Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Eight Queens Bakeries Where New Yorkers Still Buy Cookies By The Pound

Hudson Walker 7 min read
featured image b5aea96784e7 53280a1798d0
Eight Queens Bakeries Where New Yorkers Still Buy Cookies By The Pound

Some New York traditions never go out of style, and a white bakery box tied with string is one of them. Across Queens, neighborhood bakeries still weigh out butter cookies, rainbow cookies, and holiday favorites on the counter scale, one pound at a time.

These are the shops people visit before family dinners, birthday parties, and big holidays. The list below covers eight of them, from old-school Italian counters in Bayside and Astoria to a Greek bakery and a European-style pastry shop in Ridgewood.

Each one has its own specialty, whether that is powdered kourambiethes, decorated gift bags, or cookie trays built for a crowd. Some are open late, some close early, and one takes Monday off.

If you have ever wondered where to pick up a proper cookie tray in Queens, this guide gives you eight solid answers worth saving and sharing.

1. Rudy’s Pastry Shop, Ridgewood, NY

Rudy's Pastry Shop, Ridgewood, NY
© Rudy’s Pastry Shop, Ridgewood, NY

A one-pound box of assorted butter cookies sits right on the menu at Rudy’s, which tells you plenty about how this Ridgewood shop works. The cookie counter is a big part of its identity, especially around the holidays.

The shop sits at 9-05 Seneca Ave and runs as both a pastry shop and a dine-in cafe with an espresso bar and free Wi-Fi. Beyond cookies, the case holds European classics like bienenstich, Black Forest cake, linzer tarts, and cheese and cherry strudel.

Black and white cookies and hamentash show up too, along with apple turnovers, cannoli, and raspberry tarts. Vegan and gluten-free treats are part of the lineup, which helps when your guest list has mixed needs.

Staff are known for being clear about nuts and allergies, a real plus when buying cookies for a group. Breakfast sandwiches and coffee make it an easy morning stop.

Hours run from 6 AM on weekdays, closing at 4 PM on Mondays and Tuesdays and 7 PM later in the week. Weekend mornings tend to be the busiest, so a Monday morning visit is usually calmer.

2. Panepinto Bakery, Middle Village, NY

Panepinto Bakery, Middle Village, NY
© Panepinto Bakery, Middle Village, NY

Fresh bread baked on the premises is what first brings many people into Panepinto. The Italian cookie counter is what keeps them lingering.

Located at 71-19 Eliot Ave in Middle Village, this roomy bakery and eatery covers a lot of ground. You can grab breakfast, a sandwich, espresso, or gelato, then leave with a box of cookies sold by the pound.

The selection is wide, with cookies sitting alongside cakes, macarons, and pastries. Acai bowls are on offer too, which is not something every old-school bakery can claim.

Cookie prices here lean toward the higher end, so it helps to know your budget before pointing at the case. The variety makes it an easy pick for gatherings.

Panepinto opens at 6:30 AM daily and stays open until 9 PM Friday through Sunday. It is dog-friendly, has a restroom and free Wi-Fi, and offers delivery and in-store pickup.

3. Framboise Patisserie, Middle Village, NY

Framboise Patisserie, Middle Village, NY
© Framboise Patisserie, Middle Village, NY

Gift-ready cookies are the calling card at Framboise. A pound of cookies here often leaves the shop in a cutely decorated bag, ready to hand over at a party.

This Middle Village patisserie at 64-59 Dry Harbor Rd is run by an award-winning baker. The shop is best known for custom cakes, but its cookie selection earns plenty of attention on its own.

The case also holds pies, cupcakes, Danish pastries, croissants, and bread. Outdoor seating gives you a spot to enjoy a coffee and a pastry before heading home.

I would save this one for the times when presentation matters as much as taste. A host gift in a decorated bag beats a plain box.

Framboise keeps generous hours, open 6:30 AM to 8 PM every day of the week. Free street parking is available nearby, though availability may vary.

4. Artion Bakery, Astoria, NY

Artion Bakery, Astoria, NY
© Artion Bakery, Astoria, NY

Powdered sugar is the giveaway here. Artion sells kourambiethes, the traditional Greek butter cookie dusted in sugar, by the pound.

That alone sets this Astoria bakery apart from the Italian counters on this list. Found at 23-18 31st St, Artion leans into high-end European-style breads, cakes, and pastries, plus Greek treats such as baklava.

The menu also covers savory items like vegan spinach pie hortopita and other cheese, meat, and vegetable bakes. That makes it handy for a lunch stop with a cookie run on the side.

The shop is beautifully decorated and the staff are helpful with choices. Note that there is no restroom on site.

Artion opens at 7:30 AM on weekdays, 8 AM Saturday, and 9 AM Sunday. Parking options include a free lot, which is rare in Astoria.

5. Lulu’s Bakery, Flushing, NY

Lulu's Bakery, Flushing, NY
© Lulu’s Bakery, Flushing, NY

Rainbow cookies get serious treatment at Lulu’s. You can find them as classic cookies, as rainbow cookie pastries, and in sheets sold by the pound.

This family-owned Italian bakeshop sits at 179-04 Union Tpke in Flushing. It has won awards and turns out homemade tarts, biscotti, and custom cakes.

Lobster tail pastries and tiramisu are part of the regular draw. Cake fans can look at Italian birthday cake, pistachio cake, and strawberry shortcake.

Holiday seasons bring creative specials, including chocolate cake with a biscoff cookie element. The counter staff are happy to suggest something new.

Gelato rounds things out for warmer days. Lulu’s is open 7:30 AM to 7 PM Monday through Saturday and closes at 5 PM on Sunday.

6. Lety’s Bakery and Cafe, Jackson Heights, NY

Lety's Bakery and Cafe, Jackson Heights, NY
© Lety’s Bakery and Cafe, Jackson Heights, NY

Late-night cookie cravings have an answer in Jackson Heights. Lety’s stays open until 9 PM most nights and 10 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.

The compact, art-lined bakery at 77-07 37th Ave weighs out its butter cookies and rainbow cookies over the counter. Heart-shaped raspberry and chocolate dipped cookies and pistachio cookies are standouts in the mix.

The rest of the case blends Italian classics with Latin favorites. Expect napoleons, biscotti, cannoli, tres leches cake, flan cheesecake, and fruit tarts.

Prices stay friendly, which makes buying a full pound less of a splurge. A quick tip: ask about the container weight when your cookies hit the scale.

Gelato and ice cream are available too. It opens at 6 AM daily, and mornings tend to be the quietest time to visit.

7. Joe’s Sicilian Bakery Inc., Bayside, NY

Joe's Sicilian Bakery Inc., Bayside, NY
© Joe’s Sicilian Bakery Inc., Bayside, NY

Old-fashioned is the right word for Joe’s. This Bayside bakery keeps things simple, with no dine-in seating and no delivery, just a counter full of bread, pastry, and Italian cookies.

You will find it at 212-16 48th Ave. The cookie trays are a big reason people come, beautifully arranged with traditional butter cookies, pinoli cookies, and rainbow cookies for celebrations.

Bread is the other star. Italian loaves, pizza dough, and filled breads with sausage and peppers, olives, or prosciutto all come out of this kitchen.

Napoleons, cannoli, cheesecake, and biscotti fill out the sweet side. Prices are known to be fair.

Plan around the schedule. Joe’s is closed Monday, open 7 AM to 6 PM Tuesday through Saturday, and closes at 2 PM on Sunday.

8. Rose & Joe’s Italian Bakery, Astoria, NY

Rose & Joe's Italian Bakery, Astoria, NY
© Rose & Joe’s Italian Bakery

Pizza and cookies under one roof is a strong combination. Rose & Joe’s has a back pizza counter serving regular slices and Sicilian corner pieces, while the front handles the sweets.

This classic Italian bakery sits at 22-40 31st St in Astoria. Platters of homemade butter cookies and rainbow cookies are its signature, sold by weight or as large assortments.

Chocolate chip pound cake is another favorite worth grabbing. A self-serve coffee station keeps the morning line moving.

Bring cash, because the bakery is cash-only. The staff are friendly and quick to help you build a mix.

Hours run 6 AM to 9 PM Monday through Saturday and until 6 PM Sunday. Friday mornings and Saturday afternoons draw the biggest crowds.

Eight bakeries, eight different reasons to grab a box. Whichever corner of Queens you call home, a pound of cookies is never far away.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *