Craving a slice that makes your fork race your coffee cup to the finish line? Florida practically invented the art of bright citrus meeting creamy bliss, and these spots keep the legend alive. Expect tart pops of lime, buttery crusts, and meringue peaks that barely last a minute. Ready to chase the perfect slice before the mug is half empty?
Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory – Tavernier, Florida
The first bite here lands like a tropical postcard, all zesty lime and silky custard wrapped in a crisp graham crust. You smell toasted crumbs as the fork breaks through, then a clean citrus breeze brightens everything. Blink and the slice is gone while your coffee still steams.
TrendingNow
Portions hit that sweet spot between generous and vanishingly light, so sharing becomes a polite lie. Staff guide you to frozen bars, chocolate dipped wedges, and classic meringue crowns. Take an extra slice for later and see how long later actually lasts.
The vibe feels Keys casual, with cheerful colors and breezy music. Outdoor tables keep things sunny. Your taste buds will remember this place long after the cup runs dry.
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop – Miami, Florida
At Fireman Derek’s, the pies come bold and photo ready, with a tang that sparks like Miami traffic at rush hour. The graham crust crunches clean, then yields to lush lime silk. You sip coffee, blink, and the plate looks suspiciously empty.
They riff on tradition with whipped cream swirls, meringue clouds, and occasional tropical twists. The texture sits between cheesecake and custard, rich but never heavy. Order fast because the case empties like a station call.
The scene buzzes with locals and dessert pilgrims clutching boxes. Staff hustle with smiles and good recs. Bring friends, pretend to share, and accept that your fork will move quicker than conversation.
Old Town Bakery – Key West, Florida
This charming stop whispers old Key West, where the pie filling is bright, balanced, and unapologetically lime forward. The crust holds firm without crumbling into chaos. Before the barista calls another latte, your slice has politely vanished.
They keep it classic, letting good citrus and careful baking do the talking. Sweetness never shouts, so each bite stays refreshing. You could easily justify breakfast pie here and feel proud about it.
Grab a seat near the door and watch bikes zip past. The staff know their regulars and point you toward the best bakes. Order two slices so the second can disappear at the exact same speed.
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen (Little) – Key Largo, Florida
Mrs. Mac’s leans classic diner comfort, but the pie reads Keys royalty. The lime custard is tart enough to wake you, smooth enough to flirt with your sweet tooth. Coffee refills come quick, yet somehow the plate outruns the pour.
They do a sturdy graham crust with just the right toast and salt. Toppings rotate from simple whipped cream to playful drizzles. Ask for a chilled slice if the day turns humid, which it will.
Service is friendly without fuss, like a neighbor sliding over another napkin. Portions look modest until you realize you ate it too fast. Consider the takeout box a necessary safety net.
Sister Honey’s – Orlando, Florida
Sister Honey’s treats key lime like a trophy dessert made approachable. The filling is glossy, firm, and sparkling with lime zest, while the crust snaps pleasantly. Even coffee that tastes like a hug cannot slow your fork down.
They are award heavy for a reason, balancing acidity and cream with precision. Expect clean flavors and consistent bakes every time. Ask for the slice to go and it still disappears in the parking lot.
The shop feels polished without losing warmth. Staff recommendations are spot on, especially when they nudge you toward seasonal twists. Save room, but honestly, you will end up making room.
Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop – Elizabeth Street – Key West, Florida
Kermit’s on Elizabeth Street is a pilgrimage for pie fans who like options. Classic slices share space with chocolate dipped bars and frozen pops. You take a sip of coffee, then suddenly you are unwrapping a second treat.
The filling is punchy and vibrant, the crust reliable and toasty. Meringue is optional, but the whipped cream route feels breezy. Tartness leads, sweetness follows, and balance stays tight.
Tourists mingle with locals grabbing quick hits of lime. The staff moves fast and keeps smiles in stock. Grab extra napkins because chocolate and sunshine play messy together.
Publix Super Market Bakery – Lakeland, Florida
Do not underestimate the Publix Bakery pie. It is dependable, pleasantly tart, and surprisingly creamy for a supermarket staple. While you debate deli subs, your slice is already gone.
The graham crust holds well, with a light sweetness that supports the lime. It chills beautifully, making it an easy party hero. You can snag one on the way to any gathering and look brilliant.
Lakeland may be the HQ, but the flavor shows up statewide. Friendly staff will check the case or the cooler for the freshest. Budget friendly, crowd pleasing, and dangerously quick to disappear.
Blue Heaven – Key West, Florida
Blue Heaven’s pie arrives with a meringue crown so tall it deserves its own postcard. The lime custard beneath stays bright, never bullied by the fluff. Coffee cools while your slice somehow evaporates.
That patio setting adds island magic, with roosters strutting and music drifting. The crust balances crumbly and cohesive, easy to fork but never soggy. Every bite feels like vacation punctuation.
Service is relaxed but attentive, perfect for lingering over seconds. Consider brunch, then make dessert the real main event. Snap the photo, then stop pretending this slice will last.
Upper Crust Cafe & Bakery – Venice, Florida
Upper Crust keeps it coastal calm, with a pie that tastes clean and confident. The lime pops brightly, and the custard sets to a silky, shapely slice. Your mug sits half full because your plate empties first.
Presentation leans simple: a little zest, tidy edges, no gimmicks. The crust gives gentle crunch and a whisper of salt. Ask for it chilled for extra snap on warm days.
Locals swing through for breads and leave with pie boxes. Staff make honest suggestions based on what just came out. Dessert here feels like a habit worth keeping.
Joe’s Stone Crab – Miami Beach, Florida
Joe’s serves a refined slice that earns its reputation without shouting. The custard is cool and focused, with lime that lingers politely. You top off coffee, and somehow the fork has done its work.
The crust is tightly packed, buttery, and precise, a match for the glossy filling. Whipped cream is strategic, never overdone. This pie pairs beautifully with post seafood satisfaction.
Service is classic, timing just right for dessert cravings. The room hums with history and celebratory dinners. Order decisively because your tablemates will angle for a bite.
Key West Key Lime Pie Co. – Key West, Florida
Here the energy is electric, and the pie is the headline act. The filling hits sharp citrus notes that bounce off a sturdy graham base. You blink between sips and your slice is history.
They do variety like pros: classic wedges, on-a-stick novelties, and fun seasonal riffs. Sweetness stays in check so the lime can lead. The fridge case empties fast, then magically refills.
You will meet tourists clutching boxes like trophies. Staff move quickly, answering questions while bagging seconds. Bring cash for extra treats because restraint is not part of the show.
Discussion about this post