Every December, a quiet race starts at bakery counters across Missouri. People are trying to grab cookie trays before the shelves go bare and the order books fill up.
Some of these shops bake Italian cookies, some frost sugar cookies by hand, and one even sells cookies shaped like the state itself. Here are eight bakeries worth calling early, before the holiday rush beats you to the last tray.
1. Missouri Baking Co, St. Louis, MO

On The Hill, the Italian cookie variety tray is a holiday table regular. Missouri Baking Co sits at 2027 Edwards St, right in the heart of the neighborhood.
The cases hold almond dough cookies, chocolate macaroons, chocolate drops, and powdery snowballs. Cannoli, napoleons, baklava, and gooey butter cake round things out, along with rye and sesame bread.
Plan around the hours. The shop is open Tuesday through Saturday from 8 AM to 4 PM and closed Sunday and Monday.
Saturday mornings get busy, so a Wednesday or Thursday visit is calmer. Service is takeout only, with no seating and no restroom, but there is free parking nearby.
I would come here when the family wants cookies that taste like an old-school Italian Christmas. Grab a loaf of sesame bread on the way out, too.
2. Federhofer’s Bakery, St. Louis, MO

Some families build their holidays around one bakery, and in south St. Louis that bakery is often Federhofer’s. The family-owned shop on Gravois Road is known for decorated butter cookies.
Around each holiday, the counter fills with iced sugar cookies, gingerbread cookies, and assorted cookies sold by the pound. Buying by the pound makes it easy to build a mix for a big gathering.
The rest of the menu is classic St. Louis. Think gooey butter cake, apple crumb cake, cream puffs, donuts, and button cookies.
Hours are generous, from 6 AM to 6 PM Monday through Saturday and 7 AM to 3 PM on Sunday. Weekend mornings bring the biggest crowds, while weekday evenings are much quieter.
Parking is free on-site. It is a grab-and-go stop, so bring a box-friendly back seat.
3. McLain’s Bakery, Kansas City, MO

Since 1945, McLain’s has been baking for Kansas City. That kind of history means plenty of families have grown up with its cookies at the holidays.
The Waldo shop at 201 E Gregory Blvd turns out royal icing cookies, chocolate drop cookies, cake bites, and blueberry crumble bars. Bear claws, mini cheesecakes, and mocha cupcakes also show up in the cases.
Unlike many bakeries on this list, you can sit down and eat. Breakfast sandwiches, avocado toast, and a smothered burrito share the menu with lattes, and there is outdoor seating and free wi-fi.
The doors open daily from 7 AM to 2:30 PM. Weekend mornings are the busiest, so ordering trays ahead is the smart move in December.
4. Hot Box Cookies, Columbia, MO

Need cookies at midnight for a holiday party? Hot Box Cookies in downtown Columbia stays open until 12 AM most nights and 2 AM on Fridays and Saturdays.
The shop focuses on warm, fresh cookies and brownies. Flavors include oatmeal chocolate chip, peanut butter chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, cookies and cream, and monster.
For bigger crowds, the Cookie Brownie Platter is the go-to. The kitchen can handle big orders fast, with one order of 132 cookies ready for pickup within an hour.
Ice cream sandwiches, s’mores sandwiches, and milkshakes add a fun twist. Delivery and in-store pickup are both available at 1013 E Broadway.
5. The Urban Cup, Springfield, MO

Cupcakes may be the name of the game here, but December belongs to the Christmas cookies. The Urban Cup announces its holiday cookie orders on Facebook, and people pay attention.
The frosted sugar cookies with buttercream are the star. Watching a decorator work on Christmas cookies in the back is part of the fun.
Cupcake flavors include German Chocolate, Boston Cream Pie, and Mint Chocolate Chip. Gluten-free cupcakes like Cookies-n-Cream and Raspberry filled are also on hand.
Prices are friendly, usually $1 to $10 per person. The shop at 1952 E Grand St is open Monday through Saturday and closed Sunday, with free on-site parking.
6. Sugar & Slice Bakery on Main, St Charles, MO

Holiday shopping on historic Main Street pairs nicely with a cookie stop. Sugar & Slice sits at 519 S Main St in St. Charles.
Seasonal sugar cookies come decorated for Thanksgiving and Christmas. Hosts often stock up on assorted cookies for holiday gatherings.
Regular options include crunchy lemon, soft oatmeal raisin, and chocolate chip oatmeal cookies. Chocolate chip cookies run about $3 each, chewy in the middle and a little crisp on the edges.
Cheesecake slices, like Butterfinger and Blueberry Cobbler, plus cookie dough push pops make it more than a cookie counter. Note that it is closed Monday and Tuesday but open until 8 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.
7. High Rise Bakery, Jefferson City, MO

Cookies shaped like the state of Missouri are about as local as a holiday tray gets. High Rise Bakery in downtown Jefferson City makes them.
The scratch bakery also offers molasses cookies, cranberry walnut oatmeal cookies, and cinnamon rolls. Gluten-free options are available as well.
Trays are a real strength here. Advance tray orders are handled with care, even when arranged months ahead.
Breakfast burritos, waffles, biscuits and gravy, and rabbit hash make it a solid sit-down stop too. Hours run 7 AM to 2 PM on weekdays and 8 AM to 1 PM on weekends, and it does not take reservations.
8. Sugar & Spice Laura’s Delights, Montgomery City, MO

Early birds win in Montgomery City. Sugar & Spice opens at 5:30 AM Tuesday through Saturday and closes at 1 PM.
This small-town shop is a bakery, cafe, deli, and ice cream shop all in one. There is plenty of seating for breakfast or lunch.
Cookie fans can find nicely decorated sugar cookies and big, soft oatmeal chocolate chip cookies. Cakes, pies, muffins, and donuts fill out the counter.
The service is personal, the kind where a dozen cookies might be ready before you even ask. It sits at 305 N Sturgeon St, with free street parking.
It makes a good road trip stop between St. Louis and Columbia. These eight bakeries prove that a great holiday cookie tray is worth planning for, so call early and save this list for next December.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.