Fast Food Club Fast Food Club

20 Old-School Sub Shops Across America Stuffing Rolls So Heavy They Need Two Hands

Evan Cook 9 min read
20 Old School Sub Shops Across America Stuffing Rolls So Heavy They Need Two Hands
20 Old-School Sub Shops Across America Stuffing Rolls So Heavy They Need Two Hands

Explore twenty iconic sub shops across the United States, where the sandwiches are packed so fully you’ll need both hands to handle them. These locations are steeped in tradition, offering unique flavors and experiences.

White House Subs – Atlantic City, New Jersey

White House Subs - Atlantic City, New Jersey
© White House Subs

In the heart of Atlantic City, White House Subs has been a staple since 1946. Known for their gigantic Italian subs, they overflow with generous portions of meats, cheeses, and fresh toppings. The cozy atmosphere echoes the nostalgia of yesteryears.

Locals and tourists alike flock here, eager to savor a taste of history wrapped in a soft, freshly baked roll. The vibrant flavors and warm hospitality make every visit memorable.

Did you know? Their signature sub is so famous that celebrities like Frank Sinatra once frequented the shop. It’s a must-visit for any sandwich lover.

DiBella’s Italian Market – Rochester, New York

DiBella's Italian Market - Rochester, New York
© DiBella’s Italian Market

DiBella’s Italian Market in Rochester is famous for its classic, overfilled subs. Each sandwich is crafted with precision, featuring fresh-baked bread and authentic Italian ingredients.

The market’s rustic charm and dedication to quality set it apart. From the spicy capicola to the crisp lettuce, every bite is a tribute to traditional Italian flavors.

Originating in 1918, DiBella’s has a rich history that continues to draw dedicated fans. Their commitment to craft makes their subs a Rochester icon.

Jersey Giant Subs! – Grand Ledge, Michigan

Jersey Giant Subs! - Grand Ledge, Michigan
© Jersey Giant Subs!

At Jersey Giant Subs! in Grand Ledge, Michigan, size truly matters. Their subs are famously large, stacked with fresh deli meats and vibrant veggies.

The retro decor and inviting atmosphere provide a unique dining experience. Customers rave about the combination of quality ingredients and generous portions.

With a focus on freshness and flavor, Jersey Giant has made a name for itself across Michigan. The playful energy of the shop is as enticing as their sandwiches.

Capriotti’s Sandwich Shop – Wilmington, Delaware

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop - Wilmington, Delaware
© Capriotti’s Sandwich Shop

Capriotti’s in Wilmington offers a taste of Thanksgiving all year round. Their signature Bobby sub is a hearty creation filled with turkey, stuffing, and cranberry sauce.

The warm, welcoming vibe of the shop complements their inventive menu. Each bite is a celebration of flavors that feels both familiar and exciting.

Founded in 1976, Capriotti’s has expanded but maintains its roots in quality and creativity. It’s a beloved destination for sandwich enthusiasts.

Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar – Monroeville, Pennsylvania

Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar - Monroeville, Pennsylvania
© Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar

Primanti Bros. is a Pittsburgh classic, known for sandwiches that redefine tradition. Their colossal creations include the unique twist of adding coleslaw and fries right into the sandwich.

The lively, industrial setting enhances the bold flavors and hearty portions. Each sandwich is a testament to the unconventional spirit of the area.

Since 1933, they’ve been crafting these iconic meals, making them a staple of Pennsylvania’s culinary scene. A visit promises a flavorful adventure.

Carmen’s Deli – Bellmawr, New Jersey

Carmen's Deli - Bellmawr, New Jersey
© Carmen’s Deli

Carmen’s Deli in Bellmawr offers a hometown feel with hoagies that are anything but ordinary. Their subs are generously packed, offering a delightful mix of meats, cheeses, and fresh toppings.

The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make each visit feel like coming home. It’s a place where tradition and taste meet perfectly.

Opened in 1929, Carmen’s is a beloved local institution, celebrated for its commitment to quality and community. Their hoagies are a true delight.

Sub Shop Deli – Webb City, Missouri

Sub Shop Deli - Webb City, Missouri
© Sub Shop Deli

In Webb City, Sub Shop Deli offers hefty sandwiches that capture the essence of small-town charm. Each sub is carefully crafted with a mix of meats, cheeses, and garden-fresh produce.

The welcoming environment and personalized service create a delightful experience for visitors. It’s a hidden gem where quality is never compromised.

Since opening, Sub Shop Deli has been a community favorite, known for their hearty portions and delicious flavors. It’s well worth a visit.

Hoagie Haven – Princeton, New Jersey

Hoagie Haven - Princeton, New Jersey
© Hoagie Haven

Hoagie Haven is legendary for its mammoth hoagies that have fed hungry students and locals for decades. Located near Princeton University, it’s a bustling spot with a vibrant atmosphere.

The sandwiches are loaded with diverse ingredients, from spicy meats to fresh veggies, satisfying every craving. Each bite is a burst of flavor.

Since 1974, they’ve been a staple of the Princeton area, offering unforgettable taste and generous portions. It’s a must-visit for anyone in New Jersey.

Dagwoods Deli Sub Shop – Bloomington, Indiana

Dagwoods Deli Sub Shop - Bloomington, Indiana
© Dagwoods Deli Sub Shop

Dagwoods Deli in Bloomington is a quirky, colorful haven for sandwich lovers. Their subs are towering creations filled with premium meats and fresh toppings.

The vibrant decor and friendly staff add to the playful experience, making it a favorite among locals and students alike.

Established in 1985, Dagwoods is known for creativity and quality. Their commitment to freshness and flavor keeps customers coming back for more.

Submarine House – Troy, Ohio

Submarine House - Troy, Ohio
© Submarine House

Submarine House in Troy offers a nautical twist on traditional subs. Their footlongs are packed with layers of meats and cheeses that are sure to satisfy any appetite.

The lively atmosphere, complete with submarine-themed decor, enhances the unique dining experience. It’s a place where fun meets flavor.

Since its founding, Submarine House has been known for its hearty portions and friendly service, making it a local favorite.

Capriotti’s Sandwich Shop – Dover, Delaware

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop - Dover, Delaware
© Capriotti’s Sandwich Shop

In Dover, Capriotti’s continues to impress with their enormous subs filled with turkey, roast beef, and vibrant toppings. The modern yet relaxed vibe of the shop makes it an appealing stop.

The dedication to quality ingredients and inventive combinations sets them apart from the rest.

Founded in 1976, Capriotti’s has become synonymous with creativity and taste. Their reputation for excellence continues to grow.

Mancini’s Italian Deli – Lewiston, Maine

Mancini's Italian Deli - Lewiston, Maine
© Mancini’s Italian Deli

Mancini’s Italian Deli in Lewiston is a nod to old-world charm, offering hefty Italian subs that transport you back in time. Each sandwich is packed with authentic meats and cheeses.

The deli’s inviting ambiance and dedication to tradition make it a standout in Maine. It’s a place where flavors tell a story.

Since opening, Mancini’s has become a beloved institution, celebrated for its commitment to quality and hospitality. It’s a true delight for any visitor.

Clinchfield Sub Station – Erwin, Tennessee

Clinchfield Sub Station - Erwin, Tennessee
© Clinchfield Sub Station

Clinchfield Sub Station in Erwin embraces its railroad history with hearty subs that pack a punch. The large sandwiches are overflowing with meats and cheeses that offer a taste of Tennessee.

The rustic decor and themed atmosphere add to the charm, making it a memorable dining experience.

Since opening, Clinchfield has been celebrated for its generous portions and unique setting. It’s a destination for anyone seeking flavor and local culture.

Leunig’s Petit Bijou – Burlington, Vermont

Leunig's Petit Bijou - Burlington, Vermont
© Leunig’s Petit Bijou

Leunig’s Petit Bijou in Burlington offers a chic, European-inspired dining experience. Their gourmet subs are crafted with artisanal ingredients that elevate the traditional sandwich.

The elegant setting and refined flavors make it a favorite among those seeking sophistication and taste.

Known for its dedication to quality, Leunig’s continues to impress with its innovative approach to classic dishes. It’s a Burlington gem that’s not to be missed.

Firehouse Subs Oldfield Crossing – Jacksonville, Florida

Firehouse Subs Oldfield Crossing - Jacksonville, Florida
© Firehouse Subs Oldfield Crossing

Firehouse Subs in Jacksonville offers a lively, firefighter-themed experience with subs that are anything but ordinary. The large sandwiches are filled with a variety of meats and toppings.

The vibrant decor and community focus add to the appeal, making it a favorite for families and foodies alike.

Founded by firefighters, Firehouse Subs is known for quality and philanthropy. Their dedication to taste and service shines through in every bite.

Milio’s Sandwiches – Madison, Wisconsin

Milio's Sandwiches - Madison, Wisconsin
© Milio’s Sandwiches

Milio’s in Madison serves up giant subs with a commitment to quality and freshness. The sandwiches are filled with layers of meats and cheeses, offering a satisfying meal.

The modern, laid-back atmosphere makes it a great spot for a casual lunch or dinner. It’s a place where taste and convenience meet.

With a focus on fresh ingredients and friendly service, Milio’s has become a beloved part of the community. It’s a must-try for sub enthusiasts.

Sub Station II – Lexington, South Carolina

Sub Station II - Lexington, South Carolina
© Sub Station II

Sub Station II in Lexington offers classic subs with a local touch. The large sandwiches are filled with a mix of meats and fresh vegetables, promising a hearty meal.

The friendly, local vibe makes it a welcoming spot for both regulars and newcomers. It’s a place where quality and community come together.

Founded decades ago, Sub Station II has built a reputation for its generous portions and flavorful offerings. It’s a staple in South Carolina.

Fat Tommy’s Grill & Sports Bar – Crestwood, Illinois

Fat Tommy's Grill & Sports Bar - Crestwood, Illinois
© Fat Tommy’s Grill & Sports Bar

Fat Tommy’s in Crestwood offers a lively sports bar atmosphere with subs that are big on flavor. The massive sandwiches are loaded with meats and cheeses, making them a fan favorite.

The casual, upbeat setting is perfect for enjoying a game and a great meal. It’s a place where fun and flavor meet.

Known for its hearty portions and vibrant energy, Fat Tommy’s continues to delight visitors with its bold offerings. It’s a great spot for any sports fan.

Little Brown Hen Cafe – Florence, Oregon

Little Brown Hen Cafe - Florence, Oregon
© Little Brown Hen Cafe

Little Brown Hen Cafe in Florence offers a rustic charm with subs that highlight fresh, local ingredients. The large sandwiches are thoughtfully crafted, offering a taste of Oregon.

The charming setting and commitment to quality make it a standout destination for food lovers. Each bite tells a story of local flavors.

Known for its dedication to community and quality, Little Brown Hen Cafe provides a unique dining experience. It’s a must-visit for anyone exploring the area.

Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe – Columbia, Missouri

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Columbia, Missouri
© Pickleman’s Gourmet Cafe

Pickleman’s in Columbia offers a trendy, casual dining experience with sandwiches that don’t hold back on flavor. Their massive subs are filled with fresh meats and tangy pickles.

The cafe’s lively atmosphere and friendly service make it a popular spot for both locals and visitors.

Known for their innovative menu, Pickleman’s has become a standout in Missouri. Each visit promises a unique taste adventure.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *