You can still taste old school hospitality in Minnesota, where crisp fried walleye and bracing Old Fashioneds rule the evening. These storied rooms glow with vintage charm, clinking ice, and the promise of a perfect supper club night. Pull up a chair, trade small talk with the bartender, and watch the fish fry arrive steaming hot. Here are twelve beloved spots where tradition meets your appetite and the night feels timeless.
Lindey’s Prime Steak House – Arden Hills, Minnesota
Lindey’s feels like the kind of place where the steak knives hold stories, the booths hum, and the cocktails come with a wink. You will smell sizzling fat before the menu even opens, and that is your cue to settle in. Order an Old Fashioned, watch the cherry bob, and let the night get friendly.
TrendingNow
The walleye is delicate, lightly breaded, and kissed with lemon that brightens every bite. Sides are honest and hearty, the service steady and warm like a familiar handshake. It is a supper club rhythm: clatter, laughter, more bread, another pour.
You leave feeling looked after, like the room knew what you needed. Lindey’s makes time behave, slower and kinder, one plate at a time.
Pickwick Restaurant & Pub – Duluth, Minnesota
Pickwick sits above the water like a keeper of Duluth lore, all timber, stone, and stories. You feel the lake nearby, steady and cold, while your glass warms your hands. The Old Fashioned here is strong, citrusy, and precise.
Order the walleye and taste Superior in every flake, tender under a crisp coat. Butter, lemon, and a hush of herbs do the rest without showing off. The room glows gold and amber, and conversations rise like sparks from a fireplace.
You will want dessert just to prolong the spell. Pickwick is that comforting Duluth hum where nights stretch without rush. Let the staff guide you, and let the lake hold the silence between bites.
Bennett’s Chop & Railhouse – St Paul, Minnesota
Bennett’s greets you like a neighborhood living room, only with better lighting and a sharper pour. The railhouse flair adds grit without losing the polish. Order a classic Old Fashioned and watch the bartender measure with care.
The walleye arrives crisp and steaming, escorted by tartar and lemon that behave like old friends. Sides are throwback favorites that never lost their nerve. It all says linger, talk longer, and save room for a slice of pie.
Service is quick with a grin, and that matters more than trends. Nights at Bennett’s feel easy, like you chose right without overthinking it. You will leave full, warmed, and plotting your return.
Murray’s – Minneapolis, Minnesota
Murray’s glitters like a time capsule where downtown nights dress up. You slide into a banquette and the silverware gleams back with confidence. The Old Fashioned is balanced, orange oils perfuming the air as ice settles.
Yes, the butter knife steak headlines, but the walleye holds its own with delicate flakes and a clean finish. Lemon, butter, and restraint let the fish speak clearly. You taste craft, not fuss.
Servers glide, courses land, and the city hums outside like a bassline. Here, tradition is not nostalgia, it is a working promise. You will sip slow, savor slower, and leave thinking about reservations you have not made yet.
Cuzzy’s Grill & Bar – Minneapolis, Minnesota
Cuzzy’s keeps it scrappy, loud, and friendly in the best way. You come for the neighborhood heartbeat and stay for the easy laughter. An Old Fashioned lands in front of you with no drama, just perfect bite and sweetness.
The walleye basket is crisp, golden, and dangerously snackable, especially with a squeeze of lemon. Fries pile high, and the sauce knows its job. This is not precious dining, it is craveable and honest.
Music hums, conversations overlap, and time slips. You will make friends or at least trade nods across the bar. When you want supper club spirit without the starch, Cuzzy’s shows up right on time.
The Commodore Bar & Restaurant – St Paul, Minnesota
The Commodore feels like dressing up even if you did not. Art deco lines and mirrored accents set a glamorous stage. Your Old Fashioned shines like jewelry under candlelight.
The walleye arrives with crisp edges and a silky interior, framed by seasonal sides that whisper luxury. Sauces are polished, plating intentional but not fussy. You taste the city telling old stories through new hands.
Live music sometimes softens the room, and conversations find an elegant pace. You will leave with straighter posture and a smile you did not notice forming. For a St Paul night that savors style, the Commodore keeps the promise.
Jax Cafe – Minneapolis, Minnesota
Jax feels like family history you get to borrow for a night. The walls carry decades of laughter, and the staff knows how to read a table. An Old Fashioned arrives balanced, generous, and steadying.
Walleye here is delicate and confident, sometimes pan fried with just the right crackle. Sides lean classic, with buttery potatoes and vegetables that still taste like themselves. The garden and koi pond add charm that lingers in memory.
You can celebrate big or keep things quiet, and both feel right. Service nudges, never shouts, guiding you toward dessert. Jax proves rituals survive because they are delicious, not just nostalgic.
The Lexington – St Paul, Minnesota
The Lexington carries itself with that confident St Paul hush. You settle into leather and feel the evening stretch. The Old Fashioned is measured, aromatic, and unfailingly smooth.
Walleye almondine shows up with toasty nuts and lemon that brightens each bite. The fish flakes easily, buttery but never heavy. Sides are composed, with greens that taste crisp and true.
Service glides with practiced grace, anticipating needs before you ask. It is the kind of night where celebratory toasts feel natural. You leave feeling polished, like the city nodded in approval as you stepped back outside.
The White Horse Restaurant & Bar – St Cloud, Minnesota
The White Horse is the heartbeat of downtown St Cloud, lively and unpretentious. You slide onto a barstool and are greeted like a regular. The Old Fashioned tastes like the weekend even on a Tuesday.
The walleye is crisp, flaky, and proud of its Minnesota roots. Alongside, you will likely find hearty sides that speak plainly and satisfy. It is the plate you crave after long drives or cold nights.
Conversation is easy here, the kind that drifts between tables with good humor. Service moves fast but still finds time to chat. You will leave with warmth in your chest and plans to bring a friend next time.
Lord Fletcher’s Old Lake Lodge – Spring Park, Minnesota
Lord Fletcher’s is summer bottled, even when snow piles high outside. The lake keeps the mood playful while the lodge leans cozy. Your Old Fashioned arrives with a view that does half the work.
Order walleye and taste Minnetonka in a crisp bite, whether as a sandwich or plated with lemon. The breeze carries laughter from the docks, and the dining room glows warmly after sunset. It is a place to linger, refill, and repeat.
Service is bright, upbeat, and lake proud. You will time your visit for sunset after the first go. Nights end with a satisfied sigh that feels like a promise kept.
Harbor View Cafe – Pepin, Wisconsin
Cross the river for Harbor View and you will understand the pilgrimage. The chalkboard changes with the seasons, but comfort remains constant. An Old Fashioned here tastes like a shoreline story.
The walleye sings with crisp edges and clean, river bright flavor. Sides are farm friendly and thoughtful without getting fussy. You feel the Mississippi holding court outside, slow and certain.
Service is neighborly, guiding you toward whatever is best that night. You will linger on the porch if the weather cooperates. Harbor View rewards the drive with plates that feel both careful and relaxed.
Mancini’s Char House – St Paul, Minnesota
Mancini’s buzzes with supper club swagger. Red booths, live music, and that famous neon pull you in fast. The Old Fashioned lands with a cherry and the right kind of bite.
While char is the headliner, walleye holds its lane with crisp edges and buttery flakes. Garlic bread arrives like a fan favorite, and you will not argue. The room feels celebratory, even on weeknights.
Servers keep plates and jokes moving. You will clap for a song and then order dessert without hesitation. Mancini’s proves that hospitality is a performance and you are in the best seat.
Discussion about this post