Illinois is home to some of the most delightful pie diners, renowned for serving slices so generous, they’re meant for sharing—though most won’t dare. Here are seven standout spots where the pies are legendary, and the slices are simply irresistible.
Urban Farmhouse Eatery & Pie Company – Highland
In a rustic setting that feels like a warm embrace, Urban Farmhouse Eatery & Pie Company is a haven for pie lovers in Highland. Known for their colossal slices, their fruity creations are a feast for both the eyes and the palate.
Each pie is crafted with locally sourced ingredients, ensuring the freshest taste in every bite. Regulars rave about the perfectly balanced sweetness and the flaky crust that practically melts in your mouth.
The charming atmosphere, combined with friendly service, makes it a favorite gathering spot for locals seeking a taste of home.
Traditional Sullivan Bakery – Sullivan
Traditional Sullivan Bakery has been a beloved institution in Sullivan for decades. With a reputation for serving pies that are as big as the stories behind them, this bakery is a slice of heaven.
Bakers here have mastered the art of crafting pies that are rich in flavor and nostalgia. The aroma of freshly baked goods greets you as soon as you step inside.
Many patrons have fond memories of their first pie experience here, making it a cherished part of the community’s culinary heritage.
The Village Bakery – Oregon
Nestled in the heart of Oregon, The Village Bakery is a delightful stop for pie enthusiasts seeking hearty slices. The bakery offers an inviting atmosphere, reminiscent of simpler times.
Their pies, known for their generous portions, are crafted with passion and precision. Each slice is a testament to the bakery’s commitment to quality and tradition.
Locals often recommend the cherry pie, boasting a perfectly tart filling encased in a golden, flaky crust. The Village Bakery is truly a community treasure.
Myrtle’s Pie Shop – Princeton
Myrtle’s Pie Shop in Princeton is where culinary art and comfort food meet. This establishment has become synonymous with indulgent pie slices that are anything but ordinary.
The secret to their success lies in their creative flavors and attention to detail. Each pie is made with love, and it shows in the taste and presentation.
A visit to Myrtle’s isn’t complete without trying their renowned pecan pie, which has a loyal following among locals and visitors alike. It’s a slice of bliss with every bite.
Big Apple Family Restaurant – Annawan
Big Apple Family Restaurant in Annawan is a place where family traditions and delicious pies go hand in hand. Known for their epic slices, this spot is a slice lover’s dream.
The restaurant’s inviting vibe and hearty menu make it a popular choice for families and pie aficionados. Each pie is a masterpiece, created with passion and precision.
Their apple pie, in particular, is legendary, with a filling that balances sweetness and spice, and a crust that’s just the right amount of flaky. It’s a must-try for anyone passing through.
Blue Springs Cafe – Highland
Blue Springs Cafe in Highland is a pie lover’s paradise, renowned for its huge slices that defy expectations. This charming cafe captures the heart with its homestyle cooking and friendly atmosphere.
Their pies are lovingly made, featuring traditional flavors that evoke a sense of nostalgia. The generous portions are perfect for sharing, though most prefer to keep them to themselves.
The banana cream pie is a standout favorite, with its luscious filling and perfectly crumbly crust. Blue Springs Cafe is a must-visit for pie enthusiasts.
Seasons Gastropub – Byron
Seasons Gastropub in Byron offers a contemporary take on classic pies, with slices so immense they’re practically a meal in themselves. This trendy spot combines modern dining with comfort food classics.
Each pie is a creative endeavor, blending unique ingredients to create unforgettable flavors. The emphasis on quality and innovation is clear in every slice.
Their chocolate silk pie is particularly popular, with a rich, velvety filling that’s pure indulgence. Seasons Gastropub is a delightful fusion of old-world charm and new-age culinary flair.