New York City is a melting pot of cultures, and its Italian delis are a testament to this vibrant culinary blend. These delis, cherished by locals, offer authentic flavors and a nostalgic glimpse into the city’s rich immigrant history. Whether you’re a seasoned New Yorker or a curious visitor, exploring these classic delis promises a journey through tradition and taste. Here are ten must-visit Italian delis in New York that locals swear by, each with its own unique charm and specialty.
Faicco’s Italian Specialties
Nestled in Manhattan’s West Village, Faicco’s Italian Specialties has been a family tradition since 1900.
Known for its artisanal sausages and house-made mozzarella, this deli captures the essence of authentic Italian flavors.
The bustling interior, lined with cured meats and cheeses, invites you to explore a rich culinary history.
Whether you’re grabbing a sandwich or stocking up on groceries, Faicco’s promises quality and tradition.
Don’t miss their famous rice balls, a local favorite that never disappoints. With a charm that speaks to the heart of New York’s Italian community, Faicco’s is a timeless classic.
TrendingNow
Di Palo’s Fine Foods
In the heart of Little Italy, Di Palo’s Fine Foods stands as a testament to family legacy and passion.
The Di Palo family has served New Yorkers since 1910, offering imported Italian delicacies and cheeses.
The intimate atmosphere, where customers are treated like family, enriches the shopping experience.
Their Parmigiano-Reggiano, aged to perfection, is a must-try for cheese lovers.
A visit to Di Palo’s is more than shopping; it’s a journey through generations of Italian culinary expertise.
Salumeria Biellese
Established in 1925, Salumeria Biellese in Manhattan is a haven for charcuterie enthusiasts.
Specializing in handcrafted salami and cured meats, the deli boasts recipes passed down through generations.
The rustic interior, adorned with hanging meats, evokes an old-world charm.
Their soppressata, a spicy delight, is revered by locals and visitors alike.
Salumeria Biellese offers a slice of Italy, right in the heart of New York, making it a beloved stop for meat lovers.
Lioni Italian Heroes
In the vibrant neighborhood of Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, Lioni Italian Heroes stands out with its extensive sandwich menu.
Named after Italian-American heroes, each sandwich tells a story of heritage and flavor.
The lively atmosphere, complete with Italian flags, adds to the experience.
Their signature “Godfather” sandwich, piled high with Italian meats and cheeses, is a bestseller.
Lioni’s blends cultural pride with delicious offerings, making it a cherished local institution.
Casa Della Mozzarella
Located in the Bronx’s Arthur Avenue, Casa Della Mozzarella is a paradise for cheese aficionados.
This deli is renowned for its fresh mozzarella, made daily to ensure the highest quality.
The shop’s cozy interior, filled with Italian goods, creates a welcoming ambiance.
Their mozzarella, creamy and delicate, is often called the best in the city.
Offering a taste of Italy’s cherished cheese tradition, Casa Della Mozzarella is a must-visit for anyone seeking authenticity.
Milano’s Italian Sausage
Tucked away in Brooklyn, Milano’s Italian Sausage is a gem known for its flavorful sausages.
Opened in the 1950s, Milano’s brings a taste of Italy to New York’s diverse culinary scene.
The cozy setting, with an inviting aroma of spices, makes it a neighborhood favorite.
Their fennel sausage, with its savory notes, is a highlight that draws repeat visits.
Milano’s offers a simple pleasure of traditional Italian fare, capturing the spirit of local craftsmanship.
Pasta Eater
In the heart of Queens, Pasta Eater is a haven for pasta lovers seeking fresh, handmade varieties.
This deli, open since the early 2000s, showcases Italy’s pasta-making traditions with pride.
The shelves, filled with vibrant pasta shapes and sauces, spark culinary inspirations.
Their ravioli, crafted with seasonal ingredients, is a standout choice.
Pasta Eater combines quality and creativity, offering a unique taste of Italy in New York’s diverse landscape.
Joe’s Italian Deli
Joe’s Italian Deli, located in the Bronx, is a lively spot known for its wide range of Italian products.
The deli’s friendly atmosphere, coupled with a dedication to quality, makes it a neighborhood staple.
Their selection of imported olive oils and vinegars captures the essence of Mediterranean flavors.
With a history stretching back to the 1970s, Joe’s continues to serve the community with pride.
It’s a place where tradition meets taste, offering a warm welcome to all who enter.
Alleva Dairy
Established in 1892, Alleva Dairy is a landmark in New York’s Little Italy.
Known as America’s oldest cheese shop, it offers a nostalgic glimpse into the past.
The shop specializes in fresh ricotta and mozzarella, crafted with time-honored techniques.
The decor, with its vintage charm, invites visitors to linger and explore.
Alleva Dairy not only preserves Italian culinary traditions but also embodies the neighborhood’s enduring spirit.
John’s of 12th Street
John’s of 12th Street is a Manhattan institution serving Italian classics since 1908.
While primarily a restaurant, its deli section offers a taste of their renowned dishes to go.
The classic interior, adorned with Italian memorabilia, creates a timeless ambiance.
Their eggplant parmesan, rich and flavorful, is a dish that keeps patrons returning.
John’s combines culinary excellence with a slice of New York history, making it an essential visit for Italian cuisine aficionados.
Discussion about this post