Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Ice Cream Never Goes Out Of Season At These 6 Indiana Dairy Bars Open Through Winter

Rachel Collins 6 min read
featured image c033222d4fa6 5884efdd40a9
Ice Cream Never Goes Out Of Season At These 6 Indiana Dairy Bars Open Through Winter

Plenty of Indiana ice cream stands lock their windows when the first frost shows up. The six spots on this list keep serving shakes, cones, and sundaes even when the parking lot has snow on it.

Some are drive-thru stands, some have seats inside, and a few serve coney dogs and tenderloins worth the trip on their own. If a cold-weather craving hits, this is the list to save and share.

1. Lizton Dairy Bar, Lizton, IN

Lizton Dairy Bar, Lizton, IN
© Lizton Dairy Bar, Lizton, IN

Lizton is home to fewer than 1,500 people, yet its dairy bar draws customers from across Hendricks County. The shop sits on a corner at a stoplight on Main Street, which makes it about as easy to find as a stop can be.

Thick milkshakes are the headliner here, with malts, cones, sundaes, and freezes rounding out the frozen side of the menu. Quick hot food is also available for anyone who wants a burger before dessert.

Keep in mind that this is a no-frills stop. There is no dine-in seating and no restroom, so plan on drive-thru, takeout, or curbside pickup.

The best news for winter fans is that Lizton Dairy Bar stays open year-round. Hours run 11 a.m. to 8 p.m.

Monday through Saturday and noon to 8 p.m. on Sunday.

Weekend afternoons get the biggest crowds. A weekday visit usually means a shorter wait for that shake.

2. Jimmie’s Dairy Bar, Pendleton, IN

Jimmie's Dairy Bar, Pendleton, IN
© Jimmie’s Dairy Bar, Pendleton, IN

Tangerine soft serve is not something you find at every Indiana stand. Jimmie’s Dairy Bar in Pendleton has made it a signature, and it is the flavor I would try first.

The soft serve comes in several flavors, and the menu also lists malts and banana splits. A chocolate malt here is a classic choice for anyone who likes to keep things traditional.

Jimmie’s is just as serious about food. The coney dogs, BBQ sandwiches, sloppy joes, and baked beans give the place a reputation that goes well beyond dessert, and the Facebook page even goes by Best BBQ in Indiana.

The setting leans into a 1950s look, which fits the drive-in style perfectly. There is indoor seating, outdoor seating, a drive-through, restrooms, high chairs, and a kids menu.

Hours run 10:30 a.m. to 9 p.m. every day, and the cold months do not slow things down. Expect to spend about $10 to $20 per person, and enjoy the free parking.

3. Auburn Dairy Freeze, Auburn, IN

Auburn Dairy Freeze, Auburn, IN
© Auburn Dairy Freeze, Auburn, IN

A one-pound order of fries is printed right on the menu at Auburn Dairy Freeze. That should give you an idea of how hearty things get at this locally owned stand on North Main Street.

The ice cream lineup is big, with a wide range of soft serve and some unusual combinations. Lemon raspberry swirl is a standout, and the Tornado treats and Turtle Parfait offer plenty of options for sundae lovers.

On the savory side, look for coney dogs, tenderloin sandwiches, pulled pork grilled cheese, loaded tots, BLT and tots, and nachos. Shaved ice is on the menu too.

Auburn Dairy Freeze is open year-round, from 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. Monday through Saturday and starting at 9 a.m. on Sunday.

Service runs through the drive-thru and walk-up, with some outdoor seating but no indoor dining or restroom.

It is a smart quick stop for anyone exploring DeKalb County.

4. B & G Dairy Bar and Grill, Sunman, IN

B & G Dairy Bar and Grill, Sunman, IN
© B & G Dairy Bar and Grill, Sunman, IN

Calling it a dairy bar almost undersells B & G. The Sunman spot carries a full grill menu with hamburgers, steak hoagies, and chicken fingers sitting right next to the ice cream.

Still, the cones are the reason many people come. The soft serve cones are known for being huge, and the shakes are noticeably thick.

Banana splits and snow cones fill out the dessert menu. Ice cream cones are the budget-friendly pick if you want to keep costs low.

Unlike some stands on this list, B & G offers table service, indoor seating, and restrooms. High chairs, a kids menu, and outdoor seating where dogs are welcome make it an easy family outing.

The dairy bar is open every day from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Reservations are accepted, which is handy for a group visit in this small Ripley County town of about 1,000 people.

5. J’s Dairy Inn, Liberty, IN

J's Dairy Inn, Liberty, IN
© J’s Dairy Inn, Liberty, IN

Gizzards, pizza burgers, and milkshakes on the same order are completely normal at J’s Dairy Inn. This independent dairy bar and diner in Liberty is one of the best values on the list, with most meals running $1 to $10 per person.

The pork tenderloin sandwich and fried chicken are menu highlights. The sandwich list is long, and the batter on the fried food gets plenty of attention.

For dessert, expect a strong selection of shakes and ice cream dishes at friendly prices. Service is quick and handled at the counter.

There is indoor and outdoor seating, restrooms, high chairs, and a kids menu. Dogs are allowed, which is a nice bonus for road trippers.

Plan around the schedule, though. J’s is closed on Wednesdays and open the rest of the week starting at 11 a.m., closing at 9 p.m. on Friday and Saturday and 8 p.m. on other days.

6. Bainbridge Dariette, Bainbridge, IN

Bainbridge Dariette, Bainbridge, IN
© Bainbridge Dariette, Bainbridge, IN

Ice cream purists, this one is for you. Bainbridge Dariette serves true high-fat ice cream instead of lighter ice milk, and that difference shows up in every cone.

The old-school stand in Putnam County offers shakes, malts, banana splits, and banana split flurries. Comfort food is on the menu too, and the fried pickles are a fun side to pair with something sweet.

Service is fast and friendly. Orders are handled as takeout or curbside pickup, and there is no restroom, so plan stops accordingly.

The Dariette is open Monday through Saturday from 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. and Sunday from 1 p.m. to 8 p.m. Free parking is available in the lot and on the street.

I would save this one for a drive along US 36 west of Indianapolis. It is a classic way to wrap up a winter ice cream tour of Indiana.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *