Some places in Indianapolis serve lunch, and a few serve a whole decade along with it. On the south side of the city, carhops still walk orders out to parked cars, and a jukebox in the dining room keeps playing tunes from the 1950s.
The star of the menu is a breaded pork tenderloin so big it hangs far past the edges of its bun. Root beer is made in house, onion rings have a loyal fan club, and car shows sometimes roll into the lot.
This article walks through the story, the menu favorites, the carside routine, and the small quirks worth knowing before a first trip. Stick around for practical tips on parking, ordering, and how to make the most of a visit to one of the city’s most loved retro diners.
A Retro Stop on Sherman Drive
Retro charm has a real home address in Indianapolis. Edwards Drive-In Restaurant sits at 2126 S Sherman Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46203, on the city’s south side in Indiana, United States.
The place is a classic diner with a twist. Food can be served carside, which is a style that has mostly faded from American roadsides.
Known as a venerable 1950s diner, it has built its name on two things. One is a huge breaded tenderloin, and the other is handmade root beer.
Carhop service is still part of daily life here. Guests can park, stay in the car, and have orders brought right to the window.
The spot has earned a 4.4 star average from nearly 3,000 opinions on Google Maps. That is a lot of people agreeing that the trip is worth it.
Inside, a roomy dining area offers another way to eat. So the choice comes down to a quiet meal in the car or a seat near the jukebox.
Both options lead to the same menu of hearty diner favorites. The next sections show why so many Hoosiers keep circling back to this corner of Sherman Drive.
Decades of South Side Memories
Long before retro became a trend, this diner was simply doing its thing. It carries the reputation of a true 1950s diner that never fully let go of its roots.
For many local families, the restaurant is woven into everyday life. Some longtime guests remember coming here as kids, and later watching their own children take their first job behind the counter.
That kind of history gives the place a hometown feel. It is the sort of diner where grandparents bring grandkids for hot dogs and point out how little has changed.
Former Hoosiers who have moved out of state also make a point of stopping by. Breaded tenderloins of this size are hard to find in other regions, so a trip home often includes a meal here.
Out of town travelers show up on recommendations from friends. Many try their first tenderloin sandwich here and leave as instant converts.
The restaurant is described as a hot spot for locals, and that local loyalty is easy to spot. It is a busy room full of regulars who know exactly what they want before they reach the counter, which says plenty about a place that has stood the test of time.
The Tenderloin That Outgrows Its Bun
Indiana takes its pork tenderloin seriously, and this kitchen treats it like a headliner. The breaded tenderloin is the most talked about item on the menu by a wide margin.
Size is the first thing people notice. The cutlet stretches well beyond the bun, so the bread ends up looking like a small hat in the middle.
Many guests say it comes out moist and cooked fresh. The breading earns plenty of attention too, and it is a big part of what makes the sandwich so popular.
Fans of the classic style appreciate that this tenderloin is not a fritter. It is a real pork cutlet, which matters a lot to Hoosiers who care about these things.
A grilled version is also on the menu for anyone skipping the breading. That one can come out on the drier side, so the breaded one is the safer first pick.
Toppings are simple, and the mustard here gets a special nod. Extra pickles are a common add on.
Opinions on seasoning vary a little from visit to visit. Still, for a first trip, ordering the signature sandwich is the move that most regulars would make without a second thought.
Handmade Root Beer and Thick Shakes
Root beer is not just a side drink at this diner. It is one of the two things the restaurant is best known for, right next to the tenderloin.
The root beer is handmade, which sets it apart from the fountain soda found at most quick stops. Families often order a round for the whole table, kids included.
Root beer floats get a fan club of their own. Even people who normally skip floats have been won over by this version.
One small detail is worth knowing. Root beer is the only drink here that does not come with free refills, while other drinks do.
That makes sense once the drink is tried. Something made in house is a little more special than a standard soda.
Milkshakes also earn plenty of love. The strawberry shake has been called superb, and a thick shake paired with a tenderloin is considered the traditional order.
So when the menu board comes into view, save room for a cup of the house root beer. Skipping it would be like going to a ballgame and leaving before the seventh inning.
Onion Rings With a Loyal Following
Onion rings rarely steal the spotlight from a main dish, but here they come close. They are the second most mentioned item on the whole menu.
Many guests rank them among the best they have ever had. Some out of town diners put them in their personal top three.
The classic combo is simple. A breaded tenderloin with a side of onion rings is the order that shows up again and again.
Other sides have their own fans. Breaded or fried mushrooms come highly recommended, and they make a fun change of pace.
Crinkle fries are on the menu as well. On good days they arrive cooked fresh and crispy, though some find them fairly standard.
Chili and coleslaw get mixed opinions. Some call the chili decent, while others want more kick from it.
A broccoli and bacon salad is available for anyone wanting something a little different. Still, nothing on this menu claims to be health food, and that is part of the charm.
For the best results, follow the crowd. Order the rings, share them around the table, and see if they live up to the hype.
Coney Dogs, Tenders, and More
Not every member of the family wants a tenderloin, and the menu is ready for that. Coney dogs are a popular pick, especially for younger guests.
Hot dogs are one reason some grandparents bring the grandkids along. Kids meals are also available, which keeps ordering easy for families.
One note on those kids meals. The mac and cheese portion is small and in a familiar boxed style, so hungry kids may want an extra side.
Chicken tenders show up often in conversations about the menu. The chicken filet sandwich also gets high marks, and its bun is a standout.
Burgers are part of the lineup too. Bacon is charged by the strip, so a bacon cheeseburger means adding strips one at a time.
Condiments can cost a bit extra on sandwiches. Some guests wish the portions were a little more generous, so ask for extras if needed.
The menu is classic American diner food from top to bottom. It is the kind of place where everyone at the table finds something familiar, and where nobody leaves needing a snack an hour later.
Carhops and the Art of Eating Carside
Few things signal a time warp quite like a carhop heading toward a parked car with a tray. Here, that scene is still part of the daily routine.
Curb service runs out front. Guests drive up, park, and stay right in their seats while the staff takes the order and brings it back.
Order accuracy is described as pretty consistent. The service is often called quick and friendly, which keeps the carside line moving.
Eating in the car has a practical perk too. Families point out that it keeps the fried food smell from following them around for the rest of the day.
It also works well for anyone traveling with little ones who need their own space. A car can be a cozy private dining booth.
Parking can get tricky at busy times. Some drivers struggle with the stalls, so it helps to take the turn slowly and be patient.
Carside dining is the reason many people make the drive in the first place. Roll down the window, order like it is 1955, and let the carhop handle the rest.
A Free Jukebox Full of Oldies
Inside the dining room, the soundtrack is set by a jukebox. It plays oldies from the 1950s and fits the retro theme perfectly.
The jukebox has been described as free in recent years. Older memories include patrons dropping in a quarter while waiting for their number.
That small moment sums up the place well. An older gentleman taking off his coat and picking a song while his food cooks is pure diner life.
The dining area itself is large. It offers plenty of seating for groups, families, and anyone who prefers a table over a front seat.
Ordering inside works like a classic counter shop. Guests order at the front, wait for a number to be called over the speakers, and then pick up their food.
Decor leans fully into the 1950s style. Many guests love it, and it adds to the fun of the meal.
The space is often praised for being very clean and well kept, inside and out. That level of care helps the nostalgia feel fresh instead of tired, and it keeps the jukebox crowd coming back for one more song.
Car Shows, Families, and Regulars
Classic cars and a classic diner make a natural pair. The restaurant has been known to host car shows at this location, so checking its website before a visit is a smart idea.
Those events add another layer to the retro theme. Vintage cars parked near the carhop stalls fit right in with the setting.
The everyday crowd is a mix of people. Local regulars, families with young kids, and travelers looking for a true American diner all share the room.
The atmosphere is relaxed and comfortable. Nobody needs to dress up, and kids fit in easily.
The place feels family friendly in a simple way. Portions are fair for the price, and the menu covers picky eaters too.
One honest detail about the setting is worth sharing. The diner sits next to an industrial site, so the window view is not exactly postcard material.
That has never slowed down the crowds, though. People come for the food, the carhops, and the music, and the view outside becomes a small footnote once the tray arrives.
Smart Moves Before the Trip
A little planning makes the visit even smoother. Here are a few practical points pulled together from frequent guests.
Prices are widely seen as reasonable. The portions, especially the tenderloin, offer good value for the money.
Bacon is charged per strip, at about 89 cents each in the past. Extra condiments may also add a small cost.
Root beer does not include free refills, but other drinks do. Straws have occasionally been missing, so ask at the counter if needed.
Inside, listen for your number. Orders are called over the speaker, and guests pick up their own food.
Out front, park in a stall for carhop service. Take extra care when parking during busy hours.
Hours are not listed here, so checking the restaurant’s website or calling ahead before the drive is wise. The website is also where car show dates tend to appear.
For a first visit, keep the order classic. A breaded tenderloin, a basket of onion rings, and a cup of house root beer cover the essentials, and they give a clear picture of why this diner has lasted so long.
Is it worth the trip across town? For anyone who loves old school diners, curb service, and oversized sandwiches, the answer leans firmly toward yes, and a jukebox song on the way out makes the perfect encore.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.