Experience the tangy delight of Key Lime Pie across Florida’s finest spots. Each bite offers a unique twist on this classic dessert, making every stop a must-visit for pie enthusiasts.
Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory – Tavernier, FL
Nestled in Tavernier, the Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory offers a vibrant atmosphere infused with tropical charm. The pies here are known for their perfect balance of tartness and sweetness, crafted with fresh ingredients.
Visitors can enjoy their slice under swaying palm trees, making it an iconic Keys experience. With each bite, the creamy texture and crispy crust deliver a memorable treat.
The factory also offers a variety of key lime products, from candies to sauces, ensuring there’s something for every palate. It’s a slice of paradise in pie form.
TrendingNow
Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe – Key West, FL
In the heart of Key West, Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe is a vibrant destination for pie lovers. The shop’s quirky, lime-green decor instantly catches the eye, inviting guests to explore its wide array of offerings.
Kermit’s pies are celebrated for their zesty flavor and smooth filling, topped with a dollop of whipped cream. Each slice captures the essence of the island’s citrusy splendor.
Beyond pies, the shop boasts a selection of key lime treats, including sauces and candies, making it a delightful stop for anyone with a sweet tooth.
Blue Heaven – Key West, FL
Blue Heaven in Key West offers more than just a meal; it provides an experience steeped in island charm. Known for its laid-back atmosphere, this spot is famous for its towering key lime pie.
With a meringue topping that’s as delightful as the pie itself, Blue Heaven’s version is both a visual and culinary treat. The lively setting, complete with roaming chickens, adds to the unique dining vibe.
It’s a place where the sun-kissed flavors of the pie perfectly match the tropical ambiance, creating a memorable visit.
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen – Key Largo, FL
At Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen in Key Largo, the warm, homey setting is as comforting as its delicious key lime pies. This beloved diner boasts a rich history and a recipe that patrons swear by.
The pie here is known for its refreshing taste and buttery crust, providing a slice of comfort with every forkful. The addition of whipped cream adds a delightful finish.
Decorated with vintage memorabilia, the diner invites guests to relax and enjoy a piece of Floridian nostalgia alongside their dessert.
The Fish House – Key Largo, FL
The Fish House in Key Largo combines fresh seafood with a delightful slice of key lime heaven. Known for its nautical decor, this restaurant offers a coastal vibe that complements its culinary offerings.
Their key lime pie stands out for its vibrant, citrusy flavor, perfectly offset by a crunchy, graham cracker crust. It’s a refreshing end to any seafood feast.
Surrounded by maritime charm, guests enjoy their pie in an ambiance that feels both lively and relaxing, capturing the essence of the Keys.
Lazy Days Restaurant – Islamorada, FL
Lazy Days Restaurant in Islamorada is a laid-back spot where guests can savor key lime pie while enjoying breathtaking ocean views. The restaurant’s relaxed ambiance is perfect for unwinding.
Known for its creamy filling and tangy zest, the pie here is a taste of the tropics on a plate. Each bite is enhanced by the gentle sea breeze.
The beachside setting makes it an ideal location to indulge in this Floridian classic, offering a serene escape with every forkful.
The Green Turtle Inn – Islamorada, FL
The Green Turtle Inn in Islamorada blends history with culinary excellence. This storied establishment is renowned for its refined take on key lime pie.
The pie’s smooth texture and bold lime flavor are complemented by a delicate crust, creating a sophisticated dessert experience. Each slice is a testament to the inn’s culinary heritage.
With its cozy interior and vintage flair, the Green Turtle Inn offers a slice of elegance and nostalgia, making it a must-visit for dessert enthusiasts.
Mangrove Mama’s – Summerland Key, FL
Mangrove Mama’s on Summerland Key offers a charming, garden-like setting where guests can enjoy generous servings of key lime pie. This quaint spot is known for its vibrant and welcoming atmosphere.
The pie here boasts a rich, tangy filling paired with a perfectly crumbly crust, making for a satisfying treat. The addition of fresh cream elevates the dessert experience.
Surrounded by lush greenery, diners find a peaceful retreat where the flavors of the pie harmonize with the natural beauty.
Castaway Waterfront Restaurant – Marathon, FL
Castaway Waterfront Restaurant in Marathon serves key lime pie with a side of oceanfront charm. Known for its welcoming atmosphere, this spot is perfect for enjoying a hearty slice.
The pie’s creamy filling and zesty lime essence are a highlight, complemented by a robust crust. Each bite is a celebration of Florida’s citrusy delight.
With nautical accents and serene views, Castaway offers an inviting space where the flavors of the pie are only matched by the beauty of the surroundings.
Key Lime Pie Bakery – Key West, FL
Key Lime Pie Bakery in Key West is a nostalgic gem, offering a classic take on this beloved dessert. The bakery’s vintage charm draws visitors in for a taste of tradition.
Renowned for its authentic key lime pie, the bakery uses fresh ingredients to achieve the perfect balance of sweetness and citrusy tang.
Each slice is a tribute to the Keys’ rich culinary heritage, served in a setting that invites guests to savor both the pie and the history of Key West’s baking traditions.
Old Town Bakery – Key West, FL
Old Town Bakery in Key West captures the essence of artisanal baking with its renowned key lime pies. This rustic spot is celebrated for its hand-crafted desserts.
The pie stands out with its lush lime filling and meticulously prepared crust, offering a delightful contrast of textures and tastes.
In a setting that feels warm and inviting, guests are encouraged to indulge in the bakery’s creations, taking a moment to appreciate the craftsmanship behind each slice.
Mattheessen’s – Key West, FL
Mattheessen’s in Key West is a sweet lover’s haven, known for its oversized key lime pies. This bustling shop exudes a vintage charm that beckons dessert enthusiasts.
The pies are celebrated for their bold lime flavor and creamy consistency, providing a satisfying treat for those with a sweet tooth.
Stepping into Mattheessen’s is stepping into a world of indulgence, where generous portions and friendly service make every visit memorable.
Thai Island – Key West, FL
Thai Island in Key West offers a unique twist on the traditional key lime pie, blending Thai influences with Floridian flavors. The vibrant decor adds to the dining experience.
This version of the pie features exotic spices that enhance the lime’s natural tartness, creating a fusion of flavors that intrigue the palate.
Overlooking the water, Thai Island provides a serene backdrop for enjoying this inventive dessert, making for a delightful culinary adventure.
Porky’s Bayside BBQ – Marathon (FL)
Porky’s Bayside BBQ in Marathon offers more than just savory delights; its key lime pie is a showstopper. This rustic BBQ joint is known for its generous portions.
The pie here is characterized by a rich, creamy texture and vibrant lime flavor, perfectly complementing the hearty BBQ dishes.
With outdoor seating overlooking the water, Porky’s provides a laid-back environment where guests can enjoy a slice of pie alongside the picturesque views.
Discussion about this post