Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

These 7 Mississippi Supper Clubs And Old-School Steakhouses Still Feel Like A Night Out In 1965

Cole Harrison 7 min read
featured image 7ac6bdd178c6 eee737f82668
These 7 Mississippi Supper Clubs And Old-School Steakhouses Still Feel Like A Night Out In 1965

Some restaurants chase trends, and some never bothered. Across Mississippi, a handful of steakhouses and supper clubs still serve dinner the way it was done when a night out meant a big steak, a crisp salad, and a table you held onto for hours.

You might walk through a working kitchen to reach your seat, or eat a ribeye off a paper plate inside a general store that has stood since the 1800s. Others offer curtained booths, white tablecloths, and dining rooms that have changed very little in decades.

This list covers seven of them, from the Delta to the Gulf Coast, and each one earns its place for a different reason. A few are famous, a few fly under the radar, and all of them are open for dinner right now.

Save this one for your next road trip, anniversary, or any evening when a chain restaurant just will not do.

1. Doe’s Eat Place, Greenville, MS

Doe's Eat Place, Greenville, MS
© Doe’s Eat Place, Greenville, MS

The front door at Doe’s does not lead to a hostess stand. It leads straight through the kitchen, past potatoes, salads, and steaks being prepped for the night.

That walk sets the tone for the whole meal. The building is a humble old house on Nelson Street, and the dining rooms feel plain on purpose, with nothing trying to impress you except the food.

The porterhouse is the cut people plan their visit around, and the bone-in ribeyes come in serious sizes. Tamales are on the menu too, which surprises first-timers and delights everyone else.

Fries, fried shrimp, and a simple salad with a distinctive dressing round out the classic order.

Doe’s is open Monday through Saturday from 5 to 9 p.m. and closed Sunday. Reservations are recommended, especially for groups, and expect to spend roughly $40 to $100 per person.

If you want one meal that explains Delta dining, start here.

2. Giardina’s Restaurant, Greenwood, MS

Giardina's Restaurant, Greenwood, MS
© Giardina’s Restaurant, Greenwood, MS

Privacy was a big deal at old supper clubs, and Giardina’s still takes it seriously. Diners eat inside private curtained booths and rooms, a setup that gives the place its prohibition-era personality.

The restaurant sits on Howard Street in downtown Greenwood and is connected with The Alluvian hotel. The style is elegant, but it stays comfortable enough that families with kids fit right in.

Steaks lead the menu, often paired with grilled asparagus. Gulf seafood gets plenty of attention as well, including a fried Gulf shrimp appetizer, and Italian specialties like spinach manicotti nod to the restaurant’s roots.

Hours run Monday through Saturday from 5 to 10 p.m. Reservations are recommended for dinner, and parking is usually easy to find.

I would save this one for an anniversary or any night that calls for a closed curtain and a long conversation.

3. Old Hickory Steak House, Columbus, MS

Old Hickory Steak House, Columbus, MS
© Old Hickory Steak House, Columbus, MS

Menu anxiety is not a thing at Old Hickory. You get steak, a baked potato, a salad, and that is pretty much the whole story.

The steaks are cooked over an open charcoal grill, and the large ribeye is the order regulars point newcomers toward. Keeping the menu this tight lets the kitchen focus on doing one job well.

The building on Highway 45 North has an old roadside diner look, casual and unfussy. It is a hole-in-the-wall in the best sense.

Plan around the schedule. Old Hickory is open Tuesday through Saturday from 4 to 9 p.m., and it does not take reservations, so a wait is common on Friday and Saturday evenings.

Parking can get tight, too.

An early weeknight arrival is the smart play. Budget about $40 to $50 per person.

4. The Rustler, Meridian, MS

The Rustler, Meridian, MS
© The Rustler, Meridian, MS

Red walls, white tablecloths, a bar, and a fireplace. If you pictured a 1960s steakhouse in your head, The Rustler probably looks a lot like it.

Set on Old Highway 80 West, this is old-school Meridian through and through, an independent spot that stands apart from the chains clustered along the interstate. It is often family-run in feel, with an attentive, accommodating staff.

Prime rib and hand-cut steaks anchor dinner, and lobster tail is there for a surf-and-turf night. Crab dip and fried sliced mushrooms make good starters, and a red snapper special shows up for seafood fans.

Save room for dessert. The banana pudding cheesecake is a fun Southern twist.

Doors open Monday through Saturday at 5 p.m., and the kitchen wraps up at 8:30, earlier than many places. Reservations are accepted, and Saturday is the busiest night.

5. Mayflower Cafe, Jackson, MS

Mayflower Cafe, Jackson, MS
© Mayflower Cafe, Jackson, MS

Dating to 1935, the Mayflower is the oldest stop on this list, and the vintage neon out front on West Capitol Street makes that clear before you even step inside.

Inside, counter seating and classic booths keep the retro look intact. The menu leans Greek-inspired, with seafood and steaks sharing the spotlight.

The Captain’s Platter, soft shell crab, crab cakes, veal cutlets, and a hamburger steak all have loyal fans. Fried green tomatoes and comeback dressing, the Jackson-born sauce, add local flavor.

Bread pudding is the classic finish.

Unlike most places here, the Mayflower serves lunch, Tuesday through Friday from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. Dinner runs Tuesday through Saturday from 4:30 to 9 p.m.

Prices range widely, from about $10 to $60 per person, and there is a kids’ menu, so it works for a casual family dinner as easily as a date night.

6. H.D. Gibbes & Sons, Learned, MS

H.D. Gibbes & Sons, Learned, MS
© H.D. Gibbes & Sons, Learned, MS

A premium ribeye on a paper plate sounds like a mix-up. At H.D.

Gibbes & Sons, it is the whole point.

The restaurant operates inside a 19th-century general store in Learned, a tiny village with fewer than 100 residents. Quirky finds fill the rustic building, and community tables mean you may end up chatting with strangers.

Ribeye, New York strip, filet of beef, and lamb chops make up the main event. The baked sweet potato topped with butter, brown sugar, and cane syrup is a standout side, and spinach dip, bread pudding, and pound cake with strawberries round things out.

Hours take some planning. Lunch runs Tuesday through Saturday from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m., while dinner is served only Thursday and Friday from 5 to 9 p.m. and Saturday from 4:30 to 9 p.m.

Dinner reservations are recommended. Even with one, a short wait is common.

7. Mary Mahoney’s | Old French House, Biloxi, MS

Mary Mahoney's | Old French House, Biloxi, MS
© Mary Mahoney’s | Old French House, Biloxi, MS

Opened in 1964, Mary Mahoney’s has been serving Biloxi for about as long as this article’s title suggests. It fits the 1965 theme almost to the year.

The restaurant fills a historic building known as the Old French House on Rue Magnolia. Diners are seated in separate rooms, and the courtyard offers some of the most romantic outdoor seating on the Gulf Coast.

Seafood is the specialty. Back Room crab cakes, stuffed flounder, fried shrimp, Seafood Bienville, and Sisters of the Sea au gratin are signature dishes, while premium filets and escargot keep the supper club spirit going.

Service here is old-style and polished, the kind that remembers how formal dining used to work.

Hours are Monday through Saturday from 11 a.m. to 8:30 p.m., so lunch is an option. Friday and Saturday evenings get busy, and dinner reservations are recommended.

Taken together, these seven spots prove Mississippi never lost its taste for a proper night out. Pick one close to home, then start planning the road trip to the rest.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *