Indiana’s most legendary tenderloin isn’t at a fairground—it’s sizzling at Nick’s Kitchen in downtown Huntington. This humble American restaurant plates a cutlet so massive it eclipses the bun and spills over the edge like a delicious dare. With 4.5 stars across 1,283 reviews, locals and road-trippers agree it’s worth planning a detour. Come hungry, stay for pie, and discover why this small-town icon still sets the standard for Hoosier comfort food.
The Iconic Tenderloin That Started It All
At Nick’s Kitchen, the breaded pork tenderloin is more than a sandwich—it’s an origin story. Pounded thin, breaded to a golden crunch, and fried to order, the cutlet hangs dramatically off the plate. Bite in to discover a juicy, tender interior contrasted with crisp, seasoned edges. Order it full-size or as a mini if you must, but sharing is smart. Classic toppings—lettuce, pickles, onion, and mustard—let the pork shine. Regulars praise its balance of crunch and moisture, never dry. It’s the definitive Hoosier tenderloin, served where the legend began.
TrendingNow
Inside the Small-Town Diner With Big Flavor
Nick’s Kitchen blends nostalgic charm with hustle. The room hums at noon as locals and travelers pack the counter and booths. Servers move fast, often offering to split the giant tenderloin and set toppings on the side—small touches that feel thoughtful. Expect fair prices, friendly chatter, and an open-kitchen rhythm. Though sides vary by taste, the star never wavers. Come early; they open at 7 AM and close mid-afternoon. It’s the kind of place where staff remember faces and pie orders. In short: hometown heart, destination-worthy bite.
How to Order Like a Local
First-timers should go full-size tenderloin if sharing, or mini for solo appetites. Ask for toppings on the side to preserve the crunch and customize each bite. Pair with onion rings, fries, or mashed potatoes—then save room for pie. Regulars grab a counter seat for the show and quick service. If mornings are your jam, try the tenderloin biscuit with gravy—hearty, peppery, and beloved. Keep an eye on the daily pie lineup; sugar cream is a must. Arrive before the lunch rush for shorter waits and maximum crisp.
What the Reviews Really Say
Across hundreds of ratings, a clear theme emerges: the tenderloin delivers on crunch, size, and juiciness. Guests praise warm, attentive service—even during the lunch rush—while noting some sides can be hit-or-miss. Pies earn raves, especially sugar cream, peanut butter, and buckeye. One reviewer lauded the staff’s proactive touches, like splitting sandwiches and adjusting toppings. Another celebrated the tenderloin biscuit smothered in gravy. Even skeptical visitors left impressed by the moist interior beneath that signature golden crust. Overall, consistent hospitality and a legendary cutlet make repeat visits a given.
Sugar Cream Pie: Indiana’s Sweet Finish
Don’t leave without dessert. Nick’s sugar cream pie—a Hoosier classic—arrives silky, custardy, and gently caramelized, with a tender crust that holds its shape. Some days, a pie flight tempts with peanut butter and buckeye slices, but sugar cream remains the benchmark. Fans recommend snagging a fresh slice in-house for peak texture, and grabbing a to-go piece if you must. It’s the kind of simple, nostalgic sweetness that pairs perfectly after a savory, crunchy tenderloin. One bite and you’ll understand why locals rank it among Indiana’s best.
Plan Your Visit: Hours, Price, and Logistics
Nick’s Kitchen keeps early-bird hours: open daily 7 AM–2 PM. Prices are friendly—most meals land between $10 and $20. Expect a bustling lunch, especially on weekends, so consider off-peak times. The restaurant sits at 506 N Jefferson St, Huntington, IN, with parking nearby. Call +1 260-356-6618 to confirm daily specials or pie availability. The vibe is casual, quick, and family-friendly. Whether you’re road-tripping through northeast Indiana or making a pie pilgrimage, Nick’s makes planning easy—and the tenderloin makes it unforgettable.
Beyond the Bun: Breakfast and Comfort Classics
While the tenderloin steals the spotlight, breakfast at Nick’s is pure comfort. Locals praise the tenderloin biscuit with rich gravy, as well as waffles, eggs, and homestyle potatoes. Lunch brings hearty sides—mashed potatoes, fries, onion rings, and fried mushrooms—plus simple diner staples. Portions satisfy without pretense. Coffee is hot, refills are quick, and the pace stays lively. It’s a menu that honors Midwestern roots and keeps flavors straightforward. Add a slice of pie and you’ll understand why regulars keep the tradition alive.
Why This Tenderloin Endures
Nick’s secret isn’t flashy—just time-tested technique and respect for the cut. The pork stays moist because it’s thin yet not overcooked, with a seasoned breading that crisps without greasiness. Toppings are kept classic to highlight the meat, and service culture ensures each plate feels considered. Add fair prices, consistent execution, and a dessert program locals champion, and you have staying power. In a state that loves its tenderloins, Nick’s remains the reference point—the benchmark others chase and the sandwich worth the drive.
Discussion about this post