Florida is renowned for its rich culinary history, and nothing embodies this more than the iconic Key Lime Pie. With its perfect blend of tart and sweet, this dessert has won the hearts of many. Let’s explore twelve cafés across Florida where this pie has been the highlight since day one.
Midway Café & Coffee Bar- Islamorada, Florida
At Midway Café, the Key Lime Pie is not just dessert; it’s a tradition. Known for its tropical ambiance, this café’s pie perfectly complements the island vibe.
Baked to perfection, the pie is a delightful blend of tangy lime and creamy filling. Regulars often pair it with their favorite coffee.
The café’s laid-back atmosphere and friendly service add to the overall experience, making it a must-visit in Islamorada.
Mangrove Mama’s- Summerland Key, Florida
Hidden amidst lush mangroves, Mangrove Mama’s is a gem in Summerland Key. Renowned for its mouthwatering Key Lime Pie, it’s a treat that captures the essence of Florida.
The pie’s refreshing flavor makes it a beloved choice among visitors. Its vibrant, airy setting enhances the experience.
Whether you’re a local or a traveler, the pie here is a delicious reminder of Florida’s culinary heritage.
The S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill- Marathon, Florida
At The S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill, the atmosphere is as captivating as the pie itself. Overlooking the ocean, this spot serves a Key Lime Pie that’s both rich and refreshing.
Its smooth texture and tangy taste create a harmonious balance, making it a favorite. The nautical theme adds a unique twist to the dining experience.
Visitors often enjoy their pie while soaking in the panoramic sea views, making it an unforgettable stop.
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop- Miami, Florida
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop is a vibrant hub in Miami where desserts take center stage. Their Key Lime Pie stands out for its bold flavor and artistic presentation.
Baked with precision, each slice is a masterpiece. Known for its creative approach, the pie is as visually appealing as it is tasty.
The lively atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a hotspot for dessert enthusiasts.
Fookem’s Fabulous Key Lime Pie- Coconut Grove, Florida
In Coconut Grove, Fookem’s Fabulous Key Lime Pie is a must-try for pie lovers. Known for its rich and tangy flavor, this pie is truly fabulous.
The modern setting and innovative approach to baking make this spot unique. Each slice is crafted with attention to detail.
Locals flock here for a taste of what many consider Coconut Grove’s best-kept secret in desserts.
dBakers Sweet Studio- Miami, Florida
dBakers Sweet Studio is where creativity meets baking in Miami. Their Key Lime Pie is celebrated for its exquisite taste and presentation.
The pie’s smooth filling and crisp crust make it a delight for those with a sweet tooth. The studio’s trendy vibe adds to its allure.
Each visit promises a new and exciting dessert experience, ensuring it remains a favorite among Miami locals.
Joe’s Stone Crab- Miami Beach, Florida
Joe’s Stone Crab is a Miami Beach institution, well-known for its seafood and Key Lime Pie. The pie’s creamy texture and tangy zest offer a perfect end to a meal.
The restaurant’s classic ambiance and esteemed reputation draw visitors from afar. Dining here is a quintessential Miami experience.
Its enduring popularity ensures the pie remains a staple on the menu, loved by many over the years.
Pepe’s Café- Key West, Florida
Step into Pepe’s Café, and you’re greeted with the charm of old Key West. This café has been serving its renowned Key Lime Pie since its inception. The pie’s buttery crust and zesty filling make it a local favorite.
Its vintage setting provides the perfect backdrop for enjoying this timeless dessert. Many locals swear by the pie’s consistency and taste.
Pepe’s has remained unchanged through the years, becoming a nostalgic spot for both locals and tourists alike.
Red Bar- Grayton Beach, Florida
Red Bar is a lively spot in Grayton Beach where Key Lime Pie is a standout offering. Known for its eclectic interiors, the pie is a delightful surprise.
With its tangy filling and crisp crust, it’s a dessert that complements the bar’s vibrant atmosphere. The pie is a beloved choice for patrons.
The funky decor and upbeat vibe make it a favorite hangout for both locals and tourists.
Pineapple Willy’s- Panama City Beach, Florida
At Pineapple Willy’s, the beachside setting is as enticing as the Key Lime Pie. Known for its tropical flair, the pie here is a refreshing treat.
Each slice offers a burst of citrus flavor, perfect for a sunny day by the beach. The relaxed atmosphere enhances the dining experience.
Visitors often enjoy their pie with a drink, soaking in the stunning ocean views.
Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe- Key West, Florida
Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe is a paradise for lime lovers. The shop’s Key Lime Pie is legendary for its authentic taste.
The vibrant lime-green decor adds to the lively experience. Visitors can explore various lime-infused treats.
This shop has become a must-visit in Key West, offering a slice of the island’s unique flavor.
Blue Heaven- Key West, Florida
Blue Heaven is a Key West classic, famed for its Key Lime Pie served in a rustic, open-air setting. The pie’s tartness is perfectly balanced with a smooth texture.
Surrounded by lush greenery, dining here feels like stepping into a tropical paradise. The café’s charm is unmatched.
Regulars and newcomers alike relish the pie, making it an enduring favorite in the area.