Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Regulars Have Spent Nearly 20 Years At This Old-School Atlanta, Georgia Deli Known For Overstuffed Corned Beef Sandwiches

Cole Savannah 8 min read
featured image 6cc01c55008f dac4339f0d7a
Regulars Have Spent Nearly 20 Years At This Old-School Atlanta, Georgia Deli Known For Overstuffed Corned Beef Sandwiches

Some people eat at the same deli for a week, and some keep coming back for nearly two decades. At Gruby’s New York Deli in Atlanta, that second kind of customer is easy to find.

The draw is simple: tall stacks of corned beef and pastrami, warm matzo ball soup, and servers who greet you like family. I went to see why this tucked-away spot has earned such loyal fans.

A New York Deli Hiding on Johnson Ferry Road

A New York Deli Hiding on Johnson Ferry Road
© Gruby’s New York Deli, Atlanta, GA

Finding a real New York deli in Atlanta sounds like a long shot, but I found one at 860 Johnson Ferry Rd NE. Gruby’s New York Deli sits in a plaza in the Perimeter area, close to Northside Hospital.

It is easy to drive past if you are not looking for it.

Google describes it as a laid-back eatery for classic breakfasts, overstuffed sandwiches, soups, salads, and burgers. That list covers a lot of ground, and the kitchen seems happy to handle all of it.

Visitors give it 4.5 stars across more than 600 reviews, which is a strong showing for any neighborhood spot.

One guest admitted it was a little hard to find, tucked into the plaza the way it is. Once you spot the sign, though, the hunt pays off.

Inside, you step into a room that feels like it was lifted from a city block up north and set down in Georgia.

I liked that feeling right away. There was no fuss and no gimmick, just a deli doing what delis do best.

Two Decades of Loyal Lunches

Two Decades of Loyal Lunches
© Gruby’s New York Deli, Atlanta, GA

Nearly 20 years. That is how long one regular says they have been eating at Gruby’s, and they claim they have never had a bad meal in all that time.

Think about how many sandwiches that adds up to.

The same diner called the matzo ball soup and sandwiches the best in Atlanta. They also praised a server named Eddie and the rest of the crew for service that stays on point visit after visit.

The owner replied that guests who make Gruby’s part of their tradition mean more than words can say.

That kind of loyalty does not happen by accident. Restaurants come and go fast in a big city, so a place that keeps the same faces coming back for years is doing something right.

Another reviewer said everything is consistently delicious, with generous portions. Consistency is the quiet secret here.

You know what you are getting, and what you are getting is good.

Corned Beef Piled Sky-High

Corned Beef Piled Sky-High
© Gruby’s New York Deli, Atlanta, GA

Let me be honest: I came for the corned beef. It is one of the most talked-about items in reviews, with pastrami right beside it as the top topic people mention.

Sandwiches come in sizes, and the bigger one is called the Huge. One guest who drove 30 minutes for old-fashioned New York deli sandwiches told fellow big eaters not to be afraid of ordering it.

He said it was worth it and planned to get it again.

The owner has even mentioned a new size on the lunch menu called the Skyscraper, with any deli counter sandwich piled higher than the Huge. Whether you can finish one is another question.

Reviewers keep using words like large and generous to describe the meat. One visitor said the meat was very high quality and very tasty.

If you want a sandwich you need two hands and a plan for, this is your stop.

The Twin Towers and the Classic Reuben

The Twin Towers and the Classic Reuben
© Gruby’s New York Deli, Atlanta, GA

Two sandwiches seem to win the most fans at Gruby’s. The first is the Twin Towers, stacked with corned beef, pastrami, and coleslaw together.

One diner called it the best deli sandwich they have had in Atlanta, by far. Another ordered it in the Huge style and loved the quality of the meat, though they felt $19 for the sandwich alone was a bit steep.

That is a fair point, and I would rather you hear it from me than get surprised.

The Reuben is the other star, with 25 mentions in reviews. One visitor stopped in for a quick lunch, took the server’s suggestion, and finished the whole Reuben in five minutes.

That is quite the endorsement.

If you like pastrami on its own, a reviewer said the classic pastrami on rye was very moist, with crisp coleslaw on the side. Honestly, you cannot go too wrong at this counter.

Soup That Tastes Like Home

Soup That Tastes Like Home
© Gruby’s New York Deli, Atlanta, GA

A good bowl of matzo ball soup can fix a long day. At Gruby’s, it shows up in reviews again and again, with 18 mentions.

The longtime regular who has been coming for almost two decades named it the best in Atlanta. A father and daughter split a bowl and both called it great.

It is the kind of dish that tells you a deli takes its roots seriously.

Soup specials rotate too. One couple enjoyed a chicken noodle soup special alongside half a turkey sandwich.

Pair your bowl with a sandwich and you have the classic deli combo. On a chilly Atlanta morning, I cannot think of a cozier order.

Breakfast Done the New York Way

Breakfast Done the New York Way
© Gruby’s New York Deli, Atlanta, GA

Ask a transplanted New Yorker what they miss most, and many will say a proper bacon, egg, and cheese. One reviewer did exactly that, searched online, and found Gruby’s.

Biting into the sandwich on a real Kaiser roll brought them right back home.

Breakfast is a big deal here. Omelettes get lots of attention, from a Greek omelette to a corned beef omelette served with potatoes.

Home fries are another favorite side.

Bagels come up often too. One guest learned they are made in New York nearly done and finished baking on site.

The reviewer said it was chewy and soft, though not quite a true New York bagel.

Sweet tooth? A young diner loved the chocolate chip pancakes.

Another guest gave a shout-out to the real bacon. Not every review was perfect, as one visitor felt their breakfast lacked seasoning, but most people leave happy and full.

Sides, Knishes, and an Egg Cream

Sides, Knishes, and an Egg Cream
© Gruby’s New York Deli, Atlanta, GA

Here is a fun bit of deli history: an egg cream contains neither eggs nor cream. It is a fizzy chocolate drink beloved in New York, and one visitor from the city said to order one at Gruby’s.

That same guest called this the real deal deli they remember growing up, and went back twice in one week. Pretty convincing.

Coleslaw is the side people mention most. A cucumber salad also earned praise as homemade with excellent flavor.

One first-timer tried a potato knish and found it average, so your mileage may vary.

Fries split the crowd. One diner liked them and said they tasted homemade, while another really did not.

I would lean on the slaw or cucumber salad if you want a safe bet.

Old-School Vibes and Friendly Faces

Old-School Vibes and Friendly Faces
© Gruby’s New York Deli, Atlanta, GA

Walking in feels a bit like time travel. Reviewers describe cool, old school NY deli vibes, with great photos around the room to look at while you wait.

The dining area is spacious, with tables for groups from two to six. Several guests found it fairly quiet and peaceful, though one person thought it was loud.

Another landed in the middle, calling it low key with good energy and a solid crowd.

Service is where Gruby’s really shines. A server named Edward got so much love that one guest joked he deserved a raise or stock in the company.

A waitress once greeted a family like old friends and knew everyone’s name.

It works well for families, solo lunches, and folks waiting on someone at nearby Northside Hospital. One regular noted the place could use a face lift, but said it has great character.

I agree. The charm is part of the meal.

Hours, Prices, and Parking Tips

Hours, Prices, and Parking Tips
© Gruby’s New York Deli, Atlanta, GA

Plan ahead, because Gruby’s keeps daytime hours. Monday through Friday, it opens at 7:30 AM and closes at 3 PM.

Saturday runs 10 AM to 3 PM, and Sunday is 9 AM to 2 PM.

Prices get mixed reviews. One first-timer found them very fair for the quality.

Another guest paid $47 for two sandwiches, a bag of chips, and a fountain drink, and called it a high-end sandwich spot.

Parking is usually easy, with plenty of spaces in a quieter area than Perimeter Mall. Peak times can get tight, one diner warned.

You can dine in or grab food to go.

Call +1 404-236-0060 or visit grubysnydeli.com for the latest menu. Staff even took one couple’s order as closing time neared, but I would not count on that.

Worth the Drive for a Real Deli Fix

Worth the Drive for a Real Deli Fix
© Gruby’s New York Deli, Atlanta, GA

So, is Gruby’s worth your time? If you crave a sandwich stacked with corned beef or pastrami, I think the answer is yes.

It is not flawless. Some find it pricey, a few dishes get mixed reactions, and the room is a bit worn.

Still, 633 reviews averaging 4.5 stars tell a clear story.

People drive here from 30 minutes away. Visitors from New York find a taste of home.

And one regular has been showing up for nearly 20 years without a single bad meal.

My advice is simple. Come hungry, order the Twin Towers or a Reuben, add a bowl of matzo ball soup, and say hi to the crew.

You might just start a tradition of your own.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *