Some people judge a diner by its coffee or its pancakes, but in Indiana a lot of us check the pie case first. The state has a long history with homemade pie, especially sugar cream, and small-town diners keep that habit alive one slice at a time.
This list covers seven spots from the northern farm country down to the courthouse squares of the south, each with its own reason to grab a fork. Some bake dozens of flavors a day, some sit in historic buildings, and a couple pair their pie with a tenderloin bigger than the plate.
You will find coconut cream, peanut butter, sugar cream, and plenty more along the way. Most of these places keep short hours and close early, so planning ahead helps.
Save this list for your next road trip, and maybe send it to the friend who always orders dessert first.
1. Storie’s Restaurant, Greensburg, IN
Greensburg is the town famous for a tree growing out of its courthouse roof, and Storie’s sits right on that downtown square at 109 E Main St. The setting alone makes it a fun stop.
Inside, the diner leans into a 1950s and 1960s look, with an old-school feel that matches the classic menu. Chicken-fried steak and a pork tenderloin share space with breakfast plates and coffee.
The real headliner is the homemade pie. Coconut cream gets the most attention, with a tall meringue-style slice that makes a strong case for skipping the side dish.
Prices land around $10 to $20 per person, and the staff keep things friendly. It works well for a solo breakfast or a family lunch, since there are high chairs and a kids’ menu.
Plan around the hours. Storie’s is closed Monday and Tuesday, open 8 AM to 2 PM Wednesday, Thursday, and Sunday, and stays open until 7 PM on Friday and Saturday.
Weekend mornings get busy, and reservations are not taken.
2. Mrs. Wick’s Restaurant & Pie Shop, Winchester, IN
Thirty-six varieties of pie in a single day. That number is the reason Mrs. Wick’s belongs near the top of any Indiana pie list.
The restaurant is connected to Wick’s Pies, a Winchester bakery name that dates back to 1944. If you have ever bought a sugar cream pie at an Indiana grocery store, there is a good chance you know the brand.
Sugar cream is the signature here, and ordering anything else on a first visit takes willpower. The case also rotates through a long lineup of fruit and cream flavors.
I would not treat this as dessert only, though. Breakfast is a big draw, the cheeseburgers have a following, and the chicken pot pie is a solid lunch pick on a cold day.
The diner sits at 100 N Cherry St and opens early, at 6 AM Tuesday through Saturday. It closes at 5 PM on weekdays and 2 PM on Saturday, and it is closed Sunday and Monday.
Reservations are accepted, and free Wi-Fi is available.
3. Nick’s Kitchen, Huntington, IN
Pie may be the reason you came, but the tenderloin will try to steal the show. Nick’s Kitchen is a small-town Huntington diner known for its breaded pork tenderloin sandwich, crispy outside with a light breading.
That sandwich pairs well with onion rings, and then the homemade pie closes things out. Many regulars make the trip to Huntington just for that one-two combo.
The menu stretches well beyond it. Look for huge pancakes, a Kitchen Sink Omelet, a Tenderloin Biscuit, chicken pot pie, and a taco salad.
The building has plenty of history, holding a classic storefront spot at 506 N Jefferson St. Service moves quickly, which helps on busy Saturday mornings.
Hours are simple: 7 AM to 2 PM every day of the week. Parking can be a little tricky to find, so give yourself a few extra minutes.
4. Oasis Diner, Plainfield, IN
Few diners in Indiana look more like a diner than this one. The Oasis was built in the 1950s on the Historic National Road, and its retro look still draws road trippers on US-40.
The kitchen makes homemade breads, buns, and pies, and the dessert lineup rotates. That means the pie case can change from one visit to the next, which is a good excuse to come back.
Here is a fun twist: handcrafted sodas. Flavors like butterscotch root beer and chocolate cola sit next to shakes and malts.
Portions run big, especially the BBQ sandwich, and there is a gluten-free menu too. The country fried breakfast and cinnamon roll are popular morning picks.
Find it at 405 W Main St. It keeps the longest hours on this list, open 7 AM to 9 PM Monday through Thursday, until 10 PM Friday and Saturday, and until 3 PM Sunday. Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are welcome outside.
5. Millie McGee’s Gosport Diner Restaurant, Gosport, IN
Bring cash. Millie McGee’s is a cash-only spot in Gosport, a small Owen County town with fewer than 1,000 residents.
The menu sticks to home cooking, with daily specials, catfish, and biscuits and gravy that get plenty of attention. Service is quick and the portions are generous.
Then comes dessert. The case carries pies and cheesecakes, and peanut butter pie is the one people talk about most.
Taking a slice or two home is common practice here, so leave room in the car. It makes a nice treat after a drive through the countryside near the White River.
The diner sits at 23 E Main St. Hours are limited: closed Monday through Wednesday, 7 AM to 2 PM Thursday, Saturday, and Sunday, and 7 AM to 7 PM Friday. Friday evenings tend to be the busiest stretch.
6. Howies Six Mile Restaurant, LaGrange, IN
Early risers, this one opens at 5:30 AM. Howies Six Mile sits on US-20 in LaGrange County, deep in northeast Indiana farm country.
The menu leans into hearty, Amish-style cooking. Breakfast haystacks are a specialty, and dinner plates come with big piles of mashed potatoes and cream gravy.
Dessert is a strong part of the lineup, which makes sense in a region known for homestyle baking. After a plate that size, a slice of pie is a bold but fair choice.
Prices stay friendly, and the service moves fast. The lot has room for trucks, so it is an easy stop for travelers heading along US-20.
It is open 5:30 AM to 7 PM weekdays and until 2 PM Saturday, with Sundays off. Reservations are accepted if you are bringing a group.
7. Cammack Station, Muncie, IN
Old gas pumps and automotive signs set the mood at Cammack Station, a vintage diner in the tiny community of Cammack just west of Muncie. The decor is half the fun.
The menu is built around signature breaded tenderloins and hand-dipped ice cream. It is ordered at the counter, which keeps waits short.
Dessert is a highlight, and I like this stop as the sweet finish to a list full of pie. A scoop next to your slice is never a bad idea.
The building was recently renovated, with plenty of space, outdoor seating, and a kid-friendly setup that even handles birthdays. The surrounding village has interesting old buildings worth a quick look.
Find it at 9200 W Jackson St. It is open 11 AM to 9 PM Tuesday through Sunday and closed Monday. Weekend afternoons draw the biggest crowds, so weekdays are calmer.
From sugar cream in Winchester to peanut butter in Gosport, these seven diners prove Indiana still takes its pie seriously. Pick one, check the hours, and bring an appetite.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.