The Florida Keys are renowned for their stunning sunsets, crystal-clear waters, and, of course, their mouthwatering seafood. Here are 11 seafood shacks that capture the essence of island life, offering fresh flavors that locals and tourists can’t resist.
Islamorada Shrimp Shack – Islamorada, FL
Nestled in the heart of Islamorada, the Shrimp Shack exudes a laid-back vibe that draws locals and tourists alike. Known for its fresh-caught shrimp, the menu is a homage to the ocean’s bounty.
Delight in their renowned shrimp tacos, bursting with flavor and complemented by a tangy citrus sauce. The casual setting invites guests to unwind and savor every bite.
Whether seated inside or on the breezy patio, the welcoming atmosphere and friendly service make this shack a must-visit destination for seafood lovers.
Keys Fisheries – Marathon, FL
In Marathon, Keys Fisheries offers a quintessential Keys dining experience with its fresh seafood market and restaurant. Famous for its stone crab claws, this spot is a haven for seafood enthusiasts.
Enjoy a delightful meal by the marina as boats drift by, creating a picturesque ambiance. Their lobster Reuben is a unique twist on a classic favorite.
This lively spot often hosts events, adding to its vibrant atmosphere. A visit here promises not just food, but a memorable experience of the Florida Keys.
Alabama Jack’s – Card Sound, FL
Alabama Jack’s is a charming roadside shack known for its conch fritters and live music. Located on Card Sound, it offers a perfect blend of local culture and culinary delight.
The shack’s rustic charm and outdoor seating area provide an authentic Keys experience. With lively music and friendly patrons, it’s a place where time seems to stand still.
This popular spot has become a tradition for many, inviting guests to indulge in good food, great music, and the spirit of the Keys.
Hogfish Bar & Grill – Stock Island (Key West), FL
Tucked away on Stock Island, Hogfish Bar & Grill is a local gem boasting fresh seafood and a lively atmosphere. Known for its signature hogfish sandwich, it’s a hit among both locals and visitors.
The relaxed setting, complete with nautical décor, reflects the island’s laid-back charm. Guests are welcomed with friendly smiles and exceptional service.
Diners can savor meals alfresco, surrounded by the marina’s beauty. The experience is a true taste of island life, where flavors and ambiance come together effortlessly.
The Lobster Shack – Key West, FL
The Lobster Shack in Key West is a seafood lover’s paradise, celebrated for its delicious lobster rolls. This quaint shack offers a taste of New England with a tropical twist.
The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, making it a perfect spot for a casual meal. Guests can enjoy fresh lobster with a side of sunshine.
The shack’s charm lies in its simplicity and dedication to quality. A visit here is an opportunity to indulge in one of the Keys’ most beloved seafood dishes.
B.O.’s Fish Wagon – Key West, FL
B.O.’s Fish Wagon is a Key West icon, known for its legendary fish sandwiches and quirky charm. The eclectic décor and laid-back vibe draw a diverse crowd.
Located in a bustling corner, it offers an authentic taste of local life. The fish sandwiches are a must-try, combining fresh catch with unique flavors.
This spot is more than a meal; it’s an experience. The relaxed ambiance and friendly staff make it a favorite among those seeking a true taste of the Keys.
Conch Republic Seafood Company – Key West, FL
At the heart of Key West, Conch Republic Seafood Company is a culinary landmark. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and fresh conch dishes, it captures the essence of island dining.
Guests can dine on the waterfront patio, enjoying the serene views of the harbor. The extensive menu offers a delightful array of seafood options.
This lively spot is perfect for both casual meals and special occasions. The combination of flavors, views, and ambiance make it a standout choice in Key West.
Square Grouper Bar & Grill – Key West (Cudjoe Key), FL
Located in Cudjoe Key, Square Grouper Bar & Grill is a culinary treasure. Known for its innovative seafood dishes, the restaurant offers an upscale dining experience in a relaxed setting.
The interior’s tropical theme complements the creative menu, which showcases the freshest local ingredients. Each dish is a work of art, both visually and in flavor.
The warm and inviting atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for a memorable meal. It’s a place where culinary creativity meets island charm.
Key Largo Fisheries Backyard Café – Key Largo, FL
Key Largo Fisheries Backyard Café is a family-friendly spot offering fresh seafood with a view. The casual outdoor setting is ideal for enjoying a leisurely meal by the water.
Known for its fresh catch of the day, the café delivers on both flavor and experience. It’s a place where families gather to enjoy quality time and delicious food.
The laid-back atmosphere and scenic views create a perfect backdrop for a delightful dining experience. It’s a hidden gem worth discovering in Key Largo.
Lazy Days Restaurant – Big Pine Key, FL
Lazy Days Restaurant in Big Pine Key is a vibrant spot offering fresh seafood and stunning views. The colorful décor and waterfront location create a lively dining atmosphere.
Known for its catch of the day, the menu is a celebration of local flavors. Island cocktails complement the dishes, adding a tropical touch.
The welcoming vibe and attentive service make it a favorite among visitors. Lazy Days is where the beauty of the Keys meets culinary excellence, creating memorable meals.
Blue Heaven (Fish Shack Section) – Key West, FL
In Key West, Blue Heaven’s Fish Shack section offers a whimsical dining experience. Known for its eclectic charm, it attracts those seeking unique flavors and ambiance.
The garden setting, adorned with quirky decorations, is perfect for a relaxed meal. The seafood dishes are crafted with creativity and flair.
It’s a spot where art and culinary passion converge, making each visit a delightful escape. Blue Heaven’s Fish Shack is a destination for food and fun, offering a taste of Key West’s vibrant spirit.