Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Eight Old Florida Seafood Restaurants Where Fried Shrimp Has Been Served Since The 8s Or Earlier

David Coleman 7 min read
featured image 0535cf77ac11 b65899b999d8
Eight Old Florida Seafood Restaurants Where Fried Shrimp Has Been Served Since The 8s Or Earlier

Some Florida seafood spots have been frying shrimp longer than most of our grandparents have been alive. These are the places with mounted fish on the walls, river views out back, and menus that still lean on platters, hush puppies, and baskets of golden shrimp.

A few started as fish stands or river camps, and one began with a fisherman selling his catch off a boat. If you love Old Florida flavor with a side of real history, this list is for you.

1. Walt’s Fish Market Restaurant, Sarasota, FL

Walt's Fish Market Restaurant, Sarasota, FL
© Walt’s Fish Market Restaurant, Sarasota, FL

Back in 1918, a fisherman named Walt Wallin started selling local catches straight from his boat. More than a century later, that simple idea has grown into one of Sarasota’s best-known seafood stops on South Tamiami Trail.

The building has an industrial look, with mounted fish on the walls and an outdoor bar out back. It is casual and a little funky, which fits a place with this much history.

Shrimp fans should look at the Coconut Shrimp or the Captains Platter, a fried seafood spread built for big appetites. Hush puppies, clam chowder, lobster bisque, a Grouper Reuben, and a Snapper Melt round out the menu, and Key lime pie closes things out nicely.

Plan ahead a little. Walt’s does not take reservations, there is usually a wait, and parking can be tricky even with a free lot and street spaces.

It is open every day from 11 AM to 9:30 PM, with live music, a kids’ menu, and dogs welcome inside and out. Most meals land in the $20 to $30 range per person.

2. Aunt Kates, St. Augustine, FL

Aunt Kates, St. Augustine, FL
© Aunt Kates, St. Augustine, FL

Around 1900, Catherine Usina, better known as Aunt Kate, was serving local seafood along the North River. The restaurant carrying her name still sits by the water, and it still has that home-cooked, grandma’s-table charm.

The star here is St. Augustine fried shrimp, a nod to the town’s long shrimping history. Coconut shrimp and the Aunt Kates Seafood Platter give you even more ways to get your fix.

Not in a fried mood? Try shrimp and grits, crab cakes, she-crab soup, smoked fish dip, or the flounder club sandwich.

Fried green tomatoes and fried alligator tail add some Old Florida flair.

I would save this one for a slow lunch on the outdoor seating, where the river view does a lot of the work. Dogs are welcome outside, and parking is usually easy.

Hours run 11 AM to 9 PM daily. Weekday afternoons tend to be quieter, while Saturday afternoon and evening get busy.

3. Goodrich Seafood & Oyster House, Oak Hill, FL

Goodrich Seafood & Oyster House, Oak Hill, FL
© Goodrich Seafood & Oyster House, Oak Hill, FL

Oak Hill is a small river town most drivers zip past on the way to somewhere else. That is a mistake, because Goodrich has been feeding people on the Indian River waterfront since 1910.

The menu reads like an Old Florida greatest hits list. Frog legs, gator, fish chowder, Florida chowder, and smoked fish dip all share space with raw oysters by the dozen.

Coconut shrimp is a standout for shrimp lovers, alongside po’ boys and other Southern-style fried seafood. Blackened and grilled flounder are good picks if you want something lighter.

The covered back patio looks out over the river, which is reason enough to grab an outdoor table. Dogs are allowed inside and out.

Check the schedule before you go. Goodrich is closed Mondays, open 11 AM to 8 PM Tuesday through Thursday, 11 AM to 9 PM Friday and Saturday, and 11 AM to 5 PM on Sunday.

Reservations are accepted.

4. Rustic Inn Crabhouse, Fort Lauderdale, FL

Rustic Inn Crabhouse, Fort Lauderdale, FL
© Rustic Inn Crabhouse, Fort Lauderdale, FL

Garlic crab put this place on the map in 1955, and the crowds have kept coming ever since. Rustic Inn sits near the Fort Lauderdale airport in a big, busy building with a canal-side patio.

Crab is clearly the headliner, from Dungeness garlic crabs to Alaska king crab legs. Still, shrimp has a firm spot on the menu.

Look for Key West Shrimp or go big with the Fisherman’s Platter Family Style, which is made for sharing. Conch fritters, oysters Rockefeller, a chilled lobster roll, and Key lime pie are other popular picks.

Prices run higher than most spots on this list, roughly $30 to $90 per person. Reservations are accepted, which helps on Saturday nights.

Hours are 11:30 AM to 10 PM Monday through Saturday and noon to 9 PM on Sunday. Parking is free, and there is even a kids’ menu for younger crab crackers.

5. Alabama Jacks, Key Largo, FL

Alabama Jacks, Key Largo, FL
© Alabama Jacks, Key Largo, FL

You can arrive by car or by boat, and plenty of people do both. Alabama Jacks has been sitting on Card Sound Road since 1947, far from the busy stretch of the Overseas Highway.

The setting is the draw. It is an open, breezy spot on the water with live music, and manatees sometimes show up in the waterway.

Conch fritters are the famous order, but shrimp fans have choices too. Peel-and-eat shrimp, the Small Seafood Platter, fish fingers, and conch salad keep the menu simple and coastal.

This is the kind of place I would visit on a road trip into the Keys, when the scenic route sounds better than the fast one. Parking is plentiful, and dogs are welcome outside.

Keep the hours in mind, since they are short most days. It is open 11 AM to 7 PM Sunday through Friday and 11 AM to 11 PM on Saturday, with no reservations.

6. Joe’s Stone Crab, Miami Beach, FL

Joe's Stone Crab, Miami Beach, FL
© Joe’s Stone Crab, Miami Beach, FL

Here is a fun fact: Joe’s opened in 1913, before Miami Beach was even incorporated as a city. Joe Weiss started it, and it has become one of the most famous seafood restaurants in Florida.

Stone crab claws with the signature house sauce are the reason most people come. Key lime pie is the other must-order, and it shows up on a lot of tables.

Fried select jumbo shrimp and fried seafood platters have long been part of the menu too. Lobster roll, lobster mac and cheese, grilled tomatoes, and a chopped salad round things out.

Fair warning on the budget, since dinner can top $100 per person. Reservations are recommended, and there is usually a wait.

Lunch runs Wednesday through Sunday from 11:30 AM to 2:30 PM. Dinner starts at 5 PM nightly, and valet parking is available.

7. The Yearling Restaurant, Hawthorne, FL

The Yearling Restaurant, Hawthorne, FL
© The Yearling Restaurant, Hawthorne, FL

Not every great seafood stop sits on the coast. The Yearling has been serving country cooking in rural Cross Creek since 1952, and its seafood combination brings fried shrimp together with freshwater favorites.

Inside, the room is packed with books, curiosities, and taxidermy. There is a fireplace and live blues music, which gives it a real Old Florida personality.

Catfish comes fried or blackened, and frog legs are a top pick. Gator with honey mustard, quail, and venison show off the regional side of the menu.

Family groups will find plenty to like, from the kids’ menu to the library feel of the place. Parking is free and easy.

Hours are limited, so plan around them. The Yearling is closed Monday through Wednesday, open noon to 8 PM Thursday and Sunday, and noon to 9 PM Friday and Saturday.

Reservations are accepted.

8. High Tides At Snack Jack, Flagler Beach, FL

High Tides At Snack Jack, Flagler Beach, FL
© High Tides At Snack Jack, Flagler Beach, FL

Few Florida restaurants sit right on the beach anymore, and that is what makes this one stand out. High Tides at Snack Jack has been on the Flagler Beach oceanfront since 1947.

Shrimp shows up all over the menu. The 8 Piece Coconut Shrimp Dinner is a classic, and spiced steamed shrimp, peel-and-eat shrimp, and blackened shrimp tacos give you other options.

Conch fritters, smoked fish dip, redfish sandwiches, crab cakes, and a Key lime tart are also on the list. There is even a full vegan menu for mixed groups.

Dogs are welcome inside and out, and parking includes a free lot plus valet. Reservations are not taken, so arrive early on weekends.

Note the odd schedule. It is open 11 AM to 9 PM Friday through Tuesday and closed Wednesday and Thursday.

From Sarasota to Flagler Beach, these eight spots prove fried shrimp tastes even better with a side of Florida history. Save this list for your next road trip.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *