Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Bring An Empty Stomach To These 7 Ohio Amish Bakeries Before Christmas Week

Hudson Dayton 6 min read
featured image a8f598ee6440 a4310e87de32
Bring An Empty Stomach To These 7 Ohio Amish Bakeries Before Christmas Week

Holiday baking is a lot of work, and Ohio’s Amish bakers have been quietly doing it better than most of us for generations. Before Christmas week turns every kitchen into a flour-dusted mess, it makes sense to let someone else handle the pies, rolls, and cookies.

This list covers seven Amish bakeries across Ohio, from the busy backroads of Holmes County to quiet farm country in Hardin, Geauga, Wayne, and Adams counties. Each one earns its spot with something specific, whether that is giant apple fritters, fry pies, a wood-burning oven, or a whole shelf of canned goods.

Several keep limited hours and close on Sundays, so a little planning goes a long way. Grab a cooler, clear some counter space, and pick a route.

Your holiday dessert table is about to get a serious upgrade, and nobody has to know you did not bake it yourself.

1. Miller’s Bakery, Millersburg, OH

Miller's Bakery, Millersburg, OH
© Miller’s Bakery, Millersburg, OH

Out on Township Highway 356, far from town traffic, sits a bakery that runs without the modern conveniences most shops take for granted. The building is off the grid, with no running water or indoor restrooms, yet the parking lot still fills up.

The reason is simple. The baked goods here are big and fairly priced, and the selection runs deep, from fresh rolls and bread to cookies, pies, and homemade donuts.

The cheese tarts and apple fritters get the most attention, and both come in sizes that make sharing a smart idea. Fruit-filled tarts are another specialty worth grabbing for a holiday plate.

Shelves also hold jams, spices, dried fruits, pickled vegetables, noodles, and other canned goods. I would save a little cooler space for a jar or two, since they make easy gifts.

Hours run Monday through Saturday, 7 a.m. to 4 p.m. Saturday mornings are the busiest, so a weekday stop is the calmer choice before Christmas.

2. Amish Door Bakery, Wilmot, OH

Amish Door Bakery, Wilmot, OH
© Amish Door Bakery, Wilmot, OH

Apple fritter loyalty is a real thing in Amish Country, and plenty of fritter fans end up circling back to Wilmot. The village has fewer than 300 residents, but this bakery on Winesburg Street pulls steady traffic off State Route 62.

Fritters are the headliner, sold in boxes and sized to fill a plate. Whoopie pies and full homemade pies round out the classics.

The shop also carries a cheese and meat selection, which helps if you need snack trays for holiday company. One stop can cover dessert and appetizers.

Location is handy too. Berlin is about 15 minutes away, so it slides easily into a day of shopping around Holmes County.

Friday and Saturday hours stretch until 7:30 p.m., later than most bakeries on this list. Monday through Thursday, doors close at 6 p.m., and Sundays are off.

3. Kauffman’s Country Bakery, Millersburg, OH

Kauffman's Country Bakery, Millersburg, OH
© Kauffman’s Country Bakery, Millersburg, OH

Fry pies can be surprisingly hard to find, even in the heart of Amish Country. Kauffman’s, on County Road 77 outside Millersburg, keeps them on hand alongside a wide spread of breads and sweets.

What sets this bakery apart is its Swiss and European touch. Old-fashioned cream horns and Swiss rye bread sit next to local favorites like donuts, cream sticks, pies, and cookies.

The pumpkin cookies are a strong seasonal pick. Amish white bread, sometimes called wonderbread, is another staple worth adding to the bag.

Free samples make deciding a little easier, and the staff keeps things friendly. There is a restroom on site, plus a free parking lot.

Here is the big bonus for weekend planners: Kauffman’s is open seven days a week. Sunday hours run 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., which makes it a rare option when most neighbors are closed.

4. S & S Bakery LLC, Middlefield, OH

S & S Bakery LLC, Middlefield, OH
© S & S Bakery LLC, Middlefield, OH

Northeast Ohio has its own Amish heartland, and Middlefield sits right in it. Geauga County is home to the state’s second-largest Amish settlement, and S & S Bakery on Newcomb Road fits that setting well.

The menu stays traditional. Homemade bread, cookies, pies, and sweet rolls fill the shelves.

Pepperoni rolls are the curveball here. They make a handy savory snack between sugar stops, or a quick lunch for the car ride home.

Prices land on the low end, which is helpful when you are buying for a crowd. Service is friendly and the setup is simple.

Timing matters with this one. The bakery is open only Thursday and Friday from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. and Saturday from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m., so circle those days on the calendar.

5. Miller’s Bakery & Gifts, West Union, OH

Miller's Bakery & Gifts, West Union, OH
© Miller’s Bakery & Gifts, West Union, OH

Southern Ohio gets a turn too. Down in Adams County, Miller’s Bakery & Gifts on Wheat Ridge Road pairs a full bakery with a gift shop, which is a handy combo in December.

The donuts are huge, and the cookie lineup is broad. No bake cookies, peanut butter cookies, and oatmeal cookies are standouts.

Fresh bread and pies cover the holiday table basics. Kettle corn and hot pretzels add some snacking variety.

There is also a large selection of cold cuts and cheeses. That makes it easy to build a party tray in the same trip.

I like this stop for knocking out gifts and dessert at once. Hours are Monday through Saturday, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., and Thursday mornings tend to be quietest.

6. Mary’s Market, Kenton, OH

Mary's Market, Kenton, OH
© Mary’s Market, Kenton, OH

A wood-burning oven does the work at Mary’s Market, a small Amish bakery on County Road 265 in rural Hardin County. It is a long way from the Holmes County crowds, and that is part of the appeal.

Pies lead the lineup, with Dutch apple and strawberry rhubarb among the favorites. Cinnamon rolls, sweet rolls, and white bread come out warm and fresh.

Peanut butter cookies and peanut brittle add a little crunch. The market also sells lard, which serious home bakers may want for their own holiday crusts.

Prices are reasonable, and the setup is simple. There are no restrooms and no seating, so plan accordingly.

Watch the schedule closely. Mary’s is open Monday, Tuesday, and Thursday through Saturday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., with Wednesdays and Sundays off.

7. Troyer’s Home Pantry, Apple Creek, OH

Troyer's Home Pantry, Apple Creek, OH
© Troyer’s Home Pantry, Apple Creek, OH

Early birds, this one opens at 6 a.m. on weekdays. Troyer’s Home Pantry sits on West Main Street in Apple Creek, a Wayne County village of about 1,200 people.

Pies are the specialty, packed with fruit and set in a solid crust. Strawberry pie and apple crumb pie are two to look for.

Cinnamon rolls, cream sticks, and apple fritters keep the morning crowd happy. The creamy cheesecakes are another strong choice for a holiday dessert that feels a bit different.

Coffee, free Wi-Fi, and restrooms make it a comfortable stop. Parking is free.

Hours are Tuesday through Friday, 6 a.m. to 6 p.m., and Saturday, 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. It is closed Sunday and Monday, so a midweek pie run is the safest bet.

However you map it out, these seven bakeries can cover your whole holiday spread. Pick a route, check the hours, and go hungry.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *