Some road trip stops are about gas, and some are about pie. South of Dallas, plenty of drivers on I-35E make a careful loop off the highway for a warm hand pie tucked into a paper sack.
The counter is small, the menu is long, and the flavor list runs from peach to pecan to cream cheese. Regulars swing by once a week, while Austin-bound travelers plan their whole drive around it.
The best part is that the pies can travel home with you too. Keep reading to learn where this little counter hides, what to order, how much to bring, and the tricky turn you need to know before you go.
A Pie Counter Inside a Travel Center
The best surprises sometimes hide behind a gas pump. The Original Fried Pie Shop sits at 200 Interstate Highway 35E Service Road, Red Oak, TX 75154, in the United States.
It does not have its own storefront on a quiet main street. Instead, it lives inside the Red Oak Travel Center, the mart attached to the Shell station.
Look for the counter in the center of the building, between the Wendy’s and the restrooms. Card purchases even ring up as Shell, which can be a little confusing the first time.
That setup is part of the charm. A driver can fuel up, take a break, and leave with a sack of pies in one stop.
Red Oak sits just south of Dallas, which makes this spot an easy pause for anyone heading toward Austin or San Antonio. The shop is listed as a pie shop, and that is exactly its focus today.
Small as it is, the place has earned a loyal crowd. It holds a 4.4-star average across 139 Google opinions, which is solid for a counter tucked inside a truck stop.
So the first lesson is simple. Do not judge a pie by its parking lot.
Part of a Bigger Pie Family
Plenty of first-timers walk up thinking they found a one-of-a-kind roadside stand. Then they spot the list of locations posted next to the counter.
The Original Fried Pie Shop is actually a chain, with this Red Oak counter as one of its outposts. That detail surprises people, mostly because the spot feels so personal.
Fans of the brand are fiercely loyal. Some insist that if the sign does not say The Original Fried Pie Shop, it is not worth the trip.
The name itself makes a bold claim. Loyal customers back it up, saying other places calling themselves original do not even compare.
One thing that keeps the quality steady is the cooking method. Pies are fresh cooked in peanut oil at each location, so each counter makes its own batch.
The brand also has a website for anyone curious about its other stops. Frozen pies can even be shipped directly to homes, which turns a road snack into a mail-order treat.
Fun fact for the road: plenty of people tasting a pie here have never had a fried pie before in their lives. For a chain, that is a pretty good recruiting record.
From Burgers to Pies Only
Longtime customers remember a different menu. Years back, this counter served hamburgers, seasoned fries, tots, and fried cheese sticks alongside the pies.
That changed when a Wendy’s opened right next door inside the travel center. After that, the shop dropped the grill items and turned its full attention to pies.
Some old fans still mention the burgers fondly. Even so, they also say the pies remain the reason to stop.
Older menus once included a savory option too, with a polish sausage pie getting attention years ago. Today, the focus rests on sweet hand pies.
The change made the shop simpler. One counter, one specialty, and a long list of flavors.
The travel center around it also improved over time. Regulars point out that more staff were added, the restrooms stay fairly clean even when busy, and the building feels safe.
So when someone asks what else is on the menu, the honest answer is pies. That is a short menu with a long fan list.
Fifteen-Plus Flavors and Counting
Decision fatigue is real at this counter. The flavor board is long enough to slow down even the most confident order.
Fruit options include peach, cherry, apricot, pineapple, apple, blackberry, blueberry, pumpkin, and strawberry. Cream choices cover chocolate, vanilla, lemon, and coconut.
There is also pecan for nut lovers and cream cheese for something different. Sugar-free versions of cherry and apple are available too.
Limited-time flavors pop up now and then. Strawberry has appeared as a seasonal special, and a peanut butter flavor has caught the attention of returning fans.
Some flavors draw extra love. Coconut gets frequent praise, apricot has devoted followers, and apple keeps some regulars coming back weekly.
Blackberry earns attention for being packed with filling. Bavarian vanilla surprises people who have never tried a vanilla pie.
Customers also get creative with combinations. A coconut, chocolate, and pecan pie has been made by request, which suggests the staff will work with a curious order.
The best strategy might be to buy several. That way nobody has to pick a favorite on the first visit.
What Makes the Crust Stand Out
Ask fans what keeps them loyal, and the crust usually comes up first. It is often called flaky and well made.
People also praise the balance between filling and crust. Many say the pies are not greasy, which sets them apart from other fried pies they have tried.
The crust carries a slightly salty, savory edge. That pairs with sweet fillings that are not overly sugary, especially in the fruit flavors.
Size matters here too. One pie is fairly large, roughly equal to about two and a half fast-food apple pies.
Not every pie is perfect. Some batches have come out a bit doughy in spots, and a few customers wished for more crispness.
The pies also hold up well over time. Families have kept them in the fridge for a day or two, and the crust stayed in good shape.
Even people who claim no sweet tooth have finished an entire pineapple pie. That says plenty about how easy these are to enjoy.
The Fresh-Out-of-the-Fryer Advantage
Timing can change everything. The freshest pies come straight from the fryer, and fans recommend showing up early.
Morning visits reward people with hot pies ready to go. Some treat them as a breakfast item, while others save them for dessert.
A freshly made chocolate fried pie gets high marks for being warm and crisp. Pies that have sat for a while can lose some of that crispness.
Older notes also mention a late-night batch where the fryer oil needed changing. More recent mentions focus on fresh cooking and good flavor.
Here is a helpful move. Ask the staff which flavors were just cooked before choosing.
Not everyone wants a hot pie, though. Some lifelong fried pie eaters say these treats are best at room temperature.
Others enjoy them hot, warm, or even cold. With that range, there is no wrong time to eat one, only a fresher one.
Frozen Pies for the Road Home
Leaving with only one pie is rare. Many customers grab a frozen dozen before heading back onto the highway.
Frozen pies cost $1.50 each or $12 for a dozen. Mixing and matching flavors appears to be allowed.
Back home, they can be cooked in an oven or an air fryer, or fried in your favorite oil. That flexibility makes them easy to share with family.
Some fans simply thaw them and eat them at room temperature. Apricot is a popular pick for that approach.
Buying both fresh and frozen is a common strategy. Eat one warm in the car, and save the rest for later in the week.
The brand also ships frozen pies directly to homes. That option helps anyone who lives too far to make the drive often.
Freezer space might become the real problem. Clearing a shelf before the trip is a smart move.
Friendly Faces Behind the Counter
Good pies are one thing. Kind staff make the stop memorable.
Friendly staff earn frequent praise here, with workers described as helpful and professional. They take time to explain the different flavors to newcomers.
Even when only one person is working the counter, the pies still come out well. That person handles questions and cooking at the same time.
Staff members make sure customers leave happy. One worker even became known for a cool hat.
First-timers often need guidance, and the team seems glad to help. That patience matters with a menu this long.
Pies come served warm in a paper sleeve. Then they go into a paper sack, ready for the car ride.
Small moments like that add up. A quick snack stop turns into a place people want to visit again.
Who Pulls Off the Highway Here
The crowd here is a mix of road warriors and neighbors. Truckers, families, and Dallas-to-Austin drivers all find their way to this counter.
It works as a pitstop south of Dallas. Many travelers stop for a midday snack and call it worth the break.
Families stop too, and kids often beg for chocolate pies. Parents tend to end up just as hooked.
Locals visit regularly, some driving about 20 minutes for another round. One fan admits to stopping once a week for apple.
Solo travelers appreciate the safe, clean setting. Women traveling alone have noted feeling comfortable at the travel center.
The atmosphere is casual and practical. Clean surroundings and quick service suit anyone short on time.
No reservations or dress code required. Just a little appetite and room in the cup holder.
Counting Dollars and Dozens
Budget planning is easy here. Prices are posted plainly at the counter.
Each fresh fruit pie costs $3.99. Cream pies such as chocolate, vanilla, lemon, and coconut, plus pecan, run $4.49.
Buying a dozen fresh pies gets you a 12 percent discount. That deal makes sense for families or office treats.
Frozen pies are much cheaper at $1.50 each. A frozen dozen costs $12.
A few customers feel fresh pies run a bit on the pricey side. Most still say the quality makes them worth it.
Size helps the value too. Each pie is large enough to work as a real snack.
Prices can change over time, so checking before a big order is wise. Still, these numbers give a good starting point.
Hours and the Famous Bow Tie Turn
Finding the shop takes a little planning. Southbound drivers often see it before figuring out how to reach it.
Heading south, you need to cross the highway and travel down a residential street. Go over the hill and down the road, and the travel center appears.
When leaving, drivers make a bow tie loop to get back on the southbound highway. It sounds tricky, but it becomes easy after one visit.
Hours are generous. The shop opens at 7 AM Monday through Friday and at 8 AM on Saturday and Sunday.
Every day it stays open until 8 PM. Some online listings have claimed 24-hour service, but posted hours point to the earlier close.
Early mornings are ideal for hot pies. Evenings work for a dessert run before the counter closes.
Checking the shop website before driving is smart. It saves a detour from becoming a disappointment.
Worth the Exit Ramp
Some detours cost time. This one pays you back in pies.
The Original Fried Pie Shop keeps things simple. It offers a long flavor list, friendly help, and frozen dozens for later.
It is not fancy, and it never tries to be. A counter between a Wendy’s and the restrooms does not need to be.
Small flaws pop up now and then, such as a doughy bite or a pie that sat too long. Even so, most people leave planning their next order.
For first-timers, the move is clear. Arrive early, ask what just came out of the fryer, and grab extras for home.
Regulars already know the drill. Many keep coming back weekly, and travelers mark it on their route.
So next time I-35E stretches ahead, watch for that Red Oak exit. A paper sack of pies is waiting just off the service road.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.