If you love tangy citrus desserts, Florida hides some tiny bakeries serving key lime magic that locals whisper about. These spots tuck their treasures behind pastel doors and sunny counters, where every slice tastes like a beach day. You will find pies, bars, donuts, and dreamy mousses that balance tart and sweet just right. Let’s chase them down before the secret gets out.
Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop – Elizabeth Street – Key West, Florida
At Kermit’s on Elizabeth Street, the air smells like fresh zest and buttery crust. You see classic key lime pies crowned with swirls of cream, plus chocolate dipped slices for a playful twist. The filling lands bright, never harsh, and the graham crust stays crisp even in island humidity.
Grab a frozen key lime bar on a stick and wander toward the harbor. You will taste sunshine in every bite, a tart snap that wakes you up fast. Locals point you to seasonal specials, like coconut lime tarts and mini pie bites that pack a punch.
Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory ® – Tavernier, Florida
In Tavernier, Blond Giraffe delivers a key lime lineup that keeps road trippers pulling over. Their pie on a stick, dipped in glossy chocolate, is the cult favorite. The texture sits between silky and bright, with lime oils perfuming every forkful.
You will find crumbly graham shells that hold their shape, plus meringue peaks toasted just right. Try the key lime tarts for an easy beach snack. The patio is cozy, shaded by palms, and perfect for sharing a box of minis while the Overseas Highway hums nearby.
Old Town Bakery – Key West, Florida
Old Town Bakery hides key lime gems beside crusty baguettes and buttery croissants. Their key lime tart is restrained and elegant, with a smooth custard that finishes clean. The crust brings a whisper of salt, keeping sweetness in line.
You can grab a slice for breakfast alongside cold brew, which sharpens the citrus. Locals order key lime bars to go, stashing them for later beach picnics. This place feels lived in and friendly, the kind of counter where someone remembers your name and hands you extra napkins.
Moondog Cafe Key West – Key West, Florida
Moondog Cafe bakes key lime into creative forms, from cheesecake to cream-filled cupcakes. The vibe is playful, brunchy, and bright, with a patio that feels like a hidden garden. Their key lime cheesecake lands lush but balanced, finishing with a limey sparkle.
Order a slice after eggs and coffee, or just come for dessert and sunshine. You will love the buttery biscuit crust and the generous zest spiraled on top. Ask for seasonal twists like mango-lime drizzle or toasted coconut flakes, which add beachy perfume and crunch.
Sister Honey’s – Orlando, Florida
Sister Honey’s wins awards for good reason, and the key lime pie explains why. The filling is vivid and silky, with that gentle pucker you crave. A sturdy graham crust supports each neat slice, perfect for sharing or keeping to yourself.
You will notice finesse in the zest, never bitter, and a whisper of vanilla rounding the edges. The team here treats every pie like a celebration, rosettes piped with care. Grab a whole pie for parties, or a single slice and a fork when the craving hits.
The Glass Knife – Winter Park, Florida
The Glass Knife brings couture polish to key lime. Their tart is jewel bright, set in a crisp shell that shatters neatly. The curd leans tangy with a velvety glide, the kind that feels both indulgent and refreshing.
You will find thoughtful details like lime confit or white chocolate curls. Coffee service is dialed in, and the pairing makes the citrus sing. Sit by the window, watch Park Avenue life roll by, and savor each tidy bite that proves precision can still feel joyful.
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop – Miami, Florida
Fireman Derek’s cranks up the volume on flavor, and the key lime pie keeps that promise. The filling pops with citrus, while torched meringue adds caramel notes. Portions are generous, so bring a friend or just commit.
You will taste Miami energy in every forkful, bold yet balanced. Try the key lime cheesecake slice if you want extra richness. The line moves fast, beats spill from the speakers, and soon you are outside with a box that smells like lime zest and sugar.
Pete’s Sweet Treats – Sarasota, Florida
Pete’s Sweet Treats feels like a neighborhood secret, and the key lime bars prove it. They are tart, buttery, and portable, with just enough powdered sugar to balance the zip. The crust has a sandy snap that echoes the nearby beach.
You will appreciate the no fuss charm and fair prices. Grab a coffee and a two pack for a seaside walk. Locals swear the bars taste even better chilled, when the lemony-lime edges sharpen and the top sets to a perfect sheen.
Hellas Restaurant & Bakery – Tarpon Springs, Florida
Hellas blends Greek bakery tradition with Florida citrus, turning out a striking key lime pie. The custard leans bright, layered onto a crumb crust that whispers cinnamon. Portions are generous, perfect after a stroll along the sponge docks.
You will find other lime treats too, like petite tarts beside baklava. The dining room gleams white and blue, and the pastry case feels endless. Share a slice, then take another to go, because the tangy finish keeps calling you back.
Cinotti’s Bakery-Sandwich Shop – Jacksonville Beach, Florida
Cinotti’s makes mornings brighter with key lime donuts and pies that taste like a beach day. The donut glaze carries real citrus zing, never sticky sweet. Their pie is classic, with a balanced custard and a graham crust that stays crisp.
You will want to snag a box for friends after surfing or school drop off. The staff moves quick, coffee is strong, and everything smells like fresh baking. Watch locals breeze in, grab their favorites, and head back to the sun.
Frida’s Cafe & Bakery – Largo, Florida
Frida’s balances craft and comfort, especially with their key lime mousse cups. Light and tangy, the mousse keeps its shape, topped with zest and a tiny cookie. If you prefer classic, the pie slices come neat and photo ready.
You will feel welcome lingering with an iced latte while the citrus aroma drifts by. Seasonal versions add berries or a tiny chocolate wedge. Everything tastes clean, bright, and thoughtfully made, the kind of dessert that disappears before you realize it.
Freida’s Bakery and Provisions – Palm Coast, Florida
Freida’s turns key lime into charming minis and loaf slices that feel homemade yet polished. The mini pies pack intense citrus into a tidy crust with delicate crumble. Their key lime pound cake lands moist and aromatic, perfect with tea.
You will enjoy the calm space, shelves of provisions, and friendly chats at the counter. Ask about limited weekend bakes that sell out fast. Take a box for a coastal drive, and snack as the sea breeze adds its own finishing salt.