Some restaurants win people over with fancy dining rooms. This one in Westbury did it with a small storefront, friendly staff and plates big enough to need a game plan.
Locals keep coming back for combination plates that pack several favorites onto one order, and the pickup bags arrive loaded with chips, salsa and limes. The room is tiny, the tables fill fast, and nobody seems to mind.
There is also a chef with a long Long Island story, a dessert that surprises people, and a parking trick worth knowing before the dinner rush. Keep reading to learn when to go, how to beat the Saturday crowd, what the bill looks like, and why families, couples and solo taco fans all treat this snug Nassau County spot as their regular stop.
A Small Storefront on Post Avenue

Little Mexico sits at 280 Post Ave, Westbury, NY 11590, right on one of the main village streets in Nassau County on Long Island, New York. It is a Mexican restaurant with a snug streetfront dining room and a busy to-go counter.
The setup is simple. The place is described as a small cantina with a tiny kitchen that turns out everything from fajitas to sopes.
Size is the first thing people notice. Tables are close together, and there is no real waiting area, so guests either wait outside or stand near the tables until a seat opens up.
That small footprint is part of the charm. It feels like a neighborhood spot rather than a chain, and locals treat it that way.
Post Avenue makes it easy to fold a meal into an errand run or an evening out in Westbury. The restaurant is close enough to the heart of the village that it works for a quick takeout grab or a planned sit-down dinner.
With more than 760 public opinions posted online and an average of 4.4 stars, it has clearly built a loyal following. So what keeps people coming back to such a small room?
The answer starts in the kitchen.
The Chef Who Worked Up From the Line

Every neighborhood restaurant has a backstory, and this one has a good one. One longtime fan has followed the chef’s cooking for more than 20 years.
That story goes back to the chef’s days as a minimum wage worker in someone else’s kitchen. Over time, the cook became the owner of this restaurant.
Loyalty like that is hard to fake. That same fan drives more than an hour as often as possible just to eat here.
A path from kitchen worker to owner says a lot about the place. It suggests a menu shaped by years of hands-on work rather than a corporate playbook.
It also explains why the food is so often called authentic. Many diners use that exact word when they describe their meals, from first-timers to people who have been coming for years.
Small kitchens tend to reflect the people running them. Here, the steady quality has become part of the identity.
Of course, a good origin story only goes so far. The real test is what lands on the table, and that brings us to the plates that made the place famous.
Combination Plates Built for Big Appetites

Indecisive eaters, rejoice. The combination plate solves the classic menu problem by putting several favorites on one platter.
Fans of the dish call it their top recommendation by far. It has earned repeat mentions as one of the standout orders.
Portions are a big part of the appeal. Plates here are known for being huge, and many people leave with more food than they expected.
The combo lets a newcomer sample a few classics in one sitting. That makes it a smart first order for anyone unsure where to begin.
Not every plate wins every heart. One family member found the combo platter just okay, while others rank it as the best thing on the menu.
That mix of opinions is normal for any busy kitchen. Still, the combination plate keeps coming up as a signature order tied to good value.
Price matters too. Diners often describe the restaurant as affordable and fair for the amount of food that arrives.
Big plates, fair prices and a cozy room make an easy formula. Next up is the menu item that might have the most loyal fan club of all.
Tacos With a Following

Some regulars have worked through every non-seafood taco on the menu. Their verdict is that the tacos are consistently great.
That consistency matters. A taco that is good once is nice, but a taco that is good every visit builds habits.
Al pastor gets its own spotlight. It shows up among the popular topics, and one diner called it really good, even if it was messy enough to need extra napkins from a helpful server.
Takeout taco orders are generous too. A pickup order of three tacos can come with rice and beans, plus a bag of chips, salsa and plenty of limes.
Tacos also show up again and again as a family favorite alongside the fajitas. They are easy to order, easy to share and hard to resist adding to the table.
Not everyone has loved them over the years. An older opinion found them below expectations, so tastes do vary.
Still, the steady praise in recent years points to a kitchen that has found its rhythm. Hungry for something that arrives with more flair?
The fajitas are waiting.
Fajitas, Chimichangas and the Rest of the Lineup

Beyond the combos, the menu covers a lot of ground. Fajitas, sopes, nachos, taco salad, burritos, flautas and chile rellenos all appear in the mix.
Chimichangas are one of the most talked-about items. Steak fajitas also earn regular mentions from people who come back for them.
The chicken gets strong praise as well. One regular called it fabulous and couldn’t resist showing it off.
Steak lovers should speak up about doneness. One frequent guest prefers medium well but often gets steak cooked well done, so a clear request helps.
Soups are another popular topic, with several people pointing them out. They make a good add-on for anyone building a bigger meal.
The queso fundido appetizer has fans too. It was described as very cheesy and a highlight of one couple’s date night.
Enchiladas suizas are served with sour cream on top rather than mixed into the sauce. One diner preferred the other style, so it is worth knowing ahead of time.
With this much variety, return trips rarely feel repetitive. Save room, though, because the dessert menu holds a real surprise.
A Dessert Surprise Worth Saving Room For

Here is a fun twist. The fried ice cream at Little Mexico comes with raisins, and that detail has won over at least one person who normally avoids them.
Fried ice cream shows up among the popular topics. For one family, it was the best part of the whole meal.
Sopapillas also have a following. One regular loves them but admits the main meal is usually too filling to fit dessert in.
That is the downside of huge portions. Planning ahead makes a difference.
A smart move is to share an entrée or take part of the meal home. That leaves space for a sweet finish.
Desserts at small places often get skipped, yet here they get real attention. They are a big reason some people recommend lingering a little longer.
Fruit drinks are another option. A papaya smoothie has been recommended as a refreshing pick for anyone wanting something different.
Dessert closes the meal, but the room itself shapes the whole visit. That cozy space deserves its own look.
Cozy Room, Lively Background

Cozy is the word that keeps coming back. The dining room is small, close and casual.
Mexican music often plays in the background. It adds to the relaxed mood without taking over the conversation.
Tables fill quickly, especially after opening and on busy nights. Being small also has an upside, since it is easy to flag down a server.
Some guests feel the space could use a deeper cleaning of seats and surfaces. Others say the food is good enough that any small inconvenience is quickly forgotten.
The mood works for a low-key night. One couple searching for a new spot found the music, food and service all came together for a lovely date night.
There is no fancy lobby or hostess stand area. Waiting happens outside or near the tables, which is part of the neighborhood feel.
For people who like big, quiet dining rooms, it may feel tight. For those who like a lived-in local hangout, it fits right in.
A cozy room is only as good as the people working in it. Fortunately, that is where this place really shines.
Friendly Faces Behind the Counter

Ask regulars what stands out, and the staff comes up fast. Words like friendly and helpful appear again and again.
Servers are described as warm without hovering. One family praised the team for being non-intrusive and timing everything well.
Small kindnesses add up. A server once brought extra napkins to help with a messy al pastor order.
Takeout gets the same attention. Pickup orders come packed with extras like chips, salsa and limes.
Mistakes can happen anywhere. In one older case, a bill was miscalculated, but it was fixed quickly once pointed out, so checking the total is always wise.
The staff has a lot to do with why people treat this as a go-to. Good food brings people in, and good service makes them feel like regulars.
Many guests mention returning again and again, and the team seems to know it. That steady care keeps the room feeling neighborly.
Speaking of feeling at home, families have found a lot to like here too.
Room at the Table for Families

When a 6-year-old and a 10-year-old ask to come back, that says plenty. One family of six had exactly that happen after a Saturday dinner.
Their strategy was simple. They arrived at 5 PM to beat the evening crowd, and everyone loved their meals.
Groups can be seated, though timing matters. Another party of six got a table by showing up shortly after opening.
The menu works well for mixed tastes. Tacos, burritos, nachos and combination plates give picky eaters and adventurous ones plenty of choices.
Big portions are a bonus for families. Sharing plates or taking leftovers home stretches the budget.
The small room does mean less space for strollers or big groups at peak times. Calling ahead or arriving early helps.
Couples, friend groups and solo diners all show up too. The place suits almost anyone who wants a casual, filling meal.
So when exactly should a family plan its trip? The schedule holds a few things worth knowing.
When the Doors Open

Mondays are off the table. Little Mexico is closed that day, so plan accordingly.
Tuesday through Thursday, hours run from 12 PM to 9 PM. Friday and Saturday stretch later, from 12 PM to 10 PM.
Sunday hours return to 12 PM to 9 PM. Hours may vary on holidays, so checking the restaurant website before a trip is smart.
Timing matters in a small room. Weekend evenings fill quickly, and there is not much space to wait.
Early dinners are a proven move. Arriving around opening or in the late afternoon tends to make seating easier.
Lunch is another option for avoiding the rush. The noon opening makes a midday combo plate very doable.
Takeout is a strong backup plan. Pickup orders are generous and well packed, which makes them a good choice on crowded nights.
Once the timing is set, the next question is getting there and parking. Luckily, there is a helpful tip for that.
The Parking Secret Out Back

Circling Post Avenue looking for a spot is no fun. The good news is that there is parking in the rear.
Guests call the back parking super convenient. It is one of the most useful tips for a first visit.
Street parking is also available out front. Much of it is metered, so bringing a way to pay is a good idea.
Meters are sometimes free at certain times. One diner found free metered parking on a Friday night, though rules can change, so check posted signs.
Westbury is in Nassau County, making it reachable from many parts of Long Island. Some fans even drive over an hour to eat here.
Pickup customers benefit from the parking setup as well. A quick stop out back makes grabbing an order easy.
Planning ahead saves time and stress. That way, more energy goes toward the menu instead of the curb.
Once parked and seated, the final detail to sort out is the bill.
What the Bill Looks Like

Good value is one of the biggest reasons this spot became a local habit. Diners regularly describe the prices as fair, reasonable and affordable.
Huge portions make the cost feel even better. Many meals come with rice and beans, and takeout orders often include chips and salsa.
Card users should know one detail. There may be an extra charge for paying with a debit or credit card, a policy common at smaller restaurants.
Carrying cash can help avoid that fee. It is a simple step that keeps the total lower.
As with any busy restaurant, a quick look at the check before paying is a good habit. Errors are rare, but they are easy to fix when spotted.
The menu and current prices can be found on the restaurant website. Prices may change over time, so it is worth a look before ordering.
Fair prices plus big plates explain much of the loyalty here. That leaves one question: is this little room worth the trip?
Why Westbury Keeps Coming Back

Small rooms can leave big impressions. Little Mexico proves it with full tables, loyal regulars and plates that rarely leave anyone hungry.
The combination plate is the easy starting point. Tacos, fajitas and chimichangas give plenty of reasons to return and try something new.
Not every dish wins every guest. Some sauces, steak orders or older experiences have drawn mixed opinions.
Even so, the overall picture is strong. A 4.4-star average across hundreds of posted opinions shows steady satisfaction.
Friendly staff, fair prices and a long-serving chef give the place real heart. It feels like a neighborhood spot because it truly is one.
A few tips make the visit smoother. Skip Mondays, arrive early on weekends, use the rear lot and bring cash to avoid card fees.
For takeout, expect a well-stocked bag. For dine-in, expect a cozy table and a good chance of leftovers.
In a region full of choices, this Post Avenue favorite has earned its place. One big plate at a time, it keeps turning first-timers into regulars.
Enjoyed this story?
Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.