As the chill of winter settles over Wisconsin, locals flock to the cozy confines of classic supper clubs. These establishments, rich in history and tradition, offer warmth and comfort alongside hearty meals. Here are 13 supper clubs that Wisconsinites swear by when the temperatures drop.
Buckhorn Supper Club – Milton, Wisconsin
Buckhorn Supper Club in Milton is a beloved local establishment, especially when winter sets in. The vintage charm of its snow-dusted exterior invites diners inside to enjoy a cozy meal.
Renowned for its Friday night fish fry, Buckhorn also offers succulent steaks and a variety of seafood. The panoramic views of Lake Koshkonong provide a serene backdrop to your dining experience.
A warm fireplace and friendly service create a welcoming environment. Fun fact: It has been a staple in the community for decades, drawing visitors from near and far.
Black Bear Bar & Grill – Minocqua, WI
Black Bear Bar & Grill is a Minocqua treasure, especially cherished during the colder months. Its cozy, lodge-like atmosphere, complete with a crackling fireplace, provides a perfect winter escape.
Famous for its hearty portions, the menu offers everything from burgers to prime rib. The rustic charm of the setting complements the hearty fare, making it a must-visit.
With friendly staff and a welcoming vibe, Black Bear captures the spirit of a true Wisconsin supper club. Did you know? It’s been a gathering spot for locals for years.
Duck Inn Supper Club – Delavan, Wisconsin
Duck Inn Supper Club in Delavan offers a warm embrace when temperatures drop. Known for its inviting atmosphere, it combines tradition with comfort.
The menu is rich with classic supper club selections, from perfectly cooked steaks to fresh seafood. A signature feature is their seasonal specials, tailored to warm the winter soul.
With a history rooted in the community, Duck Inn remains a cherished dining destination. Fun fact: It’s one of the oldest supper clubs in the area, maintaining its charm over generations.
Altona Supper Club – New Holstein, Wisconsin
Altona Supper Club in New Holstein is a winter haven, known for its traditional decor and comforting cuisine. The warm ambiance makes it a popular choice as the weather turns cold.
Offering a wide range of dishes, from tender steaks to classic fish fry, Altona caters to every palate. The friendly staff ensures a memorable dining experience.
The cozy lighting and welcoming atmosphere make it a perfect spot for both locals and visitors. Did you know? Altona has been serving the community for over 50 years!
Blanck’s Supper Club – Malone, Wisconsin
Blanck’s Supper Club in Malone is a winter favorite, known for its welcoming environment and delicious meals. The snow-covered exterior adds to its charm during the colder months.
Inside, guests are treated to a menu filled with traditional supper club fare, from steaks to seafood. The warm lighting and friendly service make every visit special.
Blanck’s has built a reputation for quality and hospitality. Fun fact: It’s a family-run establishment that has been delighting patrons for generations.
The Boarding House Supper Club – Suring, Wisconsin
The Boarding House Supper Club in Suring is a winter retreat, offering a cozy atmosphere with its inviting fireplace and warm decor. The setting is perfect for escaping the chill.
Known for its hearty portions, the menu features a variety of options, including prime rib and fresh fish. Each dish is prepared with care, ensuring a satisfying meal.
With friendly service and a welcoming vibe, it’s a staple for locals during the winter months. Did you know? It’s located in a historic building, adding to its unique charm.
Five O’Clock Steakhouse – Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Five O’Clock Steakhouse in Milwaukee is a classic choice for a winter dining experience. Known for its old-school vibe and exceptional steaks, it remains a favorite among locals.
The vintage decor transports diners back in time, creating a unique and nostalgic atmosphere. The menu boasts a selection of perfectly cooked steaks and traditional sides.
With attentive service and a rich history, Five O’Clock offers an unforgettable dining experience. Fun fact: It has been a Milwaukee institution since 1946!
Joey Gerard’s – A Bartolotta Supper Club – Greendale, Wisconsin
Joey Gerard’s in Greendale combines elegance with comfort, making it an ideal supper club for winter dining. The sophisticated decor and dim lighting set the scene for a memorable meal.
Offering a menu filled with classic favorites, from steak to chicken, each dish is crafted with precision. The cocktail selection adds a touch of class to the dining experience.
With a reputation for exceptional service, Joey Gerard’s ensures every visit is special. Did you know? It’s part of the renowned Bartolotta Restaurants group.
The Tornado Steak House – Madison, Wisconsin
The Tornado Steak House in Madison is a staple for winter dining, known for its rich history and exceptional food. The inviting glow from the windows draws diners in from the cold.
The menu features a variety of cuts, each cooked to perfection, alongside classic sides and fresh seafood. Its historic setting adds to the overall charm.
With a focus on quality and service, Tornado is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Fun fact: It’s located near the Wisconsin State Capitol, adding to its allure.
The Butterfly Club – Beloit, Wisconsin
The Butterfly Club in Beloit exudes vintage charm, making it a beloved winter destination. The snow-covered entrance adds to its allure as a cozy retreat.
Known for its delicious menu, guests enjoy everything from traditional steaks to seafood. The friendly atmosphere and attentive service enhance the dining experience.
A local favorite for generations, The Butterfly Club offers warmth and nostalgia. Did you know? It’s been a part of the Beloit community since the 1920s!
Lehman’s Supper Club – Rice Lake, Wisconsin
Lehman’s Supper Club in Rice Lake offers a quintessential winter dining experience with its warm, inviting interior. The rustic charm and wooden accents create a cozy atmosphere.
The menu features a variety of dishes, including signature steaks and fresh seafood. Each meal is prepared with care, ensuring a delightful experience.
Known for its friendly service and welcoming ambiance, Lehman’s is a favorite during the colder months. Fun fact: It’s a family-run business that has been serving the community for generations.
Schwarz’s Supper Club – Saint Anna, Wisconsin
Schwarz’s Supper Club in Saint Anna is a winter haven, renowned for its welcoming environment and delicious fare. The inviting glow from the windows offers warmth against the cold.
Specializing in steaks and traditional sides, Schwarz’s delights diners with each visit. The friendly service and cozy setting make it a standout.
A beloved local institution, it has been a gathering spot for years. Did you know? It started as a tavern in the 1800s and has evolved into a cherished supper club.
High Rock – Wisconsin Dells, WI
High Rock in Wisconsin Dells offers a cozy refuge from the cold. Nestled in the heart of the Dells, its warm, rustic interior invites visitors to relax and unwind. The menu boasts innovative dishes alongside traditional favorites.
Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Old Fashioned or a twist on local fare, High Rock delivers with flair. The staff’s friendly demeanor enhances the welcoming atmosphere, making each visit memorable.
Perfect for family gatherings or intimate dinners, High Rock ensures a delightful experience for all. Did you know? It’s a local favorite year-round!