Explore the charm and culinary tradition of Wisconsin’s renowned supper clubs, where old-fashioneds flow freely and steaks are served with timeless flair. These establishments offer not just meals but an experience steeped in nostalgia and community.
The 5 O’Clock Club – Pewaukee, WI
Nestled by Pewaukee Lake, The 5 O’Clock Club promises a dining experience imbued with rustic charm. Known for its perfectly aged steaks, this club is a carnivore’s delight.
The panoramic views of the lake create a serene backdrop, enhancing the club’s inviting atmosphere. Each old-fashioned is crafted with precision, a staple that complements their hearty menu.
Locals cherish the club’s rich history and tradition, making it a staple in the community since the 1940s. Here, every meal is a celebration of culinary artistry and scenic beauty.
Ishnala Supper Club – Lake Delton, WI
Perched on the edge of Mirror Lake, Ishnala Supper Club offers a dining experience as captivating as its surroundings. Originating in the 1950s, it’s a place where nature and culinary excellence converge.
The expansive windows provide breathtaking views, enhancing the enjoyment of their renowned prime rib and old-fashioneds. Each visit feels like a retreat into serene wilderness.
Ishnala’s unique location and rich history make it a must-visit. The club’s blend of natural beauty and fine dining creates an unforgettable evening for all who venture here.
Buckhorn Supper Club – Milton, WI
Buckhorn Supper Club in Milton offers a distinctive mix of history and hospitality. Established in 1933, it remains a beloved fixture in the community.
Known for its succulent steaks and tender seafood, the menu caters to diverse tastes. The warm, welcoming atmosphere invites guests to relax and enjoy the rustic charm.
An evening at Buckhorn often includes lively conversations and the club’s signature old-fashioned, making each visit memorable. It’s an enduring symbol of traditional supper club values and camaraderie.
Silvercryst Supper Club – Wautoma, WI
Silvercryst Supper Club, with its stunning lakeside views, crafts an unforgettable dining experience in Wautoma. It’s a place where tradition meets elegance.
From the moment guests enter, they are greeted with a warm ambiance and a menu featuring classic steaks and seafood. The old-fashioneds are a local favorite, adding to the club’s allure.
Established in the 1920s, Silvercryst’s rich history and commitment to quality have made it a beloved destination for both locals and tourists seeking a taste of Wisconsin’s supper club heritage.
Pinewood Supper Club – Mosinee, WI
Pinewood Supper Club, located in Mosinee, is a forest gem offering a unique blend of rustic charm and fine dining. Its log cabin architecture exudes warmth and character.
Renowned for its hearty steak offerings and expertly mixed old-fashioneds, Pinewood is a favorite among locals. The cozy setting provides an ideal backdrop for both intimate dinners and larger gatherings.
Since 1974, it has been a symbol of community and quality, drawing diners who appreciate a blend of hospitality, history, and exceptional cuisine.
Lehman’s Supper Club – Rice Lake, WI
Lehman’s Supper Club in Rice Lake is a beacon of traditional dining. Since 1934, it has offered a menu steeped in family recipes and local flavors.
Guests are greeted by a vintage atmosphere and a promise of hearty meals, from steaks to seafood. The old-fashioneds are a hallmark, often enjoyed with lively conversation.
Its legacy of quality and warmth draws visitors seeking a slice of Wisconsin history. Lehman’s continues to be a cherished destination, celebrating the essence of supper club culture.
Kegel’s Inn – West Allis, WI
Kegel’s Inn stands as a testament to heritage, serving as the heart of West Allis since 1924. Known for its authentic German cuisine and lively beer garden, this supper club is a local treasure.
Step inside to find a cozy, old-world ambiance enhanced by stained glass and timeless décor. Regulars and newcomers alike savor the homemade sausages and schnitzels, paired perfectly with a classic old-fashioned.
Its reputation is cemented by warm hospitality, making every visit feel like a family gathering. A cherished institution, Kegel’s Inn offers both tradition and community.
Schwarz’s Supper Club – St. Anna, WI
Schwarz’s Supper Club in St. Anna is an icon of culinary tradition, known for its historic charm and welcoming environment. Established in 1957, it’s a staple in the community.
Patrons enjoy expertly prepared steaks, complemented by the club’s famous old-fashioneds. The bustling dining area is filled with laughter and friendly faces.
Schwarz’s commitment to quality and hospitality has earned it a loyal following. It remains a beloved institution, where every meal is a celebration of tradition and togetherness.