America’s love affair with pie is a sweet tradition best experienced along the highways at quaint roadside counters. Here are 15 destinations where thick slices reign supreme.
Koffee Kup Family Restaurant – Hico, Texas
At Koffee Kup Family Restaurant, pie lovers find a slice of paradise. This charming diner in Hico serves pies that are as thick as they are delicious. The aroma of freshly baked pies fills the air, inviting guests to indulge in a slice of Americana.
Known for their coconut meringue pie, each piece is a harmony of sweet and fluffy textures. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make it a perfect stop on any road trip.
Bingham’s – Kingsley, Pennsylvania
Bingham’s in Kingsley offers a slice of nostalgia with every piece of pie. This roadside favorite is famed for its towering pies, lovingly crafted to please any sweet tooth. The quaint setting and classic diner vibe add to its charm.
Their blueberry pie is a must-try, bursting with fresh fruit and a buttery crust. It’s a delightful pause on a journey through Pennsylvania’s scenic routes.
Linn’s Restaurant – Cambria, California
Nestled in Cambria, Linn’s Restaurant enchants visitors with its famous olallieberry pie. This slice of California heaven is thick and luscious, featuring the unique olallieberry in all its glory.
The restaurant’s country charm and impeccable hospitality make it a favorite among tourists. Each slice is a delicious reminder of California’s bountiful harvests. It’s a sweet escape near the Pacific coast.
Julian Pie Company – Julian, California
In Julian, the Julian Pie Company serves slices of pie that are simply unforgettable. Known for its apple pies, this quaint bakery offers slices that are generously filled and perfectly balanced.
The shop’s rustic decor and friendly atmosphere welcome pie enthusiasts year-round. With a variety of flavors, each visit is a delightful exploration of taste. Their caramel Dutch apple pie is particularly adored.
Norske Nook – Osseo – Osseo, Wisconsin
At Norske Nook in Osseo, the pies are as legendary as the hospitality. Known for their thick, sumptuous slices, this cafe offers a taste of Scandinavian tradition.
Their rhubarb pie is both tart and sweet, capturing the essence of homemade goodness. The charming, rustic setting adds to the experience, making it a must-stop in Wisconsin.
Magpie Cafe & Coffeehouse – Decorah, Iowa
Magpie Cafe & Coffeehouse in Decorah serves up thick slices of pie that are a chocolate lover’s dream. Known for their chocolate silk pie, each slice is creamy and decadent.
The relaxed atmosphere and artisanal touch make it a delightful spot for pie enthusiasts. It’s a sweet retreat in the heart of Iowa.
Southern Baked Pie Company – Gainesville, Georgia
Southern Baked Pie Company is the pride of Gainesville, offering pies that are as thick as they are flavorful. Their pecan pie is a southern classic, rich in taste and texture.
With a focus on quality ingredients and traditional recipes, each slice is a celebration of Southern hospitality. The cozy shop and friendly service make every visit enjoyable.
Texan Cafe & Pie Shop – Hutto, Texas
In the heart of Hutto, Texan Cafe & Pie Shop is a beloved local gem. Known for its generous pie slices, this cozy spot invites visitors to savor the rich flavors of Texas. Their pies are baked to perfection, offering a delightful crunch with every bite.
The ambiance is warm and welcoming, making it a favorite for both locals and travelers. Each slice tells a story of tradition and southern hospitality. Famous for its pecan pie, it promises a sweet and memorable experience.
Lins Kitchen – Benton, Louisiana
Lins Kitchen in Benton is a hidden gem where pie slices are nothing short of extraordinary. Known for their sweet potato pie, each piece is thick and delightfully spiced.
The homey atmosphere and friendly staff make it a favorite among locals. It’s a sweet spot for those craving a taste of the South.
Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant & Smorgasbord – Bird in Hand, Pennsylvania
In Bird in Hand, the Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant & Smorgasbord serves up pie slices that celebrate Pennsylvania Dutch tradition. Their shoo-fly pie is a must-try, with its thick molasses filling.
A welcoming environment and ample servings make it a delightful experience. It’s a piece of culinary heritage worth savoring.
Village Kitchen & Pie Shoppe – Carlsbad, California
Village Kitchen & Pie Shoppe in Carlsbad is famous for its thick pie slices brimming with flavor. The boysenberry pie is a crowd favorite, known for its sweet and tangy filling.
The casual setting and vibrant atmosphere make it a popular stop for tourists and locals alike. Each slice is a delicious treat to be enjoyed.
Betty’s Pies – Two Harbors, Minnesota
Betty’s Pies in Two Harbors is a lakeside treasure where pie slices are as big as the views. Known for their banana cream pie, each slice is creamy and satisfying.
The diner’s nostalgic decor and friendly service offer a comforting experience. It’s a delicious stop along Minnesota’s scenic North Shore.
The Cup & Saucer Diner – Pine Bush, New York
In Pine Bush, The Cup & Saucer Diner is where pie lovers indulge in thick, flavorful slices. Known for their peach pie, each piece is juicy and perfectly spiced.
The diner’s retro charm and welcoming staff create a delightful dining experience. It’s a sweet slice of New York nostalgia.
Dutch Pantry Family Restaurant – Clearfield, Pennsylvania
At the Dutch Pantry Family Restaurant in Clearfield, thick slices of pie are a cherished tradition. Their cherry pie is particularly popular, with a perfect balance of tart and sweet.
The homely setting and warm service make it a favorite among families. It’s a slice of comfort in Pennsylvania’s scenic countryside.
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery – Shipshewana, Indiana
In the heart of Amish country, Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery is synonymous with hearty, thick slices of pie. The welcoming ambiance and traditional decor provide a comforting backdrop for a delightful meal.
Their cream pies are especially popular, with a smooth, rich texture that satisfies any craving. Authentic flavors and warm hospitality make every visit a treasured memory.