When it comes to authentic Neapolitan pizza, Wisconsin might not be the first place that comes to mind. However, nestled throughout the state are hidden gems that offer a slice of Italy in the Midwest. From Milwaukee to Green Lake, these pizzerias capture the essence of Naples with each bite. Discover the unique flavors and atmospheres that make these spots a must-visit for pizza lovers.
San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana – Milwaukee
San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana brings a taste of Naples right to Milwaukee. Known for its wood-fired pies, the pizzeria uses only the finest imported ingredients. Each pizza emerges with a perfectly charred crust, topped with creamy mozzarella and vibrant tomato sauce.
The rustic decor and welcoming atmosphere make it a favorite among locals. Did you know the founder trained in Italy to perfect his craft? Enjoy a slice while sipping on their curated selection of Italian wines.
Whether you’re a local or just visiting, this spot offers an unforgettable culinary experience that transports you straight to Naples.
Novanta Pizzeria – Middleton
Novanta Pizzeria in Middleton is a modern haven for authentic Neapolitan pizza. Renowned for its 90-second cooking time, each pizza is a testament to traditional techniques and flavors. The bustling open kitchen adds a touch of excitement.
Using fresh, local ingredients combined with imported Italian staples, Novanta crafts pizzas that melt in your mouth. The minimalist decor allows the food to take center stage.
A trip here wouldn’t be complete without trying their signature Margherita or the decadent Tartufo. A visit to Novanta is like a quick getaway to Italy, no passport needed.
Il Ritrovo – Sheboygan
Il Ritrovo in Sheboygan is a beloved spot for pizza enthusiasts seeking genuine Neapolitan flavors. The heart of the restaurant is its wood-fired oven, delivering pizzas with a bubbly, crisp crust.
Crafting each pie with organic ingredients, Il Ritrovo emphasizes sustainability and tradition. The inviting setting makes it perfect for family gatherings or a cozy dinner.
The owner’s passion for Italian cuisine shines through every dish. Don’t miss their classic Margherita, a true masterpiece of simplicity and taste. This pizzeria is a cornerstone of Sheboygan’s culinary scene.
Pizza Brutta – Madison
Pizza Brutta, located in Madison, offers a vibrant and unpretentious environment where pizza is the star. Known for using organic and locally sourced ingredients, their commitment to quality is evident in every bite.
The casual setting welcomes families and friends alike. With pizzas cooked to perfection in just minutes, it’s a quick yet delightful dining option.
Their spicy Diavola with Calabrian chilis is a must-try. Pizza Brutta captures the essence of Naples while adding a unique twist with bold flavors and fresh toppings, making it a Madison favorite.
Wells Brothers Italian Restaurant – Mt Pleasant
Wells Brothers Italian Restaurant in Mt Pleasant is a testament to tradition and family heritage. Established in 1921, it has been serving timeless Italian dishes for generations.
Their pizza is thin, crispy, and loaded with rich flavors, reminiscent of old-world Italy. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make every visit memorable.
Try their special house pizza, crafted with love and attention to detail. This pizzeria is not just a dining spot but a piece of Wisconsin’s culinary history, cherished by locals and visitors alike.
Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Madison
Glass Nickel Pizza Co. in Madison is known for its creativity and eclectic menu. Offering an array of unique pizza combinations, it caters to a wide variety of tastes.
The lively atmosphere is complemented by friendly staff and a commitment to community involvement. Their signature pizza, the ‘Cardiac Arrest,’ is both indulgent and irresistible.
Perfect for a casual night out, Glass Nickel’s inventive approach appeals to both adventurous eaters and traditionalists. This pizzeria is a beloved fixture in Madison’s dining scene, known for its fun and flavorful offerings.
Maria’s Pizza – Milwaukee
Maria’s Pizza in Milwaukee is a nostalgic trip back in time, offering pizza with a personal touch. A family-run establishment, it is cherished for its classic recipes and generous toppings.
The interior exudes an old-school vibe, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. Regulars swear by the ‘Super Pizza,’ laden with an abundance of cheese and meats.
Maria’s is more than just pizza; it’s a piece of Milwaukee’s heart, where tradition and taste come together beautifully. Each visit feels like dining with family, filled with love and flavor.
Rustique Pizza & Lounge – Suamico
Rustique Pizza & Lounge in Suamico offers a sophisticated yet relaxed dining experience. Set in a beautifully refurbished barn, it combines rustic charm with modern elegance.
Their gourmet pizzas are a highlight, crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The cozy fireplace and ambient lighting create an intimate setting perfect for date nights.
Don’t miss their ‘Rustique Special,’ a delightful blend of flavors and textures. This pizzeria is a hidden gem in Suamico, offering a unique culinary escape that feels both homely and special.
Cranky Pat’s Pizzeria – Green Bay
Cranky Pat’s Pizzeria in Green Bay is a local legend, known for its generous toppings and hand-tossed crusts. Founded in 1955, it has maintained its reputation through consistently delicious offerings.
The quirky name is matched by its lively interior, making it a favorite for casual hangouts. Their ‘Cranky Pat’s Special’ is a must-try for anyone new to the area.
Cranky Pat’s is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a gathering place where community and flavor meet. Each slice tells a story of tradition and taste in Green Bay.
Fixture Pizza Pub – Milwaukee
Fixture Pizza Pub in Milwaukee combines modern flair with classic pizza-making techniques. The industrial-chic decor offers a trendy backdrop for enjoying their inventive pizza creations.
Known for its craft beer selection, this pub pairs each pizza with the perfect brew. Their ‘Buffalo Chicken Pizza’ is a crowd-pleaser, spicy and flavorful.
The energetic atmosphere makes it a great spot for socializing with friends. Fixture Pizza Pub is a vibrant addition to Milwaukee’s pizza scene, where innovation meets tradition in every bite.
Christianos Pizza – Green Lake
Christianos Pizza in Green Lake is a family-oriented pizzeria known for its friendly service and delicious pies. Each pizza is handmade with care, reflecting the owner’s passion for quality.
The warm, inviting space makes it ideal for family outings. Regulars rave about their ‘Garlic Chicken Pizza,’ which harmonizes flavors beautifully.
Christianos is a slice of Naples in Green Lake, where authenticity and hospitality create a memorable dining experience. It’s a place where community and cuisine come together seamlessly.
Polito’s – Stevens Point
Polito’s in Stevens Point is celebrated for its hearty New York-style slices that fold just right. Known for generous portions and a variety of toppings, it’s a favorite among students and locals alike.
The bustling atmosphere and quick service make it perfect for a grab-and-go meal or a leisurely sit-down. Don’t miss their ‘Mac & Cheese Pizza,’ a unique twist on comfort food.
Polito’s brings a bit of city flair to Stevens Point, offering a delightful fusion of flavors and fun. It’s a must-try for anyone in the area.