Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Hoosiers Still Drive Miles For Persimmon Pudding At These 5 Southern Indiana Spots

Rachel Collins 5 min read
featured image af72d7d82d87 18c5a7241e23
Hoosiers Still Drive Miles For Persimmon Pudding At These 5 Southern Indiana Spots

Ask anyone raised in southern Indiana about persimmon pudding, and you will probably hear about a grandma, a church supper, or a fall festival. The dense, spiced dessert comes from wild persimmons that grow across the region’s hills, and plenty of folks never outgrow the craving.

The good news is that you do not have to bake it yourself to get a taste. These five spots, from an ice cream stand to a hilltop dining room, keep persimmon pudding on the table for anyone willing to make the drive.

1. Dairy bell Ice Cream, Mitchell, IN

Dairy bell Ice Cream, Mitchell, IN
© Dairy bell Ice Cream, Mitchell, IN

Mitchell is the town that throws an annual Persimmon Festival, so it makes sense that its ice cream stand takes the fruit seriously. Dairy bell Ice Cream sits along IN-60 in rural Lawrence County.

The move here is persimmon pudding topped with soft serve. It is a simple pairing, and it works especially well after a day of hiking in the area.

Fall is the best season to stop by for it.

The rest of the menu sticks to the classics. Think shakes, sundaes, cones, and a banana split, plus coffee if you need a pick-me-up.

Plan a quick visit, since there is no table service and no restroom on site. The stand is dog-friendly and good for kids, with free parking.

Hours run 11 AM to 8:30 PM Monday through Thursday and until 9 PM Friday through Sunday, with Sunday afternoons drawing the biggest crowds.

2. Porkys BBQ of Paoli, Paoli, IN

Porkys BBQ of Paoli, Paoli, IN
© Porkys BBQ of Paoli, Paoli, IN

Barbecue and persimmon pudding might not sound like a natural duo. At Porkys BBQ of Paoli, they share the same table, and the combination makes a lot of sense after a plate of smoked meat.

Smoked ribs and brisket are the signature items. The menu also covers pulled pork platters, brisket sandwiches, fried pickles, mac and cheese, potato salad, and even pizza.

The dining room is packed with nostalgic memorabilia, which gives you plenty to look at while you wait. Persimmon pudding is the local-favorite way to finish the meal.

Families will find high chairs and a kids’ menu, and dogs are welcome at the outdoor seating. Expect to spend about $10 to $20 per person.

Parking is free and usually plentiful near 711 W Main St, and the restaurant opens at 11 AM daily.

3. Hilltop Family Restaurant, Spencer, IN

Hilltop Family Restaurant, Spencer, IN
© Hilltop Family Restaurant, Spencer, IN

Timing matters here. Hilltop Family Restaurant is closed Monday and Tuesday, opens at 4 PM Wednesday through Friday and 3 PM Saturday, and serves Sunday from 11 AM to 6 PM.

Once you line it up, the payoff is a long-standing, family-style spread of down-home cooking. Fried chicken leads the way, with smoked pork chops, turkey and stuffing with gravy, and homemade yeast rolls also on the menu.

Persimmon pudding is listed right on the menu, and it is part of a large dessert selection. I would save room, even if the portions make that tricky.

The setting along US-231 in Owen County adds scenic views, and the dining room has a fireplace and a cozy, historic feel. Reservations are accepted, which helps on busy Friday and Saturday evenings.

Call 812-829-3891 to plan ahead.

4. Brownie’s Bean Blossom Family Restaurant, Morgantown, IN

Brownie's Bean Blossom Family Restaurant, Morgantown, IN
© Brownie’s Bean Blossom Family Restaurant, Morgantown, IN

Road trips through Brown County often run along State Road 135, and Brownie’s makes an easy stop in the Bean Blossom area. It opens at 7 AM every day, so breakfast is on the table too.

The rustic dining room serves country comfort food. Fried chicken, pot roast, a breaded tenderloin, a catfish dinner, okra, and a sausage gravy omelet all show up on the menu.

Desserts get real attention here, with homemade pies like coconut cream. Persimmon pudding is part of the lineup, and the kitchen has also served a persimmon bread pudding, a fun twist on the classic.

Prices land around $10 to $20 per person. Parking is free, reservations are accepted, and kids are well covered with high chairs and a kids’ menu.

5. Mammas & Pappas, Bedford, IN

Mammas & Pappas, Bedford, IN
© Mammas & Pappas, Bedford, IN

Persimmon pudding in July is not something you find everywhere. Mammas & Pappas in Bedford has served it well outside of fall, which makes it a handy stop when the craving hits off-season.

Do not wait too long in the evening, though, since the pudding can sell out. It is a popular order.

The hometown diner is known for its fried chicken and an extensive salad bar. Coconut chicken, onion rings, sweet potato fries, and cheese curds round out the menu.

Convenience is a big plus. Mammas & Pappas offers dine-in, takeout, delivery, and even a drive-through, plus outdoor seating where dogs are allowed.

It sits on Mitchell Road and is open daily from 11 AM, so you can pair it with a Dairy bell run just down the road in Mitchell.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *