Ohio is home to some of the best-kept secrets when it comes to dessert counters. These pie havens offer flavors and experiences that locals treasure and newcomers should relish, though they’re often kept quietly under wraps.
Der Dutchman – Walnut Creek, Ohio
Nestled in the heart of Amish country, Der Dutchman is a treasure trove of culinary delights. Their pies are renowned for their buttery, flaky crusts and rich fillings that speak of tradition.
Patrons rave about the classic apple pie, a heartwarming slice of Americana. With its quaint setting and warm hospitality, a visit feels like stepping back in time.
The ambiance, filled with the aroma of baking, invites you to linger and savor every bite. This spot is a beloved gem among locals.
TrendingNow
Peanut Shoppe of Akron – Akron, Ohio
At the Peanut Shoppe of Akron, pies share the spotlight with nuts and candies. The shop’s peanut butter pie is a creamy delight that captures hearts.
Rich and smooth, this pie embodies the shop’s legacy of quality and flavor. Stepping inside feels like entering a sweet wonderland.
With its charming, old-school atmosphere, this spot is a cherished slice of Akron history.
Hartville Kitchen Restaurant & Bakery – Hartville, Ohio
Hartville Kitchen is where comfort food meets bakery excellence. Their pies are as comforting as the restaurant’s hearty meals.
The fresh strawberry pie is a burst of summer in every bite. The bright, inviting setting welcomes families and pie enthusiasts alike.
This beloved spot has cultivated a loyal following, offering a slice of home with every visit.
Kafe Kerouac – Columbus, Ohio
Kafe Kerouac is a haven for the creative soul, offering not just coffee but pies that inspire. Unique flavors like chai spice pie captivate visitors.
The café’s eclectic décor creates a perfect backdrop for enjoying a slice with a book. It’s a spot where literature and dessert harmonize.
This quirky establishment is cherished by students and artists alike, offering both sustenance and inspiration.
Lindsey’s Bakery – Circleville, Ohio
Lindsey’s Bakery is famous in Circleville, especially for its pumpkin pie, a staple during the town’s annual Pumpkin Show.
The bakery exudes a small-town charm and warmth, making every visit feel like coming home. Their pies are crafted with love and tradition.
Locals swear by this sweet slice of Circleville, where history and flavor blend seamlessly.
Gray House Pies Westlake – Westlake, Ohio
Gray House Pies in Westlake is a modern twist on traditional pie-making. Known for inventive flavors like bourbon pecan, it captures imaginations.
The sleek, minimalist design of the shop contrasts beautifully with the rich, complex flavors of the pies. Seasonal offerings keep the menu exciting.
This contemporary bakery has carved a niche in Westlake, attracting pie lovers with an adventurous palate.
Heggy’s Nut Shop – Canton, Ohio
Heggy’s Nut Shop may sound like a candy store, but its pies are the true stars. Known for nutty confections, their pecan pie is a must-try.
Baked to perfection, each pie boasts a balance of sweet and nutty flavors. The shop’s retro vibe adds a touch of nostalgia.
Locals have long cherished this hidden gem, where each visit is a delicious journey down memory lane.
Discussion about this post