Wisconsin is renowned for its supper clubs, and locals insist that these spots still offer Sunday roasts done right. Whether you’re in search of a nostalgic dining experience or a taste of tradition, these supper clubs have you covered. Here are 11 must-visit places where the roast is always perfect.
The 5 O’Clock Club – Pewaukee, WI
Nestled by the tranquil waters of Pewaukee Lake, The 5 O’Clock Club exudes warmth and tradition. With its rustic charm and welcoming atmosphere, it’s no wonder locals return week after week.
The Sunday roast here is a culinary masterpiece, served with perfectly roasted vegetables and savory gravy.
With a history dating back to the 1920s, this iconic spot has a nostalgic vibe that perfectly complements its classic menu. A visit promises not just a meal, but a journey back in time.
Ishnala Supper Club – Lake Delton, WI
Set amidst the enchanting woods of Mirror Lake State Park, Ishnala Supper Club offers more than just a meal; it’s an experience. Imagine dining with expansive views of the shimmering lake while enjoying their renowned Sunday roast.
The ambiance is both romantic and serene, making it a preferred choice for special occasions.
Rich in history, the building itself dates back to the 1800s. This blend of natural beauty and culinary excellence makes Ishnala a standout in Wisconsin’s supper club scene.
Toby’s Supper Club – Madison, WI
Toby’s Supper Club in Madison is a beloved spot for locals craving authentic and hearty meals. Known for its welcoming staff and lively atmosphere, Toby’s has become a staple in the community.
Their Sunday roast is simple yet exceptional, offering flavors that evoke memories of home-cooked meals.
Established in the 1960s, Toby’s retains a vintage charm that makes every visit feel like stepping back into a cherished era. The combination of good food and great company is truly unbeatable here.
Buckhorn Supper Club – Milton, WI
Perched on the shores of Lake Koshkonong, Buckhorn Supper Club offers stunning views alongside its famous Sunday roast. The scenic backdrop enhances the dining experience, creating a perfect setting for relaxation.
The roast, accompanied by homemade sides, is a crowd favorite, embodying the essence of comfort food.
The club’s legacy dates back several decades, and its commitment to quality and tradition remains unwavering. Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, Buckhorn always feels like home.
Dreamland Supper Club – South Range, WI
Dreamland Supper Club is a delightful blend of nostalgia and culinary delight. Located in South Range, it’s a favorite among those who appreciate a classic supper club feel.
Their Sunday roast is tender and flavorful, served in a cozy, retro-themed setting that elicits a sense of nostalgia.
Since its opening in the 1950s, Dreamland has remained true to its roots, offering an experience that’s both authentic and heartwarming. It’s a place where every meal feels like a celebration of tradition.
The Duck Inn Supper Club – Delavan, WI
The Duck Inn Supper Club is a charming establishment in Delavan, known for its delightful duck-themed decor and serene pond views.
Their Sunday roast is a standout dish, perfectly cooked and seasoned to perfection. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, ideal for family gatherings and friendly get-togethers.
With a history that stretches back to the mid-20th century, The Duck Inn has become a cherished part of the local community. The combination of great food and a welcoming atmosphere never disappoints.
Tornado Steak House – Madison, WI
Tornado Steak House in Madison is synonymous with elegance and exceptional cuisine. This upscale establishment is famous for its top-quality meats and exquisite dishes.
Their Sunday roast is no exception, offering a gourmet experience that satisfies even the most discerning palates.
The sophisticated ambiance, complete with modern decor and attentive service, ensures a memorable dining experience. Tornado Steak House seamlessly blends tradition with contemporary flair, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts.
Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club – Wauwatosa, WI
Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club in Wauwatosa is a vibrant spot where tradition meets modernity. With its rustic decor and lively atmosphere, it’s a favorite for both locals and visitors.
Their Sunday roast is a delightful dish, expertly prepared to highlight rich flavors and tender textures.
Opened in recent years, Buckatabon has quickly gained a reputation for its creative twist on classic dishes. It’s a place where the community comes together to enjoy great food and great company.
Fox & Hounds Restaurant & Tavern – Hubertus, WI
Fox & Hounds Restaurant & Tavern is a historic gem nestled in the woods of Hubertus. Known for its charming and rustic ambiance, it provides a perfect escape into nature.
The Sunday roast is a signature dish, offering a perfect blend of flavors that delight the senses. The cozy interior, complete with a fireplace and antique furnishings, enhances the dining experience.
Established in the early 20th century, Fox & Hounds remains a beloved destination for those seeking both history and culinary excellence.
The Fireside Restaurant – Ellison Bay, WI
The Fireside Restaurant in Ellison Bay offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a hearty meal. Known for its wooden beams and charming decor, it’s a favorite among locals.
Their Sunday roast is a testament to their commitment to quality, featuring tender cuts of meat and flavorful accompaniments.
Situated near the bay, it provides a picturesque view that enhances every dining experience. The Fireside Restaurant is where culinary artistry meets scenic beauty, making it a memorable dining destination.
Lake Aire Supper Club – Sturgeon Bay, WI
Lake Aire Supper Club in Sturgeon Bay is a picturesque spot known for its lakeside views and traditional menu. It’s where locals gather to enjoy delicious meals and beautiful scenery.
The Sunday roast here is a beloved favorite, served with fresh, seasonal sides that enhance its rich flavors.
With a history rooted in the community, Lake Aire Supper Club continues to be a beacon of hospitality and culinary delight. The combination of great food and stunning views makes it an essential stop for any food lover.