain George’s is built for the whole crew.
Reviewers describe it as a wonderful place for families and larger groups, with one saying the more, the merrier.
Celebrations are a big draw. Multiple guests came for birthdays, and one called the visit an early birthday gift that couldn’t have been a better choice.
Another suggested it for anniversaries and special occasions, since the price feels easier to justify when there’s something to celebrate.
Group size doesn’t seem to rattle the staff. Family reunions of 50-plus, holiday parties of 15 and sports teams in town for tournaments have all shared positive experiences.
The huge dining room makes it easier to fit everyone together.
Kids have plenty to love, from the ship-shaped buffet stations to the endless dessert choices. Picky eaters can stick to chicken, ribs or mac and cheese while parents load up on crab.
Couples seeking a hushed, romantic evening might find the busy energy a lot to take in. Anyone who enjoys a bustling room full of families and friends, though, will fit right in.
The Honest Downsides Some Guests Mention
No restaurant pleases everyone, and a 4.4-star average leaves room for a few grumbles. Knowing them ahead of time can help you decide if the trip fits your taste.
Drinks draw the most specific complaints. One guest found the mixed drinks watered down and recommended sticking with wine or beer instead.
Food quality also gets occasional pushback, with one unhappy visitor calling much of it overcooked and cafeteria-like, and another describing it as bland.
A four-star reviewer summed it up as the Golden Corral of seafood buffets. That same guest found the salmon a bit dry, though nothing tasted fishy.
A leftover policy surprised one diner. When they boxed up part of an à la carte meal, the leftovers went to the hostess stand to be checked, apparently to keep buffet food from leaving.
Their box was briefly mixed up with another party’s, and the bill needed correcting too.
Price is the other common theme. Plenty of guests call the meal pricey, even those who loved it, and one regular wished there were a cheaper option for diners who don’t eat crab legs.
Weigh these notes against thousands of happy reviews before you decide.
Hours, Prices and Planning Your Visit
Timing your visit starts with the schedule. Captain George’s opens at 3:30 PM and closes at 8:30 PM Monday through Friday.
Saturday runs longer, from 2 to 9 PM, and Sunday starts earliest, from noon to 8:30 PM.
On pricing, one guest reported paying $49 per person for the buffet, with no discount for skipping crab legs. Another spent about $40 on an à la carte meal.
Prices can change, so checking captaingeorges.com or calling +1 843-916-2278 before you go is a good idea.
Groups should know that one party found the tip already included in the bill. They chose to add a little extra for great service.
Drinks cost extra too, based on another guest’s receipt.
You’ll find the restaurant at 1401 29th Ave N, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577. Plug the address into your map app and give yourself extra time, since crowds build right at opening.
Before heading out, consider a stop at the souvenir desk. One family bought long-sleeve shirts there during a chilly spell and called them reasonably priced.
A Soft Verdict From the Buffet Line
So, is Captain George’s worth the hype? For most visitors, the answer seems to be yes.
Thousands of reviews point to fresh crab legs, a massive variety of dishes, a fun nautical setting and staff who work hard to keep everything running.
It shines brightest for certain kinds of diners. Crab lovers, big families, birthday groups and anyone who enjoys fried seafood with a side of hush puppies will likely leave full and happy.
Kids who get a kick out of ship-shaped buffet stations will probably beg to come back.
It may not suit everyone. If you want raw oysters, mostly grilled dishes or a budget-friendly meal, other spots might fit better.
A few guests also found the food uneven or the drinks weak.
Still, the overall picture is hard to argue with. A 4.4-star rating across more than 16,000 reviews doesn’t happen by accident.
One reviewer said a visit to Myrtle Beach must include Captain George’s, and plenty of others seem to agree.
Arrive early, bring your appetite and save room for dessert. That strawberry shortcake won’t last long.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.