From Brooklyn’s bustling streets to Hawaii’s tropical shores, America boasts a delightful array of pie shops where tradition and taste meet. These 19 pie havens offer slices of comfort and nostalgia, each with its unique charm. Let’s explore these sweet destinations where each bite tells a story.
Four & Twenty Blackbirds – Brooklyn, New York
In Brooklyn, Four & Twenty Blackbirds is a must-visit for pie enthusiasts. Known for inventive flavors and rustic charm, this shop is a slice of heaven. Sisters Emily and Melissa Elsen have crafted a menu that includes the beloved Salted Caramel Apple Pie.
Each pie is made with locally sourced ingredients, reflecting the seasons and the city’s vibrant spirit. The atmosphere is as warm as the pies themselves, making it a favorite gathering spot.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, this pie shop promises a memorable culinary experience.
TrendingNow
Stockholm Pie & General Store – Stockholm, Wisconsin
Nestled in the charming town of Stockholm, Wisconsin, this pie shop is a hidden gem. The Stockholm Pie & General Store offers a delightful mix of sweet and savory pies, each crafted with love.
Visitors rave about the Triple Berry Pie, a sweet-tart delight. The shop also features local goods, creating a cozy community hub.
Surrounded by scenic views, it’s the perfect stop for travelers exploring the area. The friendly staff ensures you leave with a smile and a pie to remember.
Achatz Handmade Pie Co. – Armada, Michigan
Achatz Handmade Pie Co. in Armada, Michigan, is famed for its delicious, fresh-baked pies. With a history rooted in family tradition, this shop offers a slice of nostalgia.
Their Michigan 4-Berry Pie is a crowd favorite, bursting with flavors of the region’s finest fruits. Each pie is crafted with care, emphasizing quality ingredients.
The shop’s warm, welcoming atmosphere makes it a beloved destination for pie lovers from near and far.
Hoosier Mama Pie Company – Chicago, Illinois
In the heart of Chicago, Hoosier Mama Pie Company combines nostalgia with culinary innovation. This beloved pie shop offers an eclectic menu of classic and inventive flavors.
The Honey Pie is a standout, known for its rich, sweet taste. The shop’s decor harks back to a bygone era, adding to its unique charm.
Regulars enjoy both the pies and the welcoming atmosphere. It’s a slice of comfort in the bustling city.
Lauretta Jean’s – Portland, Oregon
Lauretta Jean’s, located in Portland, Oregon, is a pie lover’s paradise. Known for its artistic approach to pie-making, the shop offers a delightful selection.
The Chocolate Cream Pie is a local favorite, rich and decadent. The lively atmosphere and creative presentation make it a standout.
The shop’s dedication to quality and innovation ensures every visit is a delightful experience, whether you’re a pie aficionado or a casual visitor.
JaWanda’s Sweet Potato Pies – Birmingham, Alabama
JaWanda’s Sweet Potato Pies in Birmingham is a testament to Southern hospitality and flavor. Known for its signature sweet potato pies, this shop offers a true taste of the South.
The pies are crafted with family recipes, ensuring a heartfelt experience with every bite. The shop’s warm, inviting atmosphere adds to its charm.
Whether you’re a fan of traditional Southern desserts or seeking something new, JaWanda’s promises satisfaction.
Just Pies – Westerville, Ohio
In Westerville, Ohio, Just Pies is as straightforward as it sounds. This shop focuses purely on pies, delivering a range of flavors and styles.
The Buckeye Pie, inspired by Ohio’s state tree, is a local treat, combining peanut butter and chocolate. The shop’s no-frills approach emphasizes quality and taste.
Regulars appreciate the friendly service and consistent quality, making it a staple in the community.
Hawaiian Pie Company – Honolulu, Hawaii
In Honolulu, the Hawaiian Pie Company offers a tropical twist on classic pies. Known for incorporating local fruits, this shop is a taste of island paradise.
The Passion Fruit Pie is a unique highlight, offering a sweet and tangy flavor. The shop’s vibrant decor and friendly staff create a welcoming atmosphere.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, it’s a delicious escape to the tropics with every bite.
Heather’s Pies – Minneapolis, Minnesota
Heather’s Pies in Minneapolis brings a touch of Scandinavian warmth to every slice. Known for its beautifully crafted pies, this shop offers a variety of flavors.
The Lingonberry Pie is a Nordic-inspired treat, balancing tartness with sweetness. The cozy interior and friendly service enhance its appeal.
For those seeking a comforting, flavorful experience, Heather’s Pies is a delightful destination.
Kermit’s Key West Lime Shoppe – Key West, Florida
Famed for its authentic Key Lime Pie, Kermit’s Key West Lime Shoppe is a Florida icon. Located in Key West, this shop captures the essence of the tropics.
The pies are tangy and refreshing, crafted with real key lime juice. The shop’s coastal vibe and vibrant decor enhance the tropical experience.
A visit to Key West isn’t complete without a taste of Kermit’s signature pie.
Michele’s Pies – Norwalk, Connecticut
Michele’s Pies in Norwalk, Connecticut, is celebrated for its award-winning creations. This charming shop offers a variety of flavors, each crafted with expertise.
The Maple Pumpkin Pie is a seasonal favorite, combining rich flavors with a smooth texture. The shop’s cozy ambiance adds to its appeal.
With a reputation for excellence, Michele’s Pies is a staple for locals and visitors alike.
Little Pie Company – New York City, New York
Located in the heart of New York City, the Little Pie Company offers big flavors in small packages. Known for its mini pies, this shop is a city favorite.
The Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie is a standout, offering a unique twist on a classic. The urban chic decor and lively atmosphere make it a popular spot.
Whether you’re on the go or leisurely enjoying a slice, it’s a delightful treat in the city that never sleeps.
Miss American Pie – Brooklyn, New York
Miss American Pie in Brooklyn is a nostalgic nod to classic American desserts. This retro-style shop offers an array of traditional flavors.
The Cherry Pie is a customer favorite, celebrated for its perfect balance of tartness and sweetness. The shop’s Americana decor adds to its charm.
With a friendly atmosphere and delicious pies, it’s a sweet slice of nostalgia in a modern city.
Maui Pie – Kihei, Hawaii
Maui Pie in Kihei offers a taste of paradise with each slice. Known for its exotic flavors, this shop captures the spirit of Hawaii.
The Coconut Cream Pie is a tropical delight, rich and creamy with a hint of island sweetness. The beachside location and vibrant decor enhance the experience.
For a true taste of Maui, this pie shop is a must-visit for island flavors and relaxation.
Georgia’s Sweet Potato Pie Company – Louisville, Kentucky
In Louisville, Georgia’s Sweet Potato Pie Company brings Southern tradition to life. Specializing in sweet potato pies, this shop is a regional favorite.
Each pie is crafted with a family recipe, ensuring authenticity and flavor. The homey atmosphere invites guests to relax and savor their slice.
For a true taste of Southern comfort, Georgia’s is the perfect place to indulge.
I Like Pie – Claremont, California
In Claremont, California, I Like Pie offers a whimsical twist on traditional pies. Known for its unique mini pies, this shop is a playful delight.
The Lemon Lavender Pie is a standout, with its refreshing citrus notes and floral undertones. The cheerful decor and friendly staff enhance the experience.
Whether you’re exploring new flavors or sticking to classics, it’s a joyful stop for pie lovers.
The Pie Shop – Washington, D.C.
The Pie Shop in Washington, D.C., combines elegance with artisanal quality. Known for its beautifully crafted pies, this shop is a city gem.
The Bourbon Pecan Pie is a favorite, offering a rich, nutty flavor with a hint of warmth. The minimalist decor and stylish presentation make it a sophisticated choice.
For those seeking refined taste and quality, The Pie Shop delivers in every slice.
Sugar & Slice – Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Sugar & Slice in Philadelphia offers a vibrant take on traditional pies. Known for its creative flavors, this shop is a local favorite.
The Blueberry Basil Pie combines unexpected flavors into a delightful treat. The eclectic decor and warm staff create a lively atmosphere.
For those seeking innovation and taste, Sugar & Slice is the perfect destination for a pie with personality.
Julian Pie Company – Julian, California
Nestled in the apple-rich region of Julian, California, Julian Pie Company is a local treasure. Specializing in apple pies, the shop offers a slice of rustic charm.
The Dutch Apple Pie stands out with its crumbly topping and sweet filling. Visitors enjoy the scenic orchard views and the shop’s cozy atmosphere.
A beloved stop for tourists and locals alike, it captures the essence of its picturesque surroundings.
Discussion about this post