Some buildings in New Jersey have been around long enough to hold a few secrets. One old structure in Bloomfield once sheltered people during the Revolutionary War, and its basement is said to have been a stop on the Underground Railroad.
Today, the same walls frame a busy steakhouse where cowboy ribeyes land on tables next to fresh oysters and slices of coconut cake. Keep reading to learn the story behind the building, what makes the menu stand out, and the smart tips that help you plan the perfect visit.
A Historic Address on Franklin Street
Tucked along a quiet stretch of a busy town sits a restaurant with more backstory than most history books. Bloomfield Steak & Seafood House is found at 409 Franklin St, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, in the United States.
It is classified as a steak house, but the menu reaches well beyond beef. Seafood, a raw bar, burgers, pasta, salads, and soups all share space with the steaks.
The building itself is the first thing that sets the place apart. It is described as a former Revolutionary War hideout that has been turned into a chophouse and seafood restaurant.
Bloomfield sits in Essex County, a part of New Jersey with deep colonial roots. That history is not hidden away here, since it is part of the very structure people dine in.
The restaurant holds a 4.5-star standing from more than 1,600 Google opinions. That kind of steady praise suggests the kitchen and the history pull equal weight.
So what exactly happened inside these walls before the steaks arrived? The story starts a couple of centuries back.
Walls That Remember the Revolution
History buffs, this one is for you. The building is known as one of the oldest structures from the Pre-Revolutionary War period in Essex County.
During the fight for independence, it served as a hideout. That makes dinner here a rare chance to eat where colonial-era events once unfolded.
The story does not stop with the Revolution. The basement is said to have been a stop on the Underground Railroad, the network that helped people escape slavery and seek freedom.
Those layers of the past give the restaurant a weight that a new building simply cannot copy. The colonial-style charm is part of the decor, not a theme added later.
The business is family-owned and operated. It has been serving the Bloomfield area for over 20 years, which adds its own chapter to the building’s long timeline.
Plenty of restaurants claim a story. Few can point to the walls and say the story happened right there.
Of course, a good history lesson works up an appetite. Next up is the steak that gives this article its title.
The Cowboy Ribeye Takes Center Stage
Big steak, big name, big expectations. The cowboy ribeye is one of the headline cuts on the menu, and it tends to draw attention when it hits the table.
Ordered medium, it arrives cooked as requested. It pairs well with fried onions and mashed potatoes, a classic combo that never goes out of style.
Fair warning for anyone hoping for a full Wild West experience. The ribeye leans toward a traditional steakhouse style rather than a heavily seasoned frontier flavor, but it still delivers as a solid steak.
Beyond the cowboy cut, steaks here earn steady praise for being cooked exactly as ordered. A guest from Texas, a state that takes beef seriously, left impressed with the doneness.
Other beef choices round out the lineup. Steak Frites, a pan-fried filet mignon with blue cheese sauce, and filet mignon on toast all appear on the menu.
A quick tip on the filet: medium seems to be the sweet spot. The sauce brings plenty of punch on its own.
Steak may be the star, yet the seafood side of the name is far from a sidekick.
Surf Joins the Turf
Eighteen shrimp in one appetizer. That count comes straight from a regular who tallied them, and it sums up how generous the starters can be.
The seafood half of the menu holds its own. Fresh oysters, including Blue Points, appear on the raw bar, and they are larger than the small ones found at many spots in the state.
Shrimp in Thai chili sauce is a crowd favorite. It brings plenty of flavor without too much heat.
Calamari, shrimp scampi, and lobster bisque also show up often in conversation. Clams make the list too.
On the entree side, crab-stuffed flounder and salmon earn strong marks. Seafood here is often described as fresh, which matters a lot at a place that puts it right in the name.
Portions run large enough that boxing up leftovers is common. Appetizers alone can fill a table, so ordering in rounds is a smart move.
One more room exists in every good meal, and it belongs to dessert.
Coconut Cake and Other Sweet Endings
Some restaurants have a signature dessert, and this one has a famous coconut cake. It comes up again and again among diners as a must-order finale.
The cake is not the only sweet option. Churros with a caramel dip make a filling treat for sharing.
A warm steakhouse brownie is another choice for chocolate fans. Key lime pie also appears on the dessert list for anyone who wants something lighter.
Saving room is the real challenge. With big appetizers and hearty steaks, dessert often becomes a team effort.
Sides deserve a quick shout as well. Honey Brussels sprouts, mac and cheese, and a stuffed baked potato all win fans.
Honey garlic wings are another popular starter, and complimentary bread kicks off the meal. Diners who skip meat will find salads, pasta, and vegetarian-friendly picks on the diverse menu.
With full plates covered, the next question is where to sit. The answer depends on the season.
Patio Lights, Bubbles, and Bossa Nova
Outdoor dining is one of the most talked-about features here, with more mentions than almost any dish. The patio is well lit and draws praise for taking the experience up a notch.
In warmer weather, a live band often plays outside. One standout is a bossa nova band whose sets turn a regular dinner into a memorable evening.
Fans of that band suggest planning a reservation for a night when they perform. Checking ahead is worth the effort.
Cooler months bring a different setup. Cozy fireplaces warm the indoor rooms, and outdoor bubble seating has also been part of the mix.
Inside, the colonial-style charm meets a maritime decor theme in the back dining area. The room is described as comfortable and not too loud.
The vibe is relaxed rather than formal. It is a place for good food and good people, with no pressure to dress up.
That easygoing mood makes it a natural pick for special days, which leads to the next topic.
A Favorite Spot for Celebrations
Birthdays seem to follow this restaurant around. A 17th birthday, a 55th birthday party, and a solo birthday dinner all made the list of happy occasions here.
An upstairs semi-private room handles group events. Staff have accommodated last-minute table setup requests without hesitation.
Party planning gets regular check-ins from the team, which makes the process easier for hosts. Managers are described as professional from start to finish.
Service is a big part of the appeal. Servers often get credit by name for being friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive without rushing guests.
Solo diners feel welcome too. The staff make single guests comfortable and seated in good spots.
Not every night is flawless, and slow waits during busy times have come up. Management responds directly and says it works quickly to fix any dish that misses the mark.
Happy hour gets frequent mentions as well, making weeknights another good time to stop by. Speaking of timing, here is what to know before heading over.
Hours, Parking, and a Fair Verdict
Mondays are off the table, since the restaurant is closed that day. Tuesday through Thursday, doors open at 11:30 am and close at 10 pm.
Friday runs from 11:30 am to 11 pm. Saturday hours are 1 pm to 11 pm, and Sunday runs from 1 pm to 10 pm.
Reservations can be made easily ahead of time. Booking is wise for weekends, big groups, or nights with live music.
Parking is a nice bonus here. The restaurant offers plenty of it in an area where most spots are on the street.
Value gets good marks too. Diners describe the prices as fair for the quality compared with similar places.
More details live on the official website at eatbeefgethooked.com. The name alone hints at the playful spirit behind the business.
So is it worth the trip? For anyone who wants a solid cowboy ribeye served inside a building that sheltered history, this Bloomfield spot makes a strong case to come back hungry and curious.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.