Explore the heart of Florida with its iconic key lime pies, a treat that’s both a cultural staple and a beloved dessert. Discover 14 unique pie shops where the tart and tangy key lime still reigns supreme. These establishments capture the essence of Florida’s culinary heritage, offering a slice of sunshine in every bite.
Blue Heaven – Key West, FL
Blue Heaven offers a whimsical dining experience in Key West, where chickens roam freely amidst vibrant decor. This lively spot is famous for its outstanding key lime pie, topped with a towering meringue.
Guests often enjoy their dessert in the open-air courtyard, soaking in the eclectic atmosphere that’s as memorable as the pie itself.
The pie at Blue Heaven is a nod to traditional recipes, yet it stands out with unique flair, making it a must-visit for pie enthusiasts.
TrendingNow
Key Lime Pie Bakery – Key West, FL
Key Lime Pie Bakery in Key West is a hidden gem for those seeking the quintessential taste of Florida. With its pastel-colored facade, the bakery invites you to indulge in pie perfection.
Renowned for its creamy texture and zesty flavor, their key lime pie captures the essence of the tropics in every slice.
This bakery is a haven for pie lovers, offering a genuine taste of Key West’s culinary tradition, and a delightful escape into sweetness.
Mattheessen’s Homemade – Key West, FL
Nestled in the heart of Key West, Mattheessen’s Homemade delights visitors with its cozy charm. Known initially for its cookies, this bakery has mastered the art of key lime pie.
The pie here is celebrated for its rich flavor and crumbly graham crust, drawing patrons back time and again.
Mattheessen’s is more than just a bakery; it’s a comforting reminder of home, wrapped in the warmth of freshly baked pies.
Joe’s Stone Crab – Miami Beach, FL
Joe’s Stone Crab in Miami Beach is synonymous with culinary excellence. While famous for seafood, it’s their key lime pie that steals the show for dessert lovers.
This elegant restaurant serves a pie that boasts a smooth filling and a buttery crust, a perfect finish to any meal.
Dining at Joe’s offers a taste of Miami’s rich history, where key lime pie has earned its rightful place on the menu as a staple.
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop – Miami, FL
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop is a Miami treasure, bringing vibrant flavors to the table. Known for its creative desserts, their key lime pie is a standout.
With its delightful tartness and creamy consistency, each slice is a masterpiece. Fireman Derek’s is a haven for sweet treats, celebrated for its innovation and passion.
This bake shop is not just a place to buy pies; it’s an experience that turns any day into a special occasion with its sweet offerings.
Yoder’s Restaurant – Sarasota, FL
Yoder’s Restaurant in Sarasota is a beloved family-owned establishment where tradition meets taste. Famous for its homemade pies, their key lime offering is a fan favorite.
The pie is crafted with care, featuring a rich filling that satisfies the soul. The rustic ambiance of Yoder’s adds to the charm, inviting diners to savor each bite.
This restaurant is more than a dining spot; it’s a cherished local fixture where comfort and flavor go hand in hand.
Der Dutchman – Sarasota, FL
In Sarasota, Der Dutchman is a name synonymous with warmth and hospitality. This welcoming restaurant is renowned for its wide array of pies, with key lime pie being a standout.
Each pie is a testament to quality, featuring a perfectly tart filling and a golden crust. Der Dutchman’s is a gathering place for those who appreciate hearty meals and sweet endings.
The restaurant offers more than just food; it’s an invitation to enjoy a slice of homely goodness in every pie.
Sweetwater Organic Community Farm – Tampa, FL
Sweetwater Organic Community Farm in Tampa offers a unique blend of nature and culinary delight. Known for fresh produce, the farm’s homemade key lime pie is a delightful surprise.
Crafted with organic ingredients, the pie presents a fresh, tangy flavor that embodies the spirit of farm-to-table dining.
The farm stand at Sweetwater is more than just a market; it’s a community hub where delicious pies meet sustainable practices, offering a genuine taste of Florida’s bounty.
Mike’s Pies Inc – Tampa, FL
Mike’s Pies Inc in Tampa is a powerhouse of pie perfection. Known for award-winning desserts, their key lime pie is a highlight of their lineup.
Each pie is crafted with precision, blending creamy fillings with a distinctive tang that delights the palate.
Mike’s commitment to quality is evident in every slice, making it a go-to destination for those seeking pie excellence in Tampa.
Jerry’s Foods – Sanibel, FL
Jerry’s Foods in Sanibel combines the convenience of a grocery with the joy of gourmet pies. Their key lime pie is a local favorite, offering a refreshing taste of the island.
The pie boasts a smooth texture and a vibrant lime flavor, making it a delightful treat for all. Jerry’s is more than a store; it’s a culinary experience that brings the flavors of Sanibel to life.
Whether shopping for groceries or indulging in dessert, Jerry’s is the place to be.
Bob Roth’s New River Groves – Davie, FL
Bob Roth’s New River Groves in Davie is a citrus lover’s dream, offering the freshest produce and an unforgettable key lime pie.
The market’s pies are crafted with locally sourced ingredients, capturing the essence of Florida in every bite. The outdoor seating area invites guests to enjoy their pie amidst the grove’s natural beauty.
This market is more than a shopping stop; it’s a slice of Florida’s citrus heritage, lovingly baked into every pie.
Dunkin’ – Ocala, FL
While known for coffee, Dunkin’ in Ocala surprises with its limited-time key lime offerings. This bustling spot adds a twist to the classic donut menu with key lime-inspired treats.
These offerings provide a refreshing alternative for those craving the tangy delight of key lime, even in a quick-stop coffee shop.
Dunkin’ proves that key lime flavor is versatile, bringing a touch of Florida’s signature taste to a national chain.
Southern Grounds & Co. – Jacksonville, FL
Southern Grounds & Co. in Jacksonville provides a relaxed cafe experience with a focus on quality and community. Known for their artisanal approach, their key lime pie is a standout.
The pie’s creamy texture and zesty flavor make it a beloved choice among regulars. Southern Grounds offers more than a meal; it’s a space to unwind and enjoy the finer things in life.
Each visit promises a taste of Jacksonville’s vibrant cafe culture, served with a slice of delightful pie.
Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop – Elizabeth Street – Key West, FL
Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop stands as a testament to the enduring love for key lime in Key West. Nestled on Elizabeth Street, this quaint shop is adorned with tropical aesthetics that echo the flavors within.
The shop’s pies are celebrated for their perfect balance of tartness and sweetness, earning a cherished spot in many hearts. Kermit’s is not just about the pies; it’s a legendary stop for both locals and tourists.
A visit to Key West feels incomplete without tasting Kermit’s signature pie, a true embodiment of the island’s spirit.
Discussion about this post