Every November, the dessert table quietly becomes the most talked-about part of Thanksgiving dinner in Texas. Turkey gets the spotlight, but pie is what people remember, and what they sneak a second slice of after the dishes are done.
Baking from scratch takes time many of us simply do not have during the holiday rush. That is where a good local pie shop earns its keep.
This list rounds up seven Texas bakeries that specialize in pie, from a Garland shop selling flights of slices to a Round Top stop known for both sweet and savory options. You will find Dallas, Fort Worth, Arlington, Houston, and Hill Country picks, with pecan, buttermilk, sweet potato, cream, and fruit pies all represented.
Some keep limited hours, so planning ahead matters. Call early, place that order, and let someone else handle the crust this year.
Your guests will never ask who rolled the dough.
1. Piefalootin, Garland, TX
A pie flight is the smartest way to settle a family argument about favorite flavors. Piefalootin in Garland offers exactly that, letting you sample several slices before committing to a whole pie for the holiday table.
The menu mixes classic and creative. Texas Pecan sits alongside Key Lime, Banoffee, Oreo, and a Chocolate Euphoreo that leans fully into dessert indulgence.
The Blueberry Buttermilk Pie deserves special attention. The buttermilk filling is thick and smooth, and the handmade crust stays crisp and flaky without tipping into overly sweet territory.
Slices come in generous portions with house-made whipped cream, and the shop also pours coffee. It keeps a relaxed, easygoing setup with free Wi-Fi and a free parking lot at 2441 Goldfinch Lane.
Plan around the schedule. Piefalootin is closed Monday and Tuesday and open Wednesday through Sunday from 1 to 8 PM, with Saturday afternoon and evening drawing the biggest crowds.
Call 469-573-8756 to ask about holiday orders.
2. Texas Pie Co, Kyle, TX
Some bakeries sell pie. Texas Pie Co in Kyle also sells the crust itself, which is handy if you want to fill your own and still skip the hardest step.
The pie lineup is wide. Chocolate Fudge, Cherry, Coconut Cream, and Buttermilk Pie all appear on the menu, along with cream pies by the slice and a well-loved key lime.
Lunch is part of the draw too. King Ranch Chicken and quiche with salad make this a solid midday stop on a Hill Country drive, and lemon bars round out the sweets case.
The shop sits at 202 W Center St in quaint digs decorated with a baking theme. Hours run Monday through Friday from 10:30 AM to 6:30 PM and Saturday until 4 PM, with Sundays closed.
Fridays and Saturday mornings get busy, so weekday visits are calmer for placing a Thanksgiving order. Reach them at 512-268-5885.
3. Humble: Simply Good Pies, Dallas, TX
Sweet potato pie fans in East Dallas already know where to head. Humble: Simply Good Pies on Garland Road earns steady praise for its sweet potato and apple pies, two Thanksgiving staples that are easy to get wrong.
The shop focuses on classic cream, fruit, and nut pies. Chocolate Cream is a standout, with balanced sweetness and a flaky crust, and coconut is another strong pick.
The mini pies make the menu fun. Texas Pecan, Lemon Ice Box, and a playfully named Damned Fine Cherry come in smaller sizes, which works well for a dessert spread with lots of variety.
Grown-up flavors show up too, including a Bourbon Chocolate Pecan and a tangy Lemon Chess.
Humble is takeout only, with no dine-in seating and no restroom. It is open Wednesday and Thursday from 11 AM to 6 PM, Friday and Saturday until 9 PM, and Sunday until 8 PM.
Call 214-458-9039 before the holiday rush.
4. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Arlington, Arlington, TX
Can’t pick just one pie? The Dozen 4 Pies option at Buttermilk Sky in Arlington solves that by bundling small pies, which is great for testing flavors before the big day.
Everything here is made from scratch. The crust is the headline, light and flaky rather than gooey or heavy, and it pairs well with both cream and fruit fillings.
For Thanksgiving, the sweet potato pie is a favorite. Chocolate cream is another reliable choice, with a creamy filling over a sweet crust.
Bolder options include the 4 Candy Bar Explosion Pie, plus Chocolate Cream and Peanut Butter Cream parfaits for anyone who prefers a spoon. Shortbread cookies also share the counter.
The shop is at 1707 N Collins St, Suite 115, with a free parking lot. It opens daily, with Sunday hours from noon to 6 PM, and offers delivery.
Call 817-617-2046 to set up an order.
5. Sweet Lucy’s Pies, Fort Worth, TX
Two days a week is all you get for walk-ins at Sweet Lucy’s Pies. That short window is exactly why preordering makes sense here.
The Fort Worth bake shop sits on historic Bluebonnet Circle and specializes in flaky pies and baked goods made in small batches. Retail hours are Friday from noon to 6 PM and Saturday from 10 AM to 2 PM.
The rest of the week, the kitchen handles special orders. If you want a whole pie for Thanksgiving, calling ahead at 817-727-6009 is the way to go.
Fall is a strong season for this shop, with seasonal pies that keep customers returning once the weather cools. Prices are friendly, and a free lot makes pickup simple.
6. Flying Saucer Pie Company, Houston, TX
Houston has plenty of new dessert spots, but Flying Saucer Pie Company is the old-school standby. The family-run shop on W Crosstimbers St turns out handmade fruit and cream pies with a retro, quirky personality.
Pecan Pie is the obvious Thanksgiving call. Peach, Cherry, and Key Lime cover the fruit side, while Fresh Strawberry Cream and Fresh Banana Cream bring something lighter to the table.
The crust is flaky and buttery, and the ratio of filling, cream, and crust is well balanced. Service moves quickly, even with a big selection.
Plan for takeout only, since there is no seating and no restroom. Hours are Tuesday through Saturday from 8 AM to 7 PM, with Saturday afternoon the busiest time.
Call 713-694-1141 to reserve your holiday pies.
7. Royers Pie Haven, Round Top, TX
Round Top is a tiny town, yet its pie reputation reaches across Texas. Royers Pie Haven at 190 Henkel Circle is a big part of that.
The shop serves both sweet and savory pies, so Chicken Pot Pie can share the order with dessert. Sweet choices include apple, pecan, cherry, salted caramel, red velvet Oreo, a Sweet and Salty Pie, and a vegan Strawberry Rhubarb.
Gluten-free crust is available too, with lime coconut as one tasty example.
Coffee and breakfast make this a nice morning stop, and the setting includes scenic outdoor space. Saturday hours run from 8 AM to 6 PM, and the shop closes Tuesdays.
A Thanksgiving pickup here pairs well with a countryside drive. Call 979-249-5282 to plan your order.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.