Explore six iconic pizza counters in New Jersey where folding your slice is not just a tradition, but a necessity. These eateries offer a slice of heaven that embodies the spirit of classic East Coast pizza culture.
Valentino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant – Lake Hiawatha, New Jersey
Valentino’s Pizzeria is where tradition meets taste. Nestled in Lake Hiawatha, it offers an authentic slice of New Jersey’s pizza heritage. The generous toppings and gooey cheese are designed for that satisfying fold.
With its family-friendly vibe, Valentino’s is perfect for pizza lovers of all ages. The friendly staff and rustic decor enhance the dining experience. Each visit feels like a warm embrace from an old friend.
Did you know? Valentino’s has been serving the community for over 30 years, a true local gem.
TrendingNow
Tony D’s – Caldwell, New Jersey
Tony D’s in Caldwell is a haven for pizza connoisseurs. Known for its artisanal approach, this eatery serves slices that are crisp on the outside and soft inside. Perfect for folding, the slices are an explosion of flavor.
The contemporary setting is inviting, making it a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. The open kitchen offers a glimpse into the pizza-making process, adding to the experience.
Quirky Fact: Tony D’s is celebrated for its unique dough recipe, a guarded family secret.
Patsy’s Tavern & Restaurant – Paterson, New Jersey
Patsy’s Tavern is a slice of history in Paterson. Established decades ago, it continues to serve pizza that tastes like nostalgia. The inviting ambiance and vintage decor make it a must-visit.
The pizza, with its perfect balance of sauce and cheese, is ideal for folding. It’s more than a meal; it’s an experience. Regulars often share stories of childhood visits, a testament to its enduring appeal.
Interesting Tidbit: Patsy’s Tavern once hosted a local celebrity pizza-eating contest, a beloved tradition.
Angelina’s Tavern – South Plainfield, New Jersey
Angelina’s Tavern in South Plainfield is where flavor meets fun. Known for its vibrant atmosphere, it offers slices that are meant for folding and savoring. Each bite is a testament to quality and care.
The lively decor and friendly staff make every visit enjoyable. It’s a place where laughter and pizza go hand in hand, creating unforgettable memories.
Fun Fact: Angelina’s is famous for its themed pizza nights, drawing crowds from all over the region.
La Sicilia – Belleville, New Jersey
In Belleville, La Sicilia offers a taste of authentic Italian pizza. This cozy nook delights with slices that are perfect for folding, capturing the essence of traditional pizza making.
The warm, inviting atmosphere is complemented by attentive service, making guests feel at home. It’s a beloved spot for both quiet meals and lively gatherings.
Did you know? La Sicilia imports its cheese directly from Italy, ensuring an authentic taste in every bite.
Joe’s Rotisseria – Roselle Park, New Jersey
At Joe’s Rotisseria, the pizza experience is nothing short of theatrical. As you walk in, the enticing aroma of freshly baked pizza welcomes you. Known for its signature rotating oven, this spot offers perfectly crisp slices.
The real magic happens when you fold a slice, letting the flavors meld together. The bustling atmosphere adds to the charm, making every visit memorable. Whether it’s a quick lunch or a family dinner, Joe’s Rotisseria delivers slices that demand to be folded.
Fun Fact: Joe’s is famed for its unique specialty pizzas, including the popular Triple Threat.
Discussion about this post