Discover ten delightful pie shops across Tennessee that have won the hearts and taste buds of locals. These hidden gems promise an unforgettable experience with each bite.
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop – Knoxville
In Knoxville, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is a cherished spot for pie enthusiasts. With its inviting atmosphere and nostalgic charm, this shop serves up classic Southern flavors.
The bakery is renowned for its signature buttermilk pie, which draws customers from all over. Each pie is crafted with love and the freshest ingredients, ensuring an authentic taste.
Don’t miss their seasonal specialties that capture the essence of Tennessee’s local produce. Whether you’re a fan of traditional apple or adventurous key lime, Buttermilk Sky offers something for every palate.
Papa C Pies Bakery – Brentwood
Papa C Pies Bakery in Brentwood stands as a testament to true craftsmanship in pie making. Known for its warm service and delicious offerings, this bakery has become a local favorite.
Their menu boasts a variety of pies, each made with precision and care. From the creamy coconut cream to the rich chocolate chess, every slice is a delight.
The bakery’s commitment to quality is evident in every bite, making it a must-visit for anyone craving an exceptional pie experience in Tennessee.
Pie R Square – Chattanooga / Red Bank
Nestled in Chattanooga’s Red Bank area, Pie R Square offers a unique twist on traditional pies. This quirky shop is known for its creative flavors and innovative combinations.
With an ever-changing menu, customers are often surprised by delightful new creations. The savory options, like their chicken pot pie, are particularly popular.
Owners pride themselves on using local ingredients, ensuring each pie not only tastes great but supports the community. Pie R Square is a haven for those seeking something a little different.
Baked On 8th – Nashville
In the heart of Nashville, Baked On 8th is a haven for dessert lovers. This charming bakery is celebrated for its wide selection of freshly baked pies.
Renowned for their use of high-quality ingredients, each pie is a masterpiece. The pecan pie, with its buttery crust and sweet filling, is a crowd-pleaser.
Baked On 8th also caters to those with dietary restrictions, offering gluten-free and vegan options. It’s a delightful stop for anyone craving a sweet slice in Music City.
Dozen Bakery – Nashville
Dozen Bakery in Nashville is a hotspot for artisanal baked goods, including their famed pies. With an open kitchen concept, customers can watch their treats being crafted.
Their pies, made with precision and top-notch ingredients, range from traditional favorites to inventive flavors. The salted honey pie is a standout,
creating a perfect balance of sweet and savory.
For those who appreciate quality and craftsmanship, Dozen Bakery delivers on both fronts, making it a beloved destination in the city.
Loveless Café – Nashville
Loveless Café, a Nashville institution, is celebrated not just for its comfort food but also its delectable pies. This iconic spot has been serving up smiles for decades.
Known for their Southern hospitality, the café specializes in time-honored recipes passed down through generations. Each pie, from chess to berry, tells a story.
Visitors are drawn not only by the taste but also the nostalgic experience, making every visit to Loveless Café a journey into Tennessee’s rich culinary history.
Pie Sensations – Columbia
In Columbia, Pie Sensations is a delightful retreat for pie lovers. This cozy bakery exudes a vintage charm complemented by its tasteful selection of pies.
Known for their diverse range of offerings, customers can find everything from sweet indulgences to hearty, savory options. The caramel apple pie is a must-try.
With a focus on quality and creativity, Pie Sensations has won the hearts of many locals and remains a cherished spot in the community.
Elliston Place Soda Shop – Nashville
Elliston Place Soda Shop is a nostalgic journey back in time, complete with retro decor and classic pies. Located in Nashville, it’s beloved for its old-fashioned charm.
Their pies, made fresh daily, transport customers to simpler times with their authentic flavors. The banana cream pie, in particular, is a fan favorite.
With its delightful ambiance and delicious offerings, Elliston Place Soda Shop is more than just a café—it’s a cherished piece of Nashville’s culinary history.
Muddy’s Bake Shop – Memphis
Muddy’s Bake Shop in Memphis is as vibrant as the city itself, offering creative pies with a side of warmth and hospitality.
Their inventive flavors and artistic presentation make each pie a feast for both the eyes and taste buds. The grasshopper pie, with its minty goodness, stands out.
A visit to Muddy’s is not only about indulging in sweet treats but also experiencing the joyful spirit that defines this beloved Memphis bakery.
Dutch Maid Bakery – Tracy City
Dutch Maid Bakery, nestled in Tracy City, is Tennessee’s oldest bakery, offering a taste of history with every pie.
Known for their traditional recipes and charming atmosphere, this bakery is a beloved fixture in the community. The sour cream raisin pie is particularly noteworthy.
A trip to Dutch Maid Bakery is more than just a culinary delight; it’s a journey through time, celebrating the heritage and craft of pie making.