Discover the top 15 pie shops in America where the key lime pie remains a beloved classic. From Florida’s sun-kissed coasts to the bustling streets of Seattle, these destinations promise a tangy taste of tradition.
Key West Key Lime Pie Co. – Key West, FL
In the heart of Key West lies the Key West Key Lime Pie Co., renowned for its commitment to tradition. With a focus on quality ingredients, their pies boast an authentic taste that resonates with all who try them.
This shop’s dedication to preserving the essence of the original recipe is evident in every bite. The vibrant atmosphere adds to the allure, making it a favorite destination.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, a stop here guarantees a delightful slice of Florida’s iconic dessert.
TrendingNow
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop – Miami, FL
Miami’s Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop, founded by a retired firefighter, brings a unique twist to key lime pie. Known for their generous portions and bold flavors, this shop offers a pie experience unlike any other.
The pies are crafted with a focus on fresh ingredients and innovative techniques, resulting in a rich, zesty flavor. The combination of texture and taste is truly memorable.
With its lively atmosphere and creative approach, Fireman Derek’s has become a staple in Miami’s dessert scene.
Mattheessen’s Homemade – Key West, FL
Mattheessen’s Homemade in Key West is a haven for those seeking a classic key lime pie experience. Known for its welcoming environment, this shop offers a delightful retreat from the bustling streets.
The pies are celebrated for their smooth texture and perfect balance of sweet and tart. Each slice captures the essence of the tropics, making it a favorite among locals.
Whether enjoyed on-site or taken to go, Mattheessen’s delivers a consistent taste of Key West’s iconic dessert.
Blue Heaven – Key West, FL
Blue Heaven in Key West offers more than just delicious key lime pie; it provides an unforgettable experience. Known for its eclectic setting, this spot combines great food with a laid-back vibe.
The pie’s creamy texture and punchy lime flavor make it a standout choice. Paired with the restaurant’s tropical ambiance, every visit becomes a memorable occasion.
With its unique charm and flavorful offerings, Blue Heaven continues to be a beloved destination for pie lovers.
Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop – DeLand – DeLand, FL
In DeLand, Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop offers the same beloved pies found in Key West, bringing the taste of Florida to a wider audience. This location maintains the iconic quality and flavor.
Known for its lively decor and friendly service, the shop creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Each slice embodies the traditional recipe’s tangy perfection.
Whether you’re familiar with the brand or a first-time visitor, Kermit’s in DeLand promises a satisfying pie experience.
Sweetwater Organic Community Farm – Tampa, FL
Tampa’s Sweetwater Organic Community Farm is not only about fresh produce but also a delightful key lime pie. Nestled amid the farm’s natural beauty, the pie shop offers a true taste of Florida’s bounty.
Crafted with organic ingredients, each pie delivers pure, authentic flavor. The farm’s commitment to sustainability enhances the overall dining experience.
Visitors can enjoy a slice while exploring the farm, creating a perfect blend of nature and culinary delight.
Der Dutchman – Sarasota, FL
Der Dutchman in Sarasota adds a unique twist to the key lime pie tradition. Known for its Amish-style cooking, this restaurant combines heartwarming hospitality with delicious desserts.
Their key lime pie stands out for its smooth texture and refreshing taste. The restaurant’s inviting atmosphere complements the culinary experience.
For those seeking a comforting, home-cooked vibe, Der Dutchman offers a delightful taste of Florida with every slice.
Pie Junkie – Oklahoma City, OK
Pie Junkie in Oklahoma City brings creativity and flair to the world of key lime pies. Known for their artistic approach, this shop offers pies that are as visually appealing as they are delicious.
The pies feature a perfect balance of tangy lime and sweet cream, satisfying even the most discerning palate. The vibrant setting adds to the shop’s charm.
With its innovative spirit, Pie Junkie continues to capture the hearts of pie enthusiasts.
Dangerously Delicious HQ & Test Kitchen Bar – Baltimore, MD
Baltimore’s Dangerously Delicious HQ & Test Kitchen Bar is a haven for adventurous pie lovers. Known for its bold flavors, this shop offers a distinctive take on key lime pie.
The pie’s tangy zest and smooth consistency create a delightful contrast, making it a standout choice. The bar’s innovative approach shines through in every bite.
For those seeking a daring twist on a classic favorite, Dangerously Delicious delivers a memorable culinary experience.
Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop – Elizabeth Street – Key West, FL
Nestled in Key West, Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop on Elizabeth Street is a cornerstone for citrus lovers. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and classic recipe, this shop has been delighting locals and tourists alike.
Kermit’s offers a creamy, tangy pie that has become synonymous with Florida’s culinary heritage. The blend of fresh key lime juice and a perfect graham cracker crust creates a refreshing experience.
Visitors often stop by for a slice after enjoying the nearby beach. With its charming ambiance, Kermit’s remains a must-visit for pie enthusiasts.
Pie Bar – Seattle, WA
Seattle’s Pie Bar offers a contemporary twist on the beloved key lime pie. Known for its sleek design and warm ambiance, this shop serves pies that balance tradition with modern flair.
The pies boast a creamy texture and tangy flavor, appealing to both purists and adventurous eaters. The inviting setting enhances the overall experience.
Pie Bar’s unique approach to a classic dessert continues to win over visitors and locals alike.
The Pie Spot – Portland, OR
In Portland, The Pie Spot crafts key lime pies with a dash of creativity. Known for its artisanal approach, this shop infuses each pie with both flavor and character.
The pies are celebrated for their bright lime taste and buttery crust. The shop’s welcoming atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a local favorite.
With its artistic spirit, The Pie Spot continues to delight pie enthusiasts with every slice.
Just Pies Inc – Westerville, OH
Just Pies Inc in Westerville takes a straightforward approach to key lime pie. Known for its no-frills style, this shop focuses on delivering pure flavor.
The pies are celebrated for their smooth consistency and vibrant tartness. The shop’s homey feel and friendly service create an inviting atmosphere.
For those seeking a genuine taste of tradition, Just Pies offers a slice of pie heaven.
Three Babes Bakeshop – San Francisco, CA
Three Babes Bakeshop in San Francisco is known for its organic, locally-sourced ingredients, making their key lime pies a standout. The shop’s commitment to quality shines through in every pie.
The pies combine a tangy lime flavor with a flaky crust, creating a delightful contrast. The shop’s rustic charm and dedication to sustainability add to the experience.
Three Babes Bakeshop continues to be a beloved spot for pie aficionados seeking both flavor and ethics.
Bob Roth’s New River Groves – Davie, FL
Bob Roth’s New River Groves in Davie offers a farm-fresh take on key lime pie. Known for its use of local ingredients, this shop delivers a true taste of Florida.
The pies are celebrated for their zest and freshness, embodying the essence of the Sunshine State. The farm-style setting enhances the overall experience.
For those seeking an authentic slice of Florida, Bob Roth’s New River Groves is a must-visit destination.
Discussion about this post