Indiana is famed for its tenderloin sandwiches, transforming quaint towns into culinary hotspots. Here’s a list of must-visit places to savor this Hoosier delight.
Nick’s Kitchen – Huntington, IN
Nick’s Kitchen is where tradition meets taste. Known for its legendary tenderloin, the sandwich is as big as the plate it’s served on. The tenderloin is perfectly breaded and fried to golden perfection.
A visit here is like stepping back in time, with its vintage decor and warm, small-town charm. It’s not just a meal; it’s an experience that captures the heart of Huntington.
Locals and travelers alike are drawn to Nick’s for its history and hearty servings, making it a beloved stop in Indiana’s culinary map.
The Mug – Greenfield, IN
The Mug in Greenfield puts a unique spin on the classic drive-in. Famous for its locally sourced ingredients, their tenderloin sandwich is a testament to quality.
The thick, juicy cut of meat is hand-breaded and served with fresh toppings. The Mug offers a fun, nostalgic feel with its retro vibe and carhop service.
This isn’t just about eating; it’s about reliving the golden era of drive-ins, making it a favorite for families and food enthusiasts alike.
Lumpy’s – Cambridge City, IN
At Lumpy’s, you’ll find a sandwich that’s as hearty as the hospitality. Known for its oversized tenderloin, this local gem offers a rustic, welcoming atmosphere.
The tenderloin is expertly cooked, with a crisp exterior that gives way to a juicy interior, capturing the essence of Indiana comfort food.
It’s a delightful stop where the warmth of the community is as inviting as the food itself. Lumpy’s is where you go for a taste of home and a hearty laugh with locals.
One Eyed Jack’s – Winamac, IN
One Eyed Jack’s offers more than just a meal; it’s an escape into a friendly pub atmosphere. Their tenderloin is a standout, perfectly balancing flavor and texture.
With a golden, crispy crust and tender center, each bite is satisfying. The pub setting enhances the experience with its lively ambiance.
It’s the perfect spot to gather with friends and enjoy local brews alongside your meal. Here, every visit feels like a celebration of good taste and good company.
Shipley’s Tavern – Madison, IN
Shipley’s Tavern in Madison is where history and flavor meet. Known for its inviting wooden interiors, it offers a tenderloin sandwich that’s both hearty and flavorful.
The sandwich is generously sized, with a succulent, seasoned tenderloin that pairs beautifully with their craft beer selection.
This tavern is a cherished spot for locals and visitors seeking a taste of tradition in a storied setting. It’s where stories are shared over satisfying meals.
The Oasis Diner – Plainfield, IN
The Oasis Diner in Plainfield is a beacon of retro charm. Known for its classic American diner experience, the tenderloin sandwich is a highlight.
Served in a nostalgic setting with checkered floors and vintage booths, it’s an experience that feels straight out of the 1950s. The tenderloin is generous and delicious, making each visit memorable.
Pair it with a milkshake for the full diner experience. The Oasis is where the past meets the palate, creating lasting memories.
Mrs. Wick’s Restaurant & Pie Shop – Winchester, IN
Mrs. Wick’s is a hub of homemade goodness in Winchester. While renowned for its pies, the tenderloin sandwich is a must-try.
This cozy eatery serves a perfectly breaded tenderloin that complements their famous desserts. The warm atmosphere makes every visit feel like a family gathering.
It’s a place where comfort food reigns supreme, offering both savory and sweet delights. Mrs. Wick’s captures the essence of home-cooked tradition in every bite.
Brewery Lodge – Michigan City, IN
Brewery Lodge in Michigan City marries craft beer excellence with culinary expertise. Their tenderloin sandwich is a robust offering, reflecting the hearty nature of the venue.
The sandwich is large and satisfying, pairing perfectly with their diverse beer selection. The rustic lodge setting enhances the dining experience, providing a cozy escape.
It’s a destination for those seeking a retreat into delicious food and fine brews. Here, relaxation and taste come together beautifully.
The Friendly Tavern – Zionsville, IN
The Friendly Tavern in Zionsville is true to its name, providing a warm and inviting dining experience. Their tenderloin sandwich is a beloved staple.
Served with a side of crispy fries, the sandwich is a testament to traditional flavors done right. The lively atmosphere makes it a great spot for gatherings.
It’s a place where hospitality and hearty food create a memorable outing. The Friendly Tavern captures the spirit of Zionsville, one delicious meal at a time.
The Aristocrat Pub & Restaurant – Indianapolis, IN
The Aristocrat Pub in Indianapolis combines elegance with indulgence. Known for its gourmet take on the tenderloin sandwich, it offers a refined dining experience.
The pub’s stylish decor adds to the sophisticated ambiance, making it perfect for a special outing. The tenderloin is expertly prepared, offering a savory delight.
It’s where the traditional meets the modern in an exquisite setting. The Aristocrat provides a touch of class in every bite and sip.
Kermit’s Food Shop Bar & Grill – Andrews, IN
Kermit’s in Andrews is where casual meets delicious. Known for its lively atmosphere, it offers a tenderloin sandwich that’s a crowd-pleaser.
The sandwich is perfectly seasoned, making it a standout on their menu. The bar and grill’s relaxed vibe is ideal for enjoying good food and company.
It’s a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike, offering a taste of comfort in every bite. Kermit’s is where hearty meals and friendly faces come together.
33 Brick Street – French Lick, IN
33 Brick Street in French Lick is where sports enthusiasm and great food intersect. Their tenderloin sandwich is as impressive as their collection of sports memorabilia.
The sandwich is large and flavorful, offering a satisfying meal for sports fans and foodies alike. The vibrant atmosphere highlights local sports history.
It’s a place where delicious food and community pride go hand in hand, making it a favorite destination. 33 Brick Street combines hearty dining with a love for sports.