Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

Grandma’s Recipe Box Lives On At These 6 Indiana Church-Basement-Style Diners

Rachel Collins 5 min read
featured image b1ccd446d1f6 dcdc7f7bd577
Grandma's Recipe Box Lives On At These 6 Indiana Church-Basement-Style Diners

Some meals taste like a potluck after Sunday service, with pie on every table and gravy on everything. Indiana still has diners that cook that way, and they are worth knowing about.

These six spots serve meatloaf, beef and noodles, fried chicken, and homemade pies in plain, friendly rooms. Save this list for your next road trip, because Grandma’s recipe box is still open for business.

1. Millie McGee’s Gosport Diner Restaurant, Gosport, IN

Millie McGee's Gosport Diner Restaurant, Gosport, IN
© Millie McGee’s Gosport Diner Restaurant, Gosport, IN

Real fried potatoes are the kind of detail that tells you a kitchen cares. At this Main Street diner in Gosport, home-cooked plates, catfish, and homemade pies set the tone.

Daily specials rotate, and the homemade desserts are a big reason people linger over coffee. Biscuits and gravy anchor the breakfast side of the menu.

Portions run large and prices stay low, usually around $10 to $20 per person. The room is casual, quiet, and comfortably small-town.

Plan ahead, because the schedule is short. It is closed Monday through Wednesday, open 7 AM to 2 PM Thursday and weekends, and stays open until 7 PM on Fridays.

Friday evenings and Saturday mornings get busiest, and reservations are not taken. Parking is free and usually easy to find.

2. Nick’s Kitchen, Huntington, IN

Nick's Kitchen, Huntington, IN
© Nick’s Kitchen, Huntington, IN

Ask any Hoosier where the tenderloin sandwich matters most, and Huntington comes up fast. Nick’s Kitchen sits on N Jefferson St downtown, serving its signature breaded pork tenderloin with a light, crispy coating.

Longtime regulars say the sandwich tastes the way it did decades ago, and that kind of loyalty is hard to fake.

The rest of the menu reads like a church supper sign-up sheet. Chicken pot pie, a meatloaf sandwich with fries, a tenderloin biscuit, and huge pancakes all make appearances.

Fresh homemade pie closes things out, and the onion rings deserve a spot on the table too. The room has a retro, historic feel with quick, friendly service.

Hours are 7 AM to 2 PM every day. Saturday mornings get crowded, and parking can be a little tricky, so weekdays are the easier bet.

3. Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery, Shipshewana, IN

Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery, Shipshewana, IN
© Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery, Shipshewana, IN

If your favorite part of a church potluck was the noodle dish, Shipshewana is calling. Blue Gate is a family-owned country kitchen and bakery next to an Amish crafts marketplace.

The buffet lineup reads like a fellowship hall table. Fried chicken, meatloaf, Amish noodles, chicken and beef noodles, stuffing, sweet corn, green beans, mac and cheese, and two soups often appear.

Noodles with chicken gravy over mashed potatoes may be the house’s finest comfort move. Pot roast and a salad bar round things out, with honey French dressing on the side.

Then come the pies. Blueberry, lemon meringue, and pumpkin are among the bakery picks, plus cookies and apple butter to take home.

Hours run 10:30 AM to 7 PM, Monday through Saturday, and it is closed Sunday. Expect a wait at busy times, so weekday mornings are the calmer choice.

4. Storie’s Restaurant, Greensburg, IN

Storie's Restaurant, Greensburg, IN
© Storie’s Restaurant, Greensburg, IN

Butterscotch pie is getting harder to find, which makes this Greensburg stop a little precious. Storie’s sits at 109 E Main St on the Courthouse Square.

The room leans 50s and 60s, with a mom-and-pop feel and old-school charm. Plate lunch specials are a big draw.

Chicken-fried steak, a ham steak dinner, pork tenderloin sandwiches, and onion rings fill out the comfort side. Sweet tea pairs nicely with almost all of it.

Hours are Wednesday, Thursday, and Sunday from 8 AM to 2 PM, with Friday and Saturday open until 7 PM. It is closed Monday and Tuesday.

Saturday mornings are busiest, and reservations are not accepted. Free parking is usually easy.

5. Mayberry Cafe, Danville, IN

Mayberry Cafe, Danville, IN
© Mayberry Cafe, Danville, IN

Aunt Bee would feel right at home here. Mayberry Cafe in downtown Danville is inspired by The Andy Griffith Show, and reruns play while you eat.

Fried biscuits with apple butter are the opener to try. Country fried steak with mashed potatoes and gravy may be the most talked-about plate on the menu.

Fried chicken dinners, catfish, Floyd’s Catfish Sandwich, chicken pot pie, and a Roast Beef Manhattan Dinner keep the Sunday supper theme going. Save room for dessert.

Hours run later than most on this list. It is open 11 AM to 9 PM Tuesday through Friday, 8 AM to 9 PM on weekends, and closed Monday.

Reservations are accepted, which helps on busy Sunday afternoons. Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are welcome there.

6. Steer-In, Indianapolis, IN

Steer-In, Indianapolis, IN
© Steer-In, Indianapolis, IN

Big city, small-town cooking. Steer-In on E 10th St is a long-running Indianapolis fixture that has appeared on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives.

Beef and noodles with mashed potatoes and gravy is pure church-basement comfort. The Hoosier Tenderloin carries the state flag for sandwiches.

Breakfast brings well-seasoned biscuits and sausage gravy, plus corned beef hash and the Split Decision Breakfast. Coconut cream pie is the slice to remember.

The menu is huge, with pizza, meatball sandwiches, and onion rings too. A drive-through adds convenience.

Hours are 7 AM to 3 PM Monday and 7 AM to 8 PM the rest of the week. Reservations are accepted, and free parking is easy to find.

Enjoyed this story?

Add Fast Food Club as a preferred source to see more of our reporting on Google.

Follow us on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *