Pennsylvania is home to countless hidden gems, especially when it comes to pizza. Locals know the best spots, keeping them under wraps to avoid drawing crowds. Here are 13 pizza shops that offer unique flavors and experiences, making them worth the visit.
Roma Pizza – Pottsville, Pennsylvania
Roma Pizza in Pottsville serves up slices that locals swear by. Known for its perfectly crispy crust and rich sauce, this spot captures the heart of classic pizza lovers. Every bite offers a blend of fresh ingredients with just the right amount of cheese.
The atmosphere inside is warm and welcoming, making it a favorite for family dinners. The staff’s friendly demeanor adds to the overall charm of the place. Don’t miss their signature pepperoni pizza, a must-try for anyone visiting.
Frequented by locals, this hidden gem is cherished for its consistent quality and genuine taste.
Buck’s Pizza – DuBois, Pennsylvania
Buck’s Pizza in DuBois offers an inviting escape for pizza aficionados. With its rustic decor and welcoming vibe, it’s a local favorite. The menu features a wide variety of toppings, catering to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters.
Every bite of their pizza reveals a symphony of flavors, thanks to their special sauce and quality toppings. The wood-fired oven ensures a perfect bake, adding a subtle smokiness.
Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Buck’s provides a memorable experience. It’s not just pizza; it’s a community gathering spot.
Pizza Boy Brewing – Enola, Pennsylvania
A fusion of craft beer and delicious pizza, Pizza Boy Brewing in Enola is a delightful find. Known for its innovative brews and flavorful pies, it’s a haven for those who appreciate both.
The pizzas here are inspired, with unique toppings that surprise the palate. Their beer selection complements the pizza, offering an elevated dining experience.
Colorful and lively, the atmosphere makes it perfect for a casual night out. This spot is not just about pizza; it’s about the experience of pairing great food with exceptional beer.
Maroni’s Pizza – Scranton, Pennsylvania
Maroni’s Pizza in Scranton offers a nostalgic journey back to classic pizza days. Established decades ago, it retains a vintage charm that draws in locals.
Signature pies feature a unique blend of spices and a perfectly chewy crust. It’s a place where tradition meets taste, with recipes passed down through generations.
The intimate setting and friendly service make it a cherished community spot. Whether you’re a first-timer or a regular, Maroni’s ensures a satisfying slice every time.
Original Italian Pizza – Lock Haven, Pennsylvania
Original Italian Pizza in Lock Haven is a slice of Italy in Pennsylvania. Known for its brick-oven pizzas and authentic flavors, it’s a go-to for Italian cuisine lovers.
The pizzas feature a thin, crispy crust with toppings that reflect traditional Italian recipes. Each dish is crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
The ambiance is as inviting as the food, with rustic decor and a family-friendly vibe. A favorite for locals, it’s a testament to genuine Italian cooking.
Angelo’s Pizzeria – Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania
Angelo’s Pizzeria in Wilkes-Barre is the definition of local charm. This small pizzeria is known for its welcoming atmosphere and delicious, straightforward pizzas.
The menu is packed with classic options, each crafted to perfection. Their cheese pizza, with its gooey texture and flavorful sauce, hits all the right notes.
Family-run and community-oriented, Angelo’s provides a personal touch that sets it apart. Regulars appreciate not only the food but also the friendly faces that make every visit special.
Arcaro and Genell – Old Forge, Pennsylvania
Arcaro and Genell in Old Forge is renowned for its signature Old Forge-style pizza, a regional specialty. The pizzas here are rectangular with a thick, fluffy crust.
Each bite offers a unique texture and flavor, thanks to their special blend of cheeses and sauce. It’s a taste that locals crave and visitors seek out.
The restaurant exudes a traditional Italian charm, making it perfect for family gatherings. Known for consistency and quality, it’s a beloved part of the community.
Huntingdon Valley Pizza – Huntingdon Valley, Pennsylvania
Huntingdon Valley Pizza offers a cozy dining experience with family-friendly vibes. Known for its personalized service and mouthwatering pizzas, it’s a local staple.
The menu boasts a variety of creative options, each made with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavor. The outdoor seating is perfect for sunny days.
Patrons appreciate not only the taste but also the welcoming environment. It’s a place where families gather and create memories over a slice of pizza.
Giacomo’s Italian Market and Grille – Easton, Pennsylvania
Giacomo’s Italian Market and Grille in Easton is a delightful blend of market and restaurant, offering authentic Italian flavors. Known for its bustling atmosphere, it’s a favorite for pizza enthusiasts.
The pizzas are crafted with traditional recipes, using fresh, market-sourced ingredients. Each pie is a celebration of Italian culinary art.
Whether you’re grabbing groceries or sitting down for a meal, Giacomo’s provides an authentic Italian experience. It’s more than food; it’s a taste of Italy.
Rocco’s Pizza – Exton, Pennsylvania
Rocco’s Pizza in Exton captures the essence of modern pizza dining. With stylish decor and an open kitchen, it offers a contemporary take on traditional pies.
The pizzas are crafted with innovation in mind, featuring unique toppings and combinations. Each slice presents a delightful blend of textures and flavors.
Perfect for a casual lunch or an evening out, Rocco’s continues to impress with its fresh approach. It’s where creativity and taste meet, delighting locals and newcomers alike.
Giuseppe’s Pizza Cantina – Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania
Giuseppe’s Pizza Cantina in Mechanicsburg is synonymous with lively dining and vibrant flavors. Known for its colorful decor and welcoming atmosphere, it’s a hit among locals.
The pizzas are an explosion of taste, featuring fresh toppings and a perfectly baked crust. The cantina’s vibe adds to the appeal, making it a fun spot for gatherings.
Whether you’re a fan of classic margherita or inventive flavors, Giuseppe’s caters to all. It’s a place where food and fun go hand in hand.
Nino’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant – Reading, Pennsylvania
Nino’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant in Reading offers a warm, traditional dining experience. Known for its authentic Italian flavors, it’s a beloved spot for locals.
Each pizza is crafted with care, featuring a chewy crust and delicious toppings. The restaurant’s cozy interior enhances the dining experience, making it ideal for family dinners.
With a reputation for quality and taste, Nino’s continues to win hearts. Whether it’s a casual meal or a special occasion, it never disappoints.
Vito’s Coal Fired Pizza & Restaurant – St Clair, Pennsylvania
Vito’s Coal Fired Pizza & Restaurant in St Clair offers a unique pizza experience with its coal-fired oven. Known for its rustic decor and industrial vibe, it’s a standout destination.
The coal-fired method gives pizzas a distinctive flavor, with a crispy yet tender crust. Toppings are fresh and thoughtfully selected, elevating each bite.
Diners enjoy not only the food but also the engaging atmosphere. Vito’s provides a memorable dining adventure, marking it as a must-visit in St Clair.